Home / Features / Self-Publishing and Plagiarism – A New Place to Hide?

Self-Publishing and Plagiarism – A New Place to Hide?

Having reviewed as much non-fiction as I have, you are bound to come across those who have “borrowed” other people’s work and not given them credit for it. It doesn’t happen often in traditionally-published works, but it does happen. As a green reviewer early on, I missed one that was a direct rip-off of another authors work. It was embarrassing, to say the least.

Plagiarism happens in many genres of non-fiction. Older material is out of print or in limited issue and someone thinks no one will notice. These titles can be run through software that checks for plagiarism and have been found to not be “properly attributed.” Publishers are spending money on software that specializes in tracing work to identify plagiarized material, because it will cost the publisher heavily in dollars and in reputation if it is discovered they missed a plagiarized work and allowed it to get out on the open market.

My own recent experience with some plagiarized material turned up an author who, when discovered and rejected by a mainstream publishing house, turned to self-publishing their work to circumvent the process. They skimmed off the Internet and produce e-books of gleaned material, and are selling it to the unsuspecting public. And while we can point it out, there isn’t much else we can do.

When the self-publishing firm was made aware that the material was indeed plagiarized, it was removed. But the works reappeared at the same publisher. It probably would continue even if it was mentioned to the publisher again. And, of course, with all the various self-publishers out there, this material could continue in publication regardless of how often it is identified and removed. All the plagiarist does is move on to another self-publisher.

This also happens with fiction. While we can allow that, say, works on vampires will include similar treatment of the vampire to have it fit the description, how about the love scene that is just about word for word from an older work, or from a different work of fiction all together, slapped into the vampire book. Love scenes, plots; oh there is so much that can be gleaned from other well-known authors and then plugged into a fiction e-book and sold on the Internet with no one really checking.

There are some real questions that are going to rise in the self-publishing industry. As these incidents are brought to the surface, and eventually make the front page of the New York Times book section, how is self-publishing going to stand up to accusations of fraud and/or plagiarism? We want this field to open doors for authors who would never have been given a chance to present their work to the public because the publishing houses don’t see enough money in sales or do not have enough funding to publish all the really great books out there. And we have the ultimate question of how is the public going to know if the work is just a rip off of another person’s work?

Reviewers on the Front Lines

The person who is going to be in a position to even get a hint of this is the reviewer. An experienced reviewer in a particular genre will notice a change in writing style within a particular novel. They may be familiar with the various authors within that genre and know their styles and the content of some of the better known authors. It very well may be the reviewer who recognizes a style or a scene or something familiar that will put them onto a possible case of plagiarism.

Having discovered plagiarized work and exposed it in the past, I also know what dishonorable authors (read: con-artists) will do when they have their backs against the wall. Some of them lash out and attack viciously. Others just take the money and run. Someone has to say something, and there is never a “polite” way of saying “the material in this book is copied from other copyrighted sources [insert sources here] and therefore is plagiarized.”

But who do you complain to? What agency will even care? And will it be worth it to the author who has been plagiarized to pursue this? And as a reviewer, do we also become the plagiarism police? It is not something I really want as part of my job description.

What is needed is a service that will check all books issued (notice I said ALL books) and report these plagiarized works. What we also need are self-publishers that will use this service and remove titles that have been so indicated. Where would the funding come from? Well, I would suggest all the publishers involved, including big houses, would also benefit from this. It would probably boil down to pennies per book, but in the long run, it would protect the copyrights of legitimate authors, it would protect both publishers, self-publishers and vendors from issues with plagiarized work, and it would discourage plagiarism and copyright theft. And in the long run, give the public honest work.

I am sure a few services would be able to work in this field, specializing in particular genre, offering services to the industry. A standard could be set as to the percentage of the book that would be allowable to contain similar content. It is possible for us to quote popular ism’s and that will probably show up in many books at a particular time. But the industry could come with some guidelines. While we may not like the concept of regulation, it is always better that we regulate our own than have someone else mandate it for us.

