Home / Book Reviews / Review: 5 Reasons to Leave a Lover: a Novella and Other Short Stories by Carolyn Moncel

Review: 5 Reasons to Leave a Lover: a Novella and Other Short Stories by Carolyn Moncel

In Set Yourself Free Ellery, Ellery Roulet is an American with a career in Paris and she has made an emotionally crushing discovery.  It threatens her marriage to Julien and the life she knows as a mother to twins Evie and Maddie.  The story is told from Ellery’s point of view as well as that of Julien and his lover, Katrine.  Carolyn Moncel presents a compelling story and in fifty pages conveys the hopes and angst of all three.

While Ellery’s struggle is perhaps the most developed, Julien and Katrine weigh their choices with equal depth of feeling.  Moncel is adept at presenting the characters as scoundrels, in the minds of the others, and then conveying each person’s feelings in such a way that it is possible to have sympathy for each, in turn.

Because it is a short work, it is difficult to talk about most aspects of the plot without revealing too much about it.  There is a wonderful scene in which Ellery and Julien’s twin daughters become aware of how upset Ellery is and discuss their fears about their parents’ presumed marital discord.  It is the only part of the book shown through the twins’ point of view, and their perceptions and qualms are very realistic.

There is occasional dialogue in French, and in some books this is presented clumsily.  Not so here.  As one who has been to Paris several times, I could envision the backdrop.  There was little description of either the apartment or the unique environment that is Paris.  Sparse writing can be beautiful, but I was glad to have my own mental pictures so I could “see” the characters in their respective settings.

The novella’s ultimate question is can love survive betrayal?  Moncel shows there is not only no easy answer but there are many ways to consider the question.

The two short stories are Maybe Just Leave, Steve and Maybe in Death, Beth.  Betrayal and loyalty are again themes in Maybe Just Leave, Steve, which is told from Cinnamon’s point of view and show’s Cinnamon’s evolving feelings for Steve’s wife, Leah.  There’s a neat twist at the end.  While I saw it quickly, not all would, and it is handled deftly.

Maybe in Death, Beth shows the rewards of “working it out.”  Herman and Beth, in their mid-nineties, had their relationship struggles early in their life together, but they have made it to the point of not just love but total comfort with one another.

The two short stories are set in Chicago, which was Ellery’s American home, and it is Paris that Leah wants to live in and work in for a time.  The quick mention of “great granddaughter Leah” in Maybe in Death, Beth seems to add another link among the three stories.

I did not count to see whether Moncel actually presents five reasons to leave your lover, but that’s not important.  Set Yourself Free Ellery and its companion short stories provide a pleasant, and provocative, evening read.  I give them five stars.



