Home / Book Reviews / Review: 5 Reasons to Leave a Lover: a Novella and Other Short Stories by Carolyn Moncel

Review: 5 Reasons to Leave a Lover: a Novella and Other Short Stories by Carolyn Moncel

In Set Yourself Free Ellery, Ellery Roulet is an American with a career in Paris and she has made an emotionally crushing discovery.  It threatens her marriage to Julien and the life she knows as a mother to twins Evie and Maddie.  The story is told from Ellery’s point of view as well as that of Julien and his lover, Katrine.  Carolyn Moncel presents a compelling story and in fifty pages conveys the hopes and angst of all three.

While Ellery’s struggle is perhaps the most developed, Julien and Katrine weigh their choices with equal depth of feeling.  Moncel is adept at presenting the characters as scoundrels, in the minds of the others, and then conveying each person’s feelings in such a way that it is possible to have sympathy for each, in turn.

Because it is a short work, it is difficult to talk about most aspects of the plot without revealing too much about it.  There is a wonderful scene in which Ellery and Julien’s twin daughters become aware of how upset Ellery is and discuss their fears about their parents’ presumed marital discord.  It is the only part of the book shown through the twins’ point of view, and their perceptions and qualms are very realistic.

There is occasional dialogue in French, and in some books this is presented clumsily.  Not so here.  As one who has been to Paris several times, I could envision the backdrop.  There was little description of either the apartment or the unique environment that is Paris.  Sparse writing can be beautiful, but I was glad to have my own mental pictures so I could “see” the characters in their respective settings.

The novella’s ultimate question is can love survive betrayal?  Moncel shows there is not only no easy answer but there are many ways to consider the question.

The two short stories are Maybe Just Leave, Steve and Maybe in Death, Beth.  Betrayal and loyalty are again themes in Maybe Just Leave, Steve, which is told from Cinnamon’s point of view and show’s Cinnamon’s evolving feelings for Steve’s wife, Leah.  There’s a neat twist at the end.  While I saw it quickly, not all would, and it is handled deftly.

Maybe in Death, Beth shows the rewards of “working it out.”  Herman and Beth, in their mid-nineties, had their relationship struggles early in their life together, but they have made it to the point of not just love but total comfort with one another.

The two short stories are set in Chicago, which was Ellery’s American home, and it is Paris that Leah wants to live in and work in for a time.  The quick mention of “great granddaughter Leah” in Maybe in Death, Beth seems to add another link among the three stories.

I did not count to see whether Moncel actually presents five reasons to leave your lover, but that’s not important.  Set Yourself Free Ellery and its companion short stories provide a pleasant, and provocative, evening read.  I give them five stars.