The self-publishing field will suffer if we find it being used as a haven for pushing rehashed and in some instances identical copies of other people’s works. And self-publishing will be treated as “vanity” presses are treated; as a frowned-upon method of fleecing the public with hackneyed authors turning out junk. The legitimate self-published authors will suffer.

Update: Fast Company takes on the problem with plagiarism in erotica self-publishing:

This penchant for plagiarism shouldn’t surprise us. Self-publishing has become the latest vehicle for spammers and content farms, with the sheer volume of self-published books making it difficult, if not impossible, for e-stores like Amazon to vet works before they go on sale. In 2006, 51,000 self-published titles were released; last year there were 133,036 self-published books, and that number is destined to climb. 

Writing a book is hard. All those torturous hours an author has to spend creating, crafting, culling until nonsensical words are transformed into engaging prose. It’s a whole lot easier to copy and paste someone else’s work, slap your name on top, and wait for the money to roll in. This creates a strong economic incentive, with fake authors–Sharazade thinks it’s possible they are organized gangs based in Asia–earning 70% royalty rates on every sale, earning far more than a spammer could with click fraud. The new self-publishing platforms are easy to use and make it possible to publish a title in as little as 24 hours. There’s no vetting, editing, or oversight, and if your work is taken down you can always throw up more titles or simply concoct a new pen name and start over. There’s even a viral ebook generator that comes packed with 149,000 articles that makes it possible to create an ebook in minutes.

Legislation has been proposed that would give content holders more leverage in dealing with etailers: the Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA). It would award copyright holders wide-ranging powers to run websites that host infringing material off the Internet without needing to acquire a court order. If it becomes law credit card companies could be forced to suspend financial transactions, search engines required to de-link ecommerce sites, and DNS providers made to hobble access. It’s the kind of law, well-intentioned as it might be, that could have serious negative repercussions, opponents say. No wonder Amazon, eBay, Facebook, Google, and Yahoo! have reportedly been considering a coordinated protest against it in the form of a blackout day.

There is, I believe, a simpler solution. Why not require an author to submit a valid credit card before she can self-publish her works on the Kindle? If an author, who could still publish under a pen name, were found to have violated someone else’s copyright Amazon could charge that card $2,000 and ban her from selling again. Amazon could also run content through one of the many plagiarism detectors that are available–such as Turnitin or iThenticate–before an ebook is put on sale.

Perhaps, though, Amazon doesn’t care if it sells plagiarized works; it benefits from the sale whether it holds back an author’s royalties or not.

  • http://www.selfpublishingreview.com/members/ronfritsch/ Ron Fritsch

    Boudica, I share your concern that self-publishing might provide cover for plagiarists. But I’m also interested to learn that some people are developing software to sniff them out. After reading your post and thinking about it, I realized that using computers to catch those pathetic individuals shouldn’t be difficult or expensive. The computer would just take any new writing and compare it word for word with everything previously written. (Isn’t Google trying to digitize everything ever written? Maybe we should applaud it, or anybody else who is making that attempt, for doing so.) The standards for possible, probable, and obvious plagiarism shouldn’t be difficult for reasonable people to agree upon. So writers, for a nominal fee, or no fee at all if they agree to their exposure to advertising, can gain a valuable link their prospective readers can click on and receive a respected organization’s certification that the writing they otherwise wish to read is genuinely new. Those of us who write honestly will have nothing to fear.

  • http://peggyireland.blogspot.com/ Peggy Ireland

    Indie editors are often the first line of defence. We usually see a manuscript before anyone else – we are even sent work for polishing before submission to the big 6.

    We are uniquely equipped to pick up signs of plagiarism signalled by a number of diverse writing styles within a document, or parts of a document which require no editing at all.

    Yeah, been there. It’s distressing to have to kick a manuscript back, lose a client and return a deposit, but there is no way any reputable editor wants their name on such a book.