Barnes & Noble



quinine sulfate for leg cramps side effects leponex tableta dejstvo surutke amantadine hcl sildenafilo sandoz femara side effects letrozole oeder robaxin on line buy online ode des perfume alli cvs price phamacy canana non prescription piroxicam 20 mg and oxycodone rualis 20 cialis generico en chile precose 25 mg kemadrin tablets for sale frumil 5/40 avalide side effects doctor oxybutynin 10 mg cl er omnicef 300 mg capsule ic doxycycline hyclate 100mg neurontin and weight gain atorlip 20 increasing sperm count diet metrotab chattanooga cheap atorvastatin usa pharmacy mexitil side effects microzide hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg side effects what happened to online pharmacys viagra suppliers uk ordering domperidone from canada black market viagra overnite shipping on vigar novolog patient assistance program phone number tryptizol dosage of tylenol viagra for her online pharmacies no prescription 689 buy liquid antibiotics online lasuna garlic jims pizza complaints about healthy man viagra prazosin hcl 5 mg adderall weight loss before and after pictures non perscription flomax where can i get some viagra immy doxycap doxycycline sildenafil schweiz kaufen generic viagra on line order i need prednisone where to purchase pulmicort side effects in children amoxicillan without a prescription no prescription cialis generic cheap buylowdrugs canada post proviron steroid verapamil 240 mg daily buy generic viagra from india vimax and virectin reviews baytril antibiotic dosage for dogs actos 15 mg indian cialis 5mg overnight cialis in us cialis quick delivery uk medameds physician assistant duphalac lactulose solution laxative priceduroval viagra vpxl online canada sala fontana domperidone 10mg tablets buy order yasmin 28 without prescription vicodin overdose symptoms hydrocodone clomid and twins 2005 cialis no prescription canada prednisone without a scrip flunitrazepam buy online india cefalexina english antibioticos buy tizac without prescription thuoc renapril 5mg cialis 357 toronto drug store pharmacy best viagra in india los paratextosparoxetine simplotan tinidazole tablets 500mg mexican pharmacy with no promethazine hcl 6.25 mg does doxycycline have a shelf life viagra advertised on sirius mobicool mini fridge f 15 eagle purchase bactrim ds hyzaar side effects hair loss mincorp mining games cialis best price prednisone 20mg tab belize pharmacy express diamox dosage for prevention of altitude sickness viagra in polen kaufen flexidol relax accion terapeutica homeopatica macrodantin side effects nitrofurantoin mono clenbuterol cycle for women weight loss where is best prices for viagra buying viagra in toronto discount erectile dysfunction drugs binozyt 500 mg bonadoxina medicamento inyectable diamox sequels 500 mg cap sdmd temovate emollient cream pergotime 50mg clomid cheap 20mg nolvedex xanax addiction symptoms benzodiazepine cyclo progynova tablets amiloride hctz name brand kamagra suppliers livial tibolone treatment for pneumonia enalapril maleate for dogs where to buy naproxen buy azithromycin 500 single dose meds online no prescription valium and alcohol interaction condyline podophyllotoxin paint diclofenaco sodico 100mg generika drugstore logo designgetpharma buy cialis in los angeles sustiva and truvada combosynthroid nexium 40 euroclinix opinie aut naproxen 500mg uses side effects primox muscle men swimwear norvasc medication patient assistance viagra tablet information in hindi 100 magnesium supplements during pregnancy abilify medication drug how effective is viagra celexa side effects weight loss wellbutrin weight loss stories hydroxyzine pam viagra from canadian pharmacies caffeine pills walgreens promethazine 25mg over the counter lexpro cheap viagra online the purple pharmacy in algodones mexico vgr 100 contrave weight loss drug acheter viagra lille jasmine mickael jordan bikini percocet withdrawal symptoms and duration cheap painkillers no prescription kamagra price thailand cialis 5 mg generika gupisone prednisolone 5mg tablet warfarin diet list permethrin cream 5 for scabies side effects tadacip cipla india baclofen 10 mg rocaltrol 0 5 mcg to mg micardis plus side effects hydrochlorothiazide oracea coupon 2014 sildegra tablet cases viamax power coffee for male fosamax dosage and administration maxalt mlt side effects cymbalta medication dosage provera period started early buying pills onlinr that take paypal clomiphene citrate for men reviews venlafaxine side effects hair levoxyl recall 2008 vistaril medication classification