Home / Features / Kindle Quality Control

Kindle Quality Control

I received this email this morning from Amazon:

Dear Publisher,

During a quality assurance review of your title, we have found the following issue(s):

Typo/formatting issues exist that may have been caused by an Optical Character Recognition (OCR) problem. Following are few examples:

*Loc 1969; “kiss on the check” should be “kiss on the cheek”
*Loc 578; “I bum one” should be “I bum one”

At Location – 1924; the word “more” is missing between “even” and “doomed”.

Please look for the same kind of errors throughout and make the necessary corrections to the title before republishing it.

If you have further questions, you may write to us by visiting this page:

https://kdp.amazon.com/self-publishing/contact-us/

Please be sure to reference your ticket number when contacting us.

Best regards,

Amazon KDP

Anyone else receive one of these emails? First time for me. It’s an interesting attempt at quality control – and actually helpful, as it caught some typos I didn’t catch. Though replacing “bum one” with “bum one” isn’t very helpful.

Optical Character Recognition is normally used to convert printed books into ebooks, but the kindle bot is becoming a kind of editor – and will only get better. What it is not doing is saying: we will remove this from the store until you correct this error. So the quality control is voluntarily. More than likely, Amazon is using this software to spot duplicate spam books, which are becoming a problem. Will Amazon start deleting these books right away?  It would make sense if they did, though this poses potential problems.  As is the case with the Google algorithm, sometimes a spam blog can rank higher than the source of the original content.  So some authors could get hurt by this.  If Amazon had an efficient system for reinstating legitimate books, this seems like a necessary evil.

All said, I’m glad that Amazon didn’t remove my book from the site because of a few typos, but if it spots 100 legitimate typos, would it then be OK?  Should people be free to publish whatever kind of book they want, even if it’s unreadable?  These books are for sale, so it’s a bit different than, say, someone using a free service like Blogger.  It’s actually in Amazon’s best interest to correct books – if people buy sub-par books over and over again, they may become less willing to part with their money.

Personally, I’m not against unpublishing a book that has 100 or more typos.  This is a nuts and bolts issue – typos only detract from a book and add nothing.  I’m supportive of the First Amendment letting people say whatever they like, but at least put an apostrophe in the right place.  As self-published e-publishing becomes the majority of new books being published, and recognition software gets more advanced, these are important new considerations.

  • http://www.selfpublishingreview.com/members/ronfritsch/ Ron Fritsch

    Henry, I’m glad to hear of your experience with Amazon. (But not, of course, because it found typos in your book!)

    What amazes me is that they bother to check manuscripts with software that picks up a mistake like “kiss on the check.” A character might wish to place a kiss on a check, especially if it were for a large amount, say a celebrity’s advance on his or her ghost-written memoirs. The software must be so advanced that it can decide that within the context of your story you meant “kiss on the cheek.”

    If Amazon uses this software on every book submitted to it, independent authors should be pleased. They should want not just a few examples but a complete list of every typo, or alleged typo, the software finds. Any book can use another edit. If this one is free, all the better. And yet another reason not to bother with the traditional publishers.

  • http://daringnovelist.blogspot.com/ Camille

    I’ve heard speculation that these “quality assurance checks” are really just responses to complaints. If someone sends an email saying “I found these errors….” that can get a book put into to be checked by quality assurance.

    The tricky part is when the errors are not errors.

    • http://www.selfpublishingreview.com/members/henry-baum/ Henry Baum

      Hmmn, that would make it sound like my book’s riddled with typos. It’s not really – I was aware before this of around 5. But maybe there are sticklers out there.

      • http://daringnovelist.blogspot.com/ Camille

        Not necessarily. There are a lot of people who like to appoint themselves as keeper of the flame. They find what they look for.

        However, what I heard was just speculation. You’re only the second person I’ve heard of getting such a letter — but I’ve seen tons of AWFUL books with lots of complaints in the reviews. (And perfectly good books with lots of complaints in the reviews.)

        The speculation was that IF Amazon wanted to crowd source some quality control, the really easy way to do it would be to verify only very specific complaints and then send an automated message like that. General complaints would require more work, and so would be ignored until they reached a certain level.

        The other reason we might be only seeing this rarely is because they are testing different systems for cost and efficiency. In that case, it could have been a real proof reader doing sample tests, or a smart computer looking for likely errors (being vetted by a person), or the smart complaint system like I mentioned above.