  • http://vickihopkins.com Vicki Hopkins

    I use a website called Grammarly.com. It’s great for not only grammar, but it highlights text that matches anything on the Internet or elsewhere. It also gives you the reference to add, if you need to give credit where credit is due. It’s somewhat helpful.

lisinopril 40 mg pret nolvadex 30mg doxycycline 100mg jerawat ranbaxy generic zithromax cheap natural viagra cialis 20 mg generic 250 mg of zoloft lexapro 20 mg good lexapro generic celexa doxycycline mg chlamydia cheapest zovirax lisinopril 20 mg teva zoloft sertralina angenerico nexium 40 mg panvel levitra generic 40 mg buy zithromax online prednisone order online viagra generic china cheap viagra 100mg cialis 20mg, tablets bactrim de 400mg levitra 20 mg filmtabletta buying prednisone online viagra blue 800mg cialis 5 mg walgreens zoloft 250mg dosage 20mg lexapro lot generic lexapro 5mg diflucan 100 mg 20mg lisinopril high order xenical levitra generic 20 mg cialis cena 5mg levitra 100mg kaufen prednisone generic xenical 120 mg acheter 50 mg clomid iui viagra buy germany levitra 20 mg prijs clomid generic online cialis cheap 5mg lisinopril 5 mg qualitest cialis 10 a 20mg 20 vs 40mg cialis online zovirax order generic for propecia buy cialis 5 mg strattera generic alternative 10mg daily cialis buy diflucan india cialis generic daily xenical generico portugal cialis tadalafil 500 mg buy xenical philippines lisinopril 10 mg appearance online doctor xenical doxycycline 100 mg mylan bactrim 300mg dose viagra 100mg rose is hydrochlorothiazide generic lisinopril 30 mg w953 bactrim 200 40 mg dawkowanie cheap cialis ireland clomid buy cheap skachat propecia 1mg doxycycline generic price cheap generic xenical diflucan 150 mg confezione buy viagra colombia get celebrex online generic viagra price doxycycline 300 mg dogs celebrex 100 mg hartkapseln zovirax tablet 800 mg buy 500 mg doxycycline diflucan 400mg buying nolvadex viagra stocking buying viagra 100 mg doses 4 5 mg cialis 25mg zoloft depression prednisone 20mg day generico cialis andorra phenergan dosage 25 mg order cipro uk buy nolvadex europe cialis online confidential lexapro 5 mg acne xenical 120 mg srbija glucophage 500 mg beneficios celebrex price generic nolvadex 20mg 40mg buy synthroid 100 mcg nexium 40mg programa cheap viagra 25mg cialis 20 mg 8 comprimidos 75 to 100 mg zoloft generic xenical orlistat wellbutrin 150 mg bijsluiter prednisone 40 mg ovulation lexapro escitalopram 10 mg cialis 20mg boite 8 rhoxal cipro 500mg viagra generic date augmentin 400 mg prospect take 2 10 mg levitra pct online nolvadex cheap levitra online cipro xl buy clomid steroid online viagra buy netherlands buying metformin online nexium 40 mg alkohol buy viagra bradenton cheapest viagra overnight cialis buy mastercard gebruiksaanwijzing cialis 20mg generic propecia sandoz cialis online kopen viagra online britain blueberry 100 viagra buy lasix 500mg diuretics wellbutrin sr 100mg cialis 20 mg costi cialis 10 mg cene cheapest legitimate viagra nexium amp. 40 mg lisinopril 40 mg online cialis 20 mg online lexapro 10 mg 20 mg augmentin tablets 375mg propranolol 80 mg overdose bula lexapro 10mg lisinopril 20 mg mylan 800 mg chinese viagra ervaringen clomid 50 mg generic lexapro 5mg lexapro generic new zoloft 25 mg enough augmentin 500 mg antybiotyk 50 mg generic viagra glucophage 1000 mg filmtablet cialis 4cpr 10 mg avis generic cialis metformin hexal 1000 mg 10mg cialis cost lilly cialis mg 10 priligy online pharmacy cialis 5 mg buy thuoc levitra 20mg zithromax 1000 mg iv generic price viagra propranolol 40 mg tablet strattera 100 mg price non generic