advantage federal credit union michigan aricept 5mg vs 10mg diltiazem ointment eurax scabies treatment imiquimod 5 slimex online cost of crestor at walmart achat de cialis 5 mg mincorp mining suprax cefixime free sample pack of viagra canada xenical uk buy finasteride 5mg online deltasone 10 mg periostat 20mg and gum disease pharmacy technician training online imovane 7 5mg information now vardenafil hcl securecheckoutz pharmacy cephalexin 250mg capsules side effects cialis kantucky healthy man radio ad ampicillim online there shortage alli discount codes for pharmacy express purchase online terramycin eye ointment for cats lamisil tablets for nail fungus pain killers without prescription what is terramycin ointment for humans cabaser reviews for fifty capoten contraindications for electrical stimulation viagra ohne rezept bestellen prevacid solutab coupon amikacin injection cost carprofen 100 mg cheap robaxin 500mg methocarbamol for dogs robaxin 750 mg pictures esomeprazole 40 mg india silenor doxepin reviewsdoxiacdoxicapdoxine toprol xl 25 mg generictoradol proscar side effects finasteride abdominal fat amiloride hctz side effects cymbalta for anxiety cymbalta and weight gain cabergoline tablets online vagra ofr men pravastatin and grapefruit juice rualis 20 super active viagra generic no prescription suhagraat tips in hindi font cheap cialis extra strength trimetabol syrup brands side effects of levofloxacin 750 mg side effects tylenol dosage for infants based on weight dutasteride canada farmacia online uk best viagra online pharmacy buy cialis in israel viagra buy buy in dubai diazepam for dogs with seizures femara without a percrip progesterone suppositories pregnancy where to buy luvox pills why is alli available claritin reditabs 10mg directions medsindia comcast login cyclivex 200mg progesterone original viagra apotheke clobex shampoo cost order name brand paxil no rx viagra tablets india leconfield house curzon street w1 lergigan miter venlafaxine side effects 37.5 ornidazole and ofloxacin tablets lialda coupon 2013 asacol mesalamine side effects safe black market viagra peritol weight gain pill estradiol valerate tablets magnesium chloride benefits pinamox pinewood paroxetine hydrochloride drug side effects exelon patch treatment for frontotemporal disease buy accutane 20mg online europe canadian sources of cialis usa discount cialis canesoral reviews 50 octreotide infusion doseolanzapine baristanet montclair nj police news bentyl dosage for adults bactrim antibiotic and alcohol cialis for men eyeglasses without prescription clorfenamina compuesta genuine cialis no prescription cabgolin cabergoline dosage floxin ear drops doctor nizoral 2 percent biaxin xl 500mg side effects buying seroxat on line ordering cytotec from uk sifrol pramipexole flexidol relax efectos del buy zoloft on line viagra buy houston how to use cytotec for abortion buy tadalafil 20 mg from india cipro with out script metformin online usa no prescription rythmol manufacturer olanzapine side effects long term nebivolol 5mg reviews yasminelle tabletki get viagra without seeing a doctor generic cialis paypal amantadine hcl 100mg tab kemadrin vs mirapexin paroxetine side effects drugs viagraonline pharmacy soft viagra erectalis 20mg adderall cialis made in india generic cialis 100 mg can you get high off indomethacin vicodin overdose treatment baclofen on line pharmacy flonase vs nasonex symptoms can lasix help with aspiration can you buy nexium over the counter naproxen vs ibuprofen for inflammation can you buy viagra on line viagra shopping spain ditropan for children zocor side effects simvastatin patients non prescription synthroid viagra fast delivery uk is ordering xanax on ipharmacy legit periactin sold in uk pharmacy haloperidol drug schedule angela women gingseng tinidazole treatment and alcohol allegra printing and imaging levitra 20 mg reviews estrace cream treatment kamagra on sale canadian pharmacy tampa brand named viagra for sale online espn viagara doxycycline side effects rash t plavix femara success stories for infertility can you buy viagra in boots cialis safe order epogen information administration where has 365 pharmacy gone wellbutrin and alcohol side effects vitamix coupon code 2012 what is quinine sulfate side effects stilnox 10mg sleep zolpidem medication buy cialis online in usa xenical philippines advertisement dicyclomine side effects rest el bohio ciales ciales canada pharmacy online review buy clomid made in usa finpecia from india online catafast 50mg trazodone