        Camille

      • http://www.selfpublishingreview.com/members/ronfritsch/ Ron Fritsch

        Henry, I read your book from end to end, and I don’t remember seeing any typos. There could’ve been five. I’m willing to forgive that many. If it had been riddled with typos, I would’ve told you privately. I don’t remember the kissing of the check. Maybe that’s what I thought you meant. Some of your characters were the kind of people who might do that.

        • http://www.selfpublishingreview.com/members/henry-baum/ Henry Baum

          Thanks, Ron. I posted this letter because I’m confident enough the book’s not a mess. Interesting to know that only a few of these letters have been sent out.

  • http://www.timgreaton.com Tim Greaton

    Henry, I just received a very similar letter for my “The Santa Shop” novel this morning. The errors spotted seem to largely be hyphens carried over from the physical PDF formatting when it was first published, long before ebooks became a reality. We, too, have wondered what prompted our title to be chosen, though 50K free downloads in the last three weeks might be the culprit.

    Thanks for posting :-)

unisom cost without insurance allergy medicine for dogs prednisone zovirax without prescription miami buy generic stromectol with bonus pantoprazole uk nizoral cream side effects side effects of prilosec in babies griseofulvin for sale diflucan billig kaufen glucophage xr generic name cheapest doxycycline hyclate seizure medicine trileptal buy zithromax online mexico no prescription how to use nizoral shampoo for hair loss is naproxen better than motrin generic pyridium safe uk pharmacies online that sell motilium heart attack medication nitroglycerin glucotrol xl ships from india cheap kamagra soft xeloda order in the us generic viagra no prescription australia online canadian pharmacy soma side effects of lavitra propecia side effects nhs zyprexa 20 mg price buy acai berry uk stores zithromax suspension pfizer comprar zyban online what drug category is pyridium acheter un appartement a hammamet yasmine topamax and depakote lawsuit kamagraco keftab prescription coupon aceon best price buy vantin mexican pharmacies purchase diflucan pills pharmacy mexico clomid sominex india best price for naprosyn floxin ear drops dosage compazine pill shortage la sertralina engorda nike air max 1 fb long time side effects clomid is there a generic for nitroglycerin toprol xl over the couter buy atorlip-5 cheap generic equivalent for flonase to buy zantac what is similar to alli in canada generic of allegra prescription how long do clomid side effects last acai no prescription canada generic altace in usa benadryl sale del mercado buy diclofenac suppository online atrovent sublingual dosage take soft viagra tabs aciclovir prices rhinocort from usa buy alphagan canada non persciption zithromax vogel menosan tincture tablets can you get carbozyne overnight pharmacy orlistat prednisone 5mg dosage dogs albendazole through high ventolin pills buy buy zebeta patch where to buy zyrtec free shipping online sale of isoptin best zyban prices cytotec usa crestor generic form buy hong kong compazine pills mg 100 mg effexor xr how to use promethazine pills tadalafil 20mg dosage buy trandate astrailia diovan generic australia buy kamagra 100 micronase new zealand http www best us online pharmacy com aspirin uk next day delivery tetracycline drugs uses viagra sildenafil citrate women ed hardy packs 1xtra live original desyrel online liquid eldepryl review tretinoin .025% buy xenical orlistat pill side effects clomid dosage and timing what are the effects of viagra on women buspar dosage for anxiety what is mestinon drug acheter pas cher moduretic colchicine toxicity dose american himcolin provera without a prescription avapro shortage 2012 alli lowest price uk reviews on unisom sleepgels buy micronase uk can i use viagra with zytenz? buy glucophage with e check generic propranolol for sale on line genuine amantadine without pharmacy drugs similar to flagyl glucophage side effects hair loss female cialis online cheap can you order flonase fluticasone effects current ginseng prices effexor xr from canadian pharmacy lidocaine powder price shipping buy liposafe inhaler canada trental discount voucher seroquel high blood pressure famvir 10 mg cost buy capoten without a script what is female viagra tablets original cialis professional online where do i buy synthroid prograf prix en pharmacie en france cymbalta usage use synthroid coupon online allopurinol new zealand can you still buy xanax online purchase cheap antibiotics bactrim without viramune non perscription countries buy shatavari root provera dose to stop period purchase glucophage pills lexapro for sale uk buy crestor inhaler canada buy arava next day prilosec order on web how to take ginseng tablets fincar pas cher generic pills for probalan over the counter sarafem cheapest finpecia buy diarex pills online buy diamox us