Barnes & Noble



2.5 mg cialis reviews 20 mg of propranolol venta xenical online buying cialis sydney buy strattera adhd medicinale generico viagra buy xenical aus cialis 20 mg comprimidos order canadian cialis generic propranolol er viagra information 25mg viagra order pills clomid dose 25 mg xenical 120mg turkey xenical drug buy 50c generic viagra taking lexapro 20mg buy nexium medication kamagra generic cialis lexapro 15 mg reviews viagra 100 mg dosis viagra donne online levitra pills 10mg lisinopril 2.5 mg prices viagra online brisbane mailorder cialis cheap cialis daily generic wellbutrin xl 450 10 mg brand levitra cialis 10 mg erfahrungsberichte buy 50 mg clomid clomid dosage 150mg prednisone 10 mg usage wellbutrin 150 mg dosage generic kamagra 100mg wholesale viagra buyer buy 5 mg prednisone indian viagra 50mg online viagra order online generic cialis lexapro 2.5 mg dose generic lisinopril safe buy cialis philippines doxycycline buy india buying colombian viagra generic wellbutrin pharmacy npr wellbutrin generic buspar 15 mg dosage buying diflucan online doxycycline 500mg use cipro 500mg india 800 mg viagra zovirax 800 mg tablet buy viagra trusted generic viagra availablity amoxil 875 mg dosage nexium packets 10mg nexium 40mg 14 comprimidos mg viagra 325lb xenical 120 mg gelule 84 40 mg sublingual cialis cialis 5 mg comprar half 20mg levitra lisinopril ct 10 mg gen viagra 150 mg exist cialis generic lisinopril 20 mg uk cialis soft cheap cipro 500mg buy generic levitra ranbaxy cialis online worldwide buy propecia 12 months buy cheapest propecia viagra bijsluiter 100mg buy clomid legal medicamento nexium 10 mg cheap viagra thread nexium 60 mg prescription levitra 20 mg tesco buy viagra viagra india online lisinopril 10 mg pink cipro 500mg bid cheapest generic propecia levitra 20 mg prezzo lexapro 10mg ejaculation nexium 40 mg nebenwirkungen nolvadex 60mg foros cialis generico cialis generic ranbaxy viagra 25 mg nebenwirkungen nexium 40 mg eksi synthroid 0.1mg co online clinic cialis metformin 850 mg tablets indikasi celebrex 100 mg malaysian order viagra generic viagra trusted free online cialis 10mg lexapro reviews koop kamagra online clomid malaysia online cialis 50mg shop hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg dosage kamagra tablets 100mg lexapro 5mg weightloss online women viagra vrai cialis 20mg teva doxycycline 100mg woman generic viagra order propecia bosley generic research viagra nolvadex buy uk diflucan 100 mg iv buy nexium uk viagra condom online tablete nexium 20 mg doxycycline 20 mg teva online viagra perscriptions levitra generico orosolubile celebrex mg ireland viagra online metformin 1500 mg daily acheter cytotec online doxycycline 100mg online mexico generic viagra viagra 25 mg costo buy priligy 30mg buy cialis us zithromax buy generic lisinopril 40 mg manufacturer 0.5mg propecia eod diflucan capsules 150mg 5mg cialis daily cialis 10 mg experience nexium goi 10mg 05 mg cialis viagra online american buy valtrex walgreens generic viagra nz generic viagra phillipines diflucan philippines buy amoxil online strattera 15mg online drugs viagra buy levitra strips 25 vs 50 mg zoloft clomid 150mg bfp generic viagra walmart zoloft 100mg pill buy viagra shipping viagra 100mg de cheap levitra australia levitra cheap uk generico viagra curitiba cialis 20 mg tb nexium 20mg price lisinopril 20 mg wheezing hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg tb cialis 2,5mg price cialis tadalafil 10 mg metformin 500 mg brand prednisone taper 50 mg buying lisinopril walgreens generic levitra bactrim online buy propecia generico ecuador generic viagra box cialis 10 mg halbieren cialis 5 mg ulotka buy diflucan overnight cialis 5 mg funziona buy wellbutrin generic buy overseas viagra cialis everyday online synthroid 112 mg generic doxycycline 50 mg zoloft 50 mg nebenwirkungen wellbutrin generic hives viagra generic lozenge viagra prescription buy cheapest lasix online cheap cialis information 25 mgs of cialis celebrex 10 mg online viagra test sheep cialis 20mg amoxil online cats generic strattera uk cialis online accessrx viagra generica farmacias doxycycline 200 mg prednisone generic deltasone prednisone 20mg direction 20mg strattera overdose viagra 50 mg packungsbeilage vendo generico viagra viagra online kolkata lexapro dosage 70 mg cialis 20 mg works generic viagra facts cialis 10 mg. cost 50mg zoloft pregnancy triamterene hydrochlorothiazide 50 25 mg order brand zithromax buy amoxil online diflucan 100 mg pret generic propecia 2013 buy levitra 1.84 generic telmisartan hydrochlorothiazide lisinopril 20 mg online generic options nexium medicijn nexium 40mg preisvergleich levitra 20 mg 12 propecia 1 mg costco prednisone 80 mg dosage 50 mg zoloft reviews zoloft 0.25 mg cialis de 05mg prednisone arrow 5 mg zithromax trockensaft 1200 mg prednisone galepharm 20 mg buy propecia brazil lisinopril 10 mg sale generic viagra opinie taper prednisone 50mg levitra tablet 60 mg viagra pil 100mg order lisinopril online propranolol 20 mg pliva celebrex 200 mg posologia prednisone 15 mg dosage cialis 100 mg 20mg buying real nolvadex viagra online prescription augmentin vs generic metformin 500 mg biverkningar hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg watson generic valtrex alcohol nolvadex 20 mg buy viagra fiyatlari 100 mg cheapest cialis Washington glucophage 500 mg posologie lexapro 20 mg wikipedia nexium pediatrico 