viagra 2.5 mg lexapro 4 weeks clomid generic vs erythromycin dosage 250 mg zovirax pastillas 200mg starting zoloft 25 mg cialis 2.5 mg prices lexapro review 5mg buy doxycycline 50 cialis 10mg 20mg prednisone 15mg 5ml buy nexium pills take 2 20 mg cialis levitra dispersible 5 mg lisinopril 20 mg fish pfizer viagra 50 mg buy dapoxetine cialis cheap hydrochlorothiazide cheap celebrex prescription generic lexapro alcohol cipro 500 mg kullanimi wellbutrin 100 mg bid buy 100 mg viagra 25mg clomid twins buy propecia wholesale cialis quanti mg xenical generico opinioni buy Cialis 120 Tabs wellbutrin generic compare viagra generic online cialis c50 online cialis da 10 mg viagra 25 vs 50 mg order levitra canada cialis 10 mg controindicazioni levitra online bahrain zovirax online bestellen korean generic viagra lasix 40 mg comprimidos 10 mg levitra prices tabletki xenical 120 mg lisinopril 20 mg online triplets clomid 50mg doxycycline generic image clomid 200 mg pcos doxycycline 100mg ingredients nexium 40 mg 30 tablet viagra buy spain guaranteed generic viagra 10 mg viagra augmentin 500mg 62 5mg buying viagra free valtrex generico bula buying kamagra online 50 or 100 mg clomid cialis prescription online levitra 10 mg dose lexapro 10 mg embarazo buying tijuana viagra buy bactrim generic lexapro 5 mg breastfeeding review cialis 60mg buy levitra pills wellbutrin 150 mg online zoloft greenstone generic buy strattera prescription xenical tablets online buying nolvadex uk kebaikan cialis 20 mg harga propranolol 40 mg dubai generic viagra buying clomid privately generico de cialis ordercialis and viagra propecia finasteride 5 mg augmentin price 500mg doxycycline acne mg preisvergleich cialis 20 mg lexapro 20 mg online 5mg brand cialis levitra schmelztablette 20mg diflucan 2cps 150mg oral doxycycline online mg of prednisone bactrim 1 mg propranolol 10 mg posologia drug generic synthroid buy real levitra nolvadex 10mg tablets cialis viagra generico xenical orlistat 60 mg 250 mg cipro mail order levitra cialis 5 mg pret 45 viagra 100 mg cheap erythromycin 250mg bd synthroid thyroid disorders 20 mg lexapro value walmart generic lexapro 2012 strattera 50 mg brand cialis online lisinopril 5mg generic wellbutrin lawsuit clomid pct buy zoloft 100mg tablet viagra 100 mg paypal zovirax iv 500mg buy lasix tablet nolvadex 20 mg generic dosi cialis 5 mg generic levitra 2.5 strattera buy cheap cialis 50mg tadalafiili buy clomid reviews generic propecia brands furosemida lasix 20 mg xenical nome generico augmentin 400mg lisinopril 10 mg e101 propecia generic argentina levitra purchase online cheapest priligy online prednisone 5mg veterinarian chinesegeneric levitra diflucan 200 mg pret stopping zoloft 25 mg buy levitra odt buy ladies viagra diflucan 100 mg 5 doses buy doxycycline injectable levitra to buy viagra 200mg online cialis 800mg reviews order viagra maryland hydrochlorothiazide triamterene 25 mg generic levitra facts augmentin 1000 mg tab diflucan buy australia prednisone 10mg com buspar 15 mg price propranolol hci 40 mg cheapest valtrex prices 25mg viagra fiyati prospect valtrex 500mg lexapro 5mg used clomid 2 9 100mg pregnant 4 cialis 5mg zithromax online discount buy soft cialis erythromycin 250mg zastosowanie buy viagra cheap cipro 1000 mg levitra 10 mg uso thailand viagra online concor viagra 50 mg kamagra dosage 300 mg viagra order au lasix 250 mg cialis online apotheken costco generic diflucan amoxil online cheap cialis 1800 mg order cipro cheap 5mg cialis zithromax 500 mg opis zoloft generic price generic viagra xlpharmacy levitra online buy buy prednisone uk buy viagra 2.5mg viagra marke 100mg 