discount prescription buy tretinoin 0 025 online Purchase tenormin 50mg cheap abilify 10 canadian pharmacy over the counter medicine femara keftab generic wikipedia drugs lozol generic reviews what does citalopram hbr 20 mg look like cheap lisinopril 20mg no prescription dog antibiotics online cymbalta order on web vasodilan express canada prazosin order what does prednisone treat in dogs arimidex pills side effects doxycycline online europe lisinopril 20 mg coupons fastest delivery of amoxyl buy adalat cc nifedipine can you get beconase aq over the counter how long does lilly fluoxetine take to work where is avapro made compare price viagra cialis what are the side effects of stopping elavil what is combivent inhaler used for free viagras samples propecia medication canada children;s motrin cold medicine ordering low dose unisom buying zanaflex for dogs levitra preise holland why has avodart been discontinued buy lipothin 40 tadacip online australia perche si usa zoloft us pharmacy viagra no prescription liv drugs online purchases prazosin generico italiano cheap mentax sale uk where to buy serevent what is brahmi oil acute quinine poisoning how to get viagra without a doctor in canada can you buy prandin over the counter in germany what is the difference between medrol dose pack and prednisone buy gyne-lotrimin online amazon healthy weight 50 year old man seroquel 100mg for depression dilaudid hydromorphone erowid florida chloromycetin furosemide doctors online fucidin ointment on cold sores prednisolone for sale buy aceon through erbumine high blood billig chloramphenicol online kaufen buy prevacid tablets online amitriptyline to buy on line keppra 750 mg tablet atorlip-20 without a prescription glucophage 500 mg precio mexico buy probalan perth australia generic casodex buy canada differin pharmacies in prescription nexium in canada what is lamisil viagra costa rica zantac prices cvs uroxatral drugstore.com propecia hair loss treatment buy avodart generic forzest tablets uk anacin limited india where goes i buy alli diet pills in canada what is bayer aspirin good for ordering soft generic cialis 40mg no script viagra sublingual mg maximum dosage of ventolin what does saw palmetto do for men buy bupropion india lithium cost per ounce online forum order zyrtec perscription buy online saw palmetto generic online accutane purchase benfotiamine pharmacy dapoxetine priligy side effects how long does it take for the exelon patch to start working generic pulmicort usa pharmacy bristol-myers squibb uk pension how to get a prescription for cialis alli pills to buy buy online no prescription cheap lexapro cheap free shipping aldactone online prilosec generic for what does lioresal look like buy effexor xr from canada ordering caverta here in canada habana pharmacy tampa tricor discount anafranil pharmacies in can you get high off skelaxin 800 performance enhancement drugs in sports essays silagra online coupon code cost of voveran sr without insurance what does premarin treat craigslist glasgow kentucky potatoes not prozac 7 steps pharmacies allegra generic toll buy bentyl new zealand online order medrol dosepak what is naproxen 500 mg for buy alligator clips for hair bows supplies cheap propranolol 100 mg hytrin generic release date shuddha guggulu mg buy subscribe viagra spam cheapest methotrexate in the uk what is the medicine cephalexin for glucophage online generics med india malegra dxt pharmacy prices list lok adalat in india 2009 toradol drug class buy acivir pills 10 ventolin order online avalide doctors online donde puedo comprar acai berry select metformin pharmacy mail order detrol in croatia acheter pas cher midamor phone in order for roxithromycin flagyl drug in germany pharmacy erythromycin canada prescription which uk site to buy florinef discount code for dostinex methotrexate pharmacy error buy dutasteride online no prescription serevent drugstore.com lamictal 40 mg pharmacy blopress lawsuit canada lotensin medication diclofenac sodium and paracetamol best thyroid medication for dogs buy stromectol fast shipping purchase luvox lowest price can taking diovan cause weight gain trust org comprar cialis spain where to buy tenormin online canada levitra professional online uk propecia help hairline purchase generic dapoxetine champix side effects wiki buy zerit boots pharmacy buy zestril bulk where can i buy lopid in canada how to import aterax finasteride on-line pharmacy buy revatio with pharmacy discount probalan online ordering prednisone tablets 20mg (apo) uk buy trazodone without prescription can you get decadron plavix without prescription starting dose of predinosone for ra can i take two cialis 5 mg low cost overnight cialis professional buy phentermine amazon keppra without script safety of cefadroxil in pregnancy vermox with paypal payment cymbalta without prescription free or low cost avalide buy effexor online from canada zofran sale phexin drug schedule zetia 100 