zovirax ointment medication restonite ambien dosage adderall xr dosage information tadalafil discount generic viagra lowest prices health solutions overnight pharmacy sumycin tetracycline stained order metformin without prescription arcoxia 90mg caps buy citalaprom online no prescription salzarex vardenafil and tadalafil ritalin side effects in children gnc viagra substitute bogota colombia sa generic meds 2014 viagra ohne rezept kaufen lipothin 200 fenofibrate capsules rapidtabs reviews on fifty how to use minoxidil 5 for women where to buy cialis online insulin side effects for dogs free sample trial viagra amantadine sulfate cardinal community credit union ashtabula clavupen 100mg to g tantalum carbide powder buy wellbutrin 150mg singapore legal drugs in canada minomycin for dogs inderalici 40 atenolol buy uk zineryt pretzel fosamax 70mg side effects healthman south africahealthymalehealthyman captopril 25mg information 2011 advair coupons $20aggrenox gupisone prednisolone 5 mg usage of water best alternative to viagra biblia mais antiga best price for viagra 100mg prescriptions fast provera 10mg medroxyprogesterone acetate buy diltiazem hydrochloride cream toradol injection medication acyclovir medication dosage for shingles buy periactin online hydrodiuril dosage anything otc like viagra or cialis potassium rich foods list of foods high in potassium soft chew generic viagra 50 mg amatriptyline cheap erectile dysfunction age get 20 viagra polarmeds reviews on garcinia 7 sec pill ditropan xl 10mg proviron impotence dosage kamagra from india doxazosin online lipitor price berifen medicinal peoples coupon code flomist cipla india non prescription cialis reviews compare prices of viagra buy generic viagra paypal biaxin antibiotic 500 mg singulair side effects weight gain can you use keflex for sinus infection vibrox tablets for sale viagra coupon walmart side effects of generic viagra mavidol sl 30 mg codeine lipitor 40 mg catafast 50 mg viagra cialis india pharmacy best viagra available new zealand domperidone buying online cialis cialis special mofur cream ranitidine for infants how long to work pastillas para abortar microgram fentanyl transdermal system patch side effects pregnant celebrities pictures mirtazapine 15 mg proscar to uk without prescription altace ramipril capsules 5mg buy viagra in san diego clotrimazole and betameth cream uses vrdrug reviews apetamin p pills trazodone sleep aid side effects can i order levritra off the internet mesalamine prices accutane 40 mg online buy cheap accutane viagra online cheap cialis farmacia ciprofloxacin sales fucidin hydrocortisone buy antibiotics with out prescription antibiotic minocin side effects euthyrox 50 ug zofran pregnancy risks birth defects acheter cialis belgique is it safe to buy levitra on line z pack antibiotic prices cialis daily 5 mg detrol la medications generic viagra forum cefaclor drug class discount viagra from canada harga amoxicillin spiriva side effects capsule zofran price sublingual phenergan side effects pregnancy canada medicines prescription drugs robaxin side effects buy albuterol diane sawyer plastic surgery homemade pheromones to attract men can cialis fail viagra einzeln kaufen prednisone sale online viagra kaufen in hamburg overnight cheap levitra contrave diet pill reviews prodotto 87 potensmedel cialis ranigast ulotka real customer care lexapro without prescription cytotec ramipril capsules color sildenafil citrate 100mg pills soft pills fludrex uses fast acting viagra ornidazole injection sites ramipril capsules colorsranacid buy doxycycline on line irbesartan aprovel 150 mg cialis kaufen ohne kreditkarte amoxicillin dosage for adults no perscription generic robaxin medrol dose pack side effects in elderly abilify side effects in adults amermycin 100mg clomid viagra without a prescirption fanegada colombia earthquake buy actavis promethazine with codeine propecia from worldwide sale garlic clove restaurant evans ga best place to buy medical drugs online expres cialis morphine sulfate er 15mg tablets disgrasil orlistat 120mg cheap doxycycline dosage does generic viagra have a shelf life octreotide treatment acromegaly asthma inhalers online canada canadian propecia doxycycline hyclate order furosemide without prescription in uk provigil 200 mg price at walmart viagra boots depomedrol injection side effects dogs 1489 dr edward b armington luvox generic form toprol xl medication recall prednisolone acetate eye drops 1 birth control without an rx what happens when you take viagra super active