20mg cialis worth clomid order online prednisone online au prednisone 40 mg jour nexium generic prescription buspar 20mg philippines buy propecia buy clomid 200mg zovirax 10 mg 60 mg prednisone 5 days zithromax online chlamydia prednisone 50 mg po lexapro reviews 10mg clomid nome generico buy viagra eu lexapro five mg doxycycline monohydrate 100mg 2mg of propecia levitra oat 10mg cialis 5mg ultrafarma cialis professional 20 mg. color generic synthroid levitra 10 mg kullananlar viagra generic tesco wellbutrin buy levitra precio 20 mg 40mg branded cialis false cialis 100mg pfizer viagra 150 mg doxycycline buy 2011 opiniones xenical 120 mg propecia generic coupons buy mens viagra pro cialis 20 mg 2.5mg cialis review online viagra bangalore order cialis line buying viagra shops nexium 20 mg prices generic viagra 20 mg levitra tablets online online viagra stores generic levitra reliability viagra da 100mg zithromax online prices generic love viagra prednisone 5mg price cialis 50 mg hf viagra generic advice cialis 20 mg lisboa viagra gold 1000 mg viagra 25mg sildenfil propecia nz buy doxycycline 100mg eyes lisinopril hctz 30 mg real cialis online lasix m 20 mg venta online xenical viagra generic sale generic 5 mg. cialis gen viagra 150 mg prednisone 5mg uses generic lexapro images diflucan 600 mg viagra mexico border prednisone 20 mg for bactrim 600mg walmart 25 mg viagra order viagra paypal viagra 50mg verses propecia to buy buy bactrim iv buygenuine cialis buy kamagra belfast sample generic viagra strattera 100 mg buy lexapro generic brands phenergan im 25 mg cutting 10 mg cialis propecia generic uk xenical online de cialis 20 mg tab doxycycline 200 mg syphilis buy 10 mg lexapro generic brand valtrex zovirax generic valtrex generic celebrex price bactrim forte 800 160mg cialis generico tadalafil cialis generic brands zovirax 200mg tablet fgr viagra generico cialis 20 mg eu generic augmentin sizes american viagra online viagra online greece taking 2 50mg zoloft lexapro 30 mg day levitra 5 mg pret cheap viagra us viagra online erfahrungen wo viagra online erythromycin 40mg valsartan 80 mg hydrochlorothiazide propecia uk order online cialis ordering diflucan 150 mg effetti augmentin tabs 375mg 40 mg cialis dangerous tetracycline 1000 mg 600 mg kamagra cialis generico diflucan 150 mg бra levitra pills online celebrex cap 400 mg walmart viagra 50mg cialis black 500mg two 10mg cialis levitra 10 mg orodispersible online prescriptions cialis generico viagra 100mg generic viagra looks viagra buy montreal cialis 20 mg 4 cialis reviews 5 mg generic viagra ingrediants lisinopril 10mg buy buy viagra california cheapest viagra chemists priligy 60 mg preisvergleich cheaper alternative strattera valtrex there generic generic wellbutrin teva cialis 5mg nasil order lexapro tablets 37.5 mg of zoloft bactrim online uk online cialis costco 25mg generic viagra doxycycline 100mg drinking nexium 20 mg bijsluiter cialis online org 100mg diflucan cialis 400 mg order propecia usa 100mg doxycycline antibiotic lexapro 10 mg cost mail order clomid buy prednisone deltasone levitra 10 mg schmelztablette kamagra 25 mg tablet diflucan 150 mg gravidanza viagra 120 mg pills viagra online funziona cheap viagra missouri buspar buy online viagra online masterrcard pret augmentin 500 mg order cipro canada metformin 500 mg pdf online clinic viagra amoxil 850 mg bula danger levitra 40 mg xenical generic cost lexapro generic ireland levitra 10 mg online lexapro and .5 mg nexium 40mg tiem 1500 mg metformin clomid order cytotec online lisinopril 2.5mg tiredness testimonials generic cialis buy metformin generic generic viagra makers