review vpxl usa is micardis better than cozaar where can i purchase acai force max 2 mg aripiprazole generic effects of generic effexor xr common side allegra next day delivery buy levlen cheap albendazole australia costco pharmacy evecare price lithium drug oversea can i make voveran flu google stats where are alligators found in the wild azulfidine next day what does hydrochlorothiazide mean long term side effects doxycycline fast viagra super active deleviery plavix with no perscription co micardis side effects what is viagra sublingual pills used for buy celadrin hong kong buy propecia fast shipping atorlip discount hydrea canada head office buy mentat ds syrup visa what is clomid for men buy generic zantac online long time side effects trimox what is cardizem drip used for unisom sleep gels uk long term side effects of cephalexin buy cheap accutane online no prescription sinemet generic release date is there a generic for ceftin online pharmacy no prescription needed singulair proscar drugstore.com buy avodart in uk generic ranitidine syrup order generic viagra super active floxin medication order tadalafil tablets megalis 20 no rx cymbalta online terramycin store what is antabuse effect long term side effects of diovan hct arrested for buying viagra on craigslist can prednisone be bought online can i get hytrin buy medrol fast shipping buy cytoxan without a prescription from canadian pharmacy how to buy amoxicillin with no prescription best place to buy diovan without a prescription cheap living room rugs order actos diabetes l-tryptophan from usa pharmacy cefadroxil tablets 500mg cheap neurontin uk cheap generic pariet kytril generico italiano over counter elavil prescription vytorin 10 40 vente de topamax au quebec buy hoodia mexican pharmacies what is v-gel used for non prescription adalat haldol over counter celadrin pharmacy order generic antabuse pharmacy prescription drug cytoxan buy over the counter brand amoxil online toradol 10mg what types of allopurinol are there discount abana mg fluoxetine dose for cats order meclizine online ibuprofen gel side effects cialis super active australia sildenafil 100mg blueberry 100 fincar online in us digoxin wanted online review generic prednisone names ciprofloxacin generic for cipro cost of omnicef asacol 50mg tablets buspar mg buy haldol sublingual dosage frumil without a perscription new mexico alligator laws can buy starlix online buy brand arimidex fertomid online pharmacy uk clomid nolvadex pct dose differin pharmacy coupon brand cialis generic for stromectol amazon uk cheap amaryllis bulbs uk generic can you drink on amoxicillin 875 mg buy inderal online ipledge accutane isotretinoin what does ventolin do to you buy diclofenac gel with e check why is there a shortage of terramycin integrative medicine alliance ima buy kamagra online australia oral jelly safe place order buspar procardia buy no prescription is mail order dilantin safe can we trust protonix online actoplus met buy on line how to take tetracycline hydrochloride canadian bupropion vendita on line cialis in italia teva tamoxifen 20 mg antivert dose for vertigo what drug category is zyprexa generic flagyl er us aleve d dosage instructions zanaflex vs soma buy ephedraxin mexican pharmacies mifepristone online atorlip-10 limited india unisom mist canada epivir-hbv prices at costco alli for men sale in uk fluconazole side effects in babies buy tretinoin gel china minipress online store can i make himplasia triamterene without prescription miami triamterene generic for cheap tinidazole 500mg order styplon online no prescription with a amex what is montelukast sodium tablets 10mg for clomid uk boots tadapox canadian pharmacy doxycycline hyclate for acne treatment solu medrol price the walking dead nitroglycerin pills cheap hyaluronic acid cream nexium to get high depakote drug class strattera prescriptions order malegra fxt pill colospa comprar generic pills for lamisil generic famvir uk paypal birth control pills singulair xenical low dose birth control desyrel 100mg cheap voveran sr ordering online pharmacy costco pharmacy tadalis sx price order online bonus pills cheap accutane champix wiki fr generic voltaren usa pharmacy ditropan online australia how to get rosuvastatin on line xanax anxiety medicine lithium orotate 100 mg losec mups ingredients stats hell multiple regression xenical over counter canada suprax best online non prescription pharmacy buy aspirin capsules costco milton keynes tyres pariet usa pharmacy recommended dosage of ceftin side effects of alesse birth control pill diflucan cost no insurance colchicine precio mexico amoxicillin 500mg alcohol nhs brand voltaren for sale how to take lariam tablets aciphex 20 medicine genuine kamagra suppliers in uk acheter pas cher zyvox what is the dosage for wellbutrin xl best place to buy antibiotics online doxycycline price where can i buy doxycycline tablets viva blue pill reviews best generic female viagra review