10 mg liquid nolvadex online strattera 25mg reviews viagra online istanbul cialis 5 mg wirkungsdauer buy lasix 500mg online cialis ankara cytotec 200mg prospecto women viagra 500mg 60 mg of cialis generic levitra name cipro tabs online buy prednisone pet canada cialis 2.5 mg buy clomid legally orlistat cheap xenical prospecto cialis 40 mg lisinopril 20 mg infarmed depression wellbutrin generic prednisone 10 mg pill viagra online rating stopping 50 mg zoloft 100mg clomid unprescribed zovirax tablets generic 100mg viagra street strattera mg dosage buy xenical philippines cipro brand generic clomid twins 50mg nexium 40 mg online prednisone dog mg pricing lisinopril 20mg order bactrim overnight online cialis tadalafil levitra 20mg tab buy astrazeneca nolvadex lexapro 5 mg tired cheap viagra lavitra soft cialis online reliable cheap viagra nexium 20mg pret buying cialis bangkok levitra 10mg jenapharm xenical buying doxycycline injection 100mg 50 mg viagra generic nexium 40 mg india xenical 120 mg tomar buy cheap zithromax viagra online rpsgb nexium 40 mg prospecto 300 mg viagra ivax lisinopril 40mg buying levitra mexico steroids nolvadex buy cialis farmacie online lexapro xl 1000 mg online consultation propecia viagra cheaper valtrex generic coupon doxycycline 100mg medomycin viagra online nachnahme cialis 80 mgr glucophage 1000 mg dosis generic viagra usps levitra 20mg rezeptfrei buy clomid 200mg levitra online sicuro prized viagra online candida diflucan 100 mg canada generic strattera lexapro 20 mg snort levitra 20 mg bestellen online pharmacy viagra generic name erythromycin lexapro 10 mg 14 comprimidos 5mg lexapro stopping metformin 850 mg dose diflucan epocrates online buy clomid 500mg generic metformin canada generic viagra delhi cipro online australia lisinopril 20 mg generico buy clomid medicine lek propranolol 10 mg generic propecia 1 mg buying doxycycline 100mg buy strattera atomoxetine clomid 100mg days 3 7 augmentin generico australia cheapest viagra 100 canadian celebrex online clomid 50mg aventis tadalafil cialis 5 mg cialis 20 mg information generic viagra betrouwbaar levitra 20 mg. gebrauchsanweisung cialis 5mg instead cialis prodaja online kamagra 100 mg wikipedia ordering nexium strattera online advertisements cialis compresse 5 mg purchase xenical 60mg cialis coupon 10 mg viagra 100mg fta 12 lisinopril 40 mg dizziness valtrex 1500mg day cialis cost 5 mg roche xenical 120 mg asda generic viagra 2.5 milligram generic cialis vidal prednisone 5mg glucophage 500 mg prospect generic synthroid cost viagra plus buy amoxil order online levitra 5 mg prezzi buy viagra bpay cialis 20 mg pret cialis 5mg 1 box cheapest online zovirax generic viagra cos viagra sydney buy dominican generic viagra generic levitra tablets buy levitra web cialis italia online cheapest wellbutrin online viagra 100mg online buy zithromax iv propranolol sdz 10mg apcalis generic viagra levitra buy generic cialis pills buy propranolol 40mg ansiedade xenical 42 cap 120 mg cheap lexapro order zovirax 200mg bula cialis liquid buy buy propecia shops lisinopril 30 mg use metformin denk 850 mg levitra generic discount priligy generico mexico celebrex become generic buy metformin tablets periactin comp 4 mg doxycycline 500mg buying generic cialis 10 mg cialis 35 mg metformin 500 mg 142 prezzi levitra 5 mg xenical 120 mg 42 caps viagra 25 mg dauer doxycycline 40 mg generic cialis 20mg wiki generics for celebrex augmentin 625 mg breastfeeding buy bayers levitra viagra online indiano bactrim ds 50 mg generic viagra patent lexapro 10 mg uso 15 mg lexapro equivalent buy propecia ireland buy clomid nolvadex levitra online philippines zithromax 250 mg beipackzettel nexium inj 40 mg lasix 100 mg generic viagra rosebud 20 mg cialis online zoloft and 25mg generic lexapro ingredients wellbutrin 750mg lisinopril 2.5 mg coupon cipro 500 mg tablet buy 10 mg cialis viagra online jersey generic lexapro alternative xenical 300 mg viagra buy manila viagra 100mg at. propranolol 40 mg used prednisone for cheap celebrex mims online safe generic levitra generic propecia shedding doxycycline 20 mg vet tlilly cialis 100 mg cialis 100mg preis viagra generico teuto generic india viagra buy nolvadex hcg glucophage 1000 mg overdose cheapest levitra vardenafil indicazioni diflucan 150 mg buy cheap valtrex amoxil bencard 500mg generic uk viagra cheapest lexapro online zoloft depersonalization disorder viagra buy thailand erfahrung cialis 10mg buy viagra humboldt cialis 10 mg 2013 celebrex 20 mg viagra online 24 hr two 20mg cialis generic vs levitra propecia cheap drugs lexapro alternatives generics cipro 500 mg ciprofloxacino generic cialis online kamagra pille 100mg generic wellbutrin sr 150 buy cialis batam cialis professional ordering cap.xenical 120mg levitra generic lasix 40 mg iv wellbutrin 300 mg libido propecia orders metformin 500mg sr generic levitra 20mg cialis 5 mg o 10 propecia 1mg less cheapest kamagra now clomid 5mg buy propecia women cialis price 5mg buy viagra suppositoria cialis online pharmacy valtrex 4000 mg cipro 500 mg sistit 80 mg nolvadex metformin 25 mg generic viagra brazil lexapro mg nexium online buy generic cialis height propecia cost 5mg doxycycline malaria 100mg generic viagra 50 viagra mg 200 lisinopril 20 mg eon purchase Levitra 10mg levitra tab 20 mg cytotec 50mg levitra 10mg sklep ordinare cialis generico cialis 10 mg etkisi buy liquid propecia cipro 500 mg endikasyonu