Review: Death And Other Taxes by Robby Miller

Because he died before his time, the teen protagonist of this wildly imaginative fantasy/sci-fi novel ends up in the special part of the afterlife reserved for lost things. He is meant to wait there until his proper time to die. Wit, as he is called in the afterlife, finds himself sharing this peculiar sort of purgatory with all manner of lost things—not just children. Buttons, socks, religion (“people are losing their religion all the time, right?”) and more turn up there as well. Wit, however, is unwilling to accept that he is dead and immediately sets about trying to find a way back to his life. His adventures along the way make for an unusual picaresque fantasy that is at times sweetly amusing and at other times deeply disturbing. This book seemed to me like The Hitchhikers Guide To The Galaxy meets Dante. If that combo makes you faintly queasy, well, don’t say I didn’t tell you.

As you might expect from Wit’s name, the book is filled with puns and wordplay, and twisty little jokes that veer from groaningly obvious to bits that I almost missed, sometimes getting the pun or punch line a half step behind the beat.

These aren’t just one-off jokes; the wordplay is often extended, setting up an entire section or theme. Here is an example, not nearly the most clever, but one that is relatively easy to excerpt:

Term-Mights on the other hand wouldn’t bite you if you were

not wood.”

“Um, it’s termites,” corrected Wit.

“Not in a democracy,” re-corrected Thera.

“They are the power behind the throne balanced around you but they

are only here for a term; they might or might not achieve anything

in that time depending on the poles.”

“You mean polls?” Wit asked hesitantly.

“No, the Beast Pole or the Waste Pole. You’ve

come in through the Waste because the Fun rises in the Beast. To

put it another way, people are losing power all the time, it turns

them into beasts; others are wasting power all the time, lights

left on in closed rooms must illuminate something. So, like either

end of a magnet, both powers parley here and it energises the

Term-Mights to produce something that either power alone couldn’t

achieve by itself: cooperation.

Hanging in with passages like this is both worthwhile and necessary if you want to follow the action. Miller obviously has a great time with words and meanings, but uses wordplay in a rather serious way as well.

Occasionally the narrative is hard to follow, falling just short of a stream-of-consciousness style, and the relentless wordplay gets tedious fairly quickly. Nonetheless this is a powerful book. On no account should the reader let all this punning and silliness lull him or her into the sense that this is a lighthearted story. Miller keeps you off-footed by mixing a sort of childlike storytelling—including many references to fairy tales and nursery rhymes—with extremely adult themes, not limited to premature death. Many of the characters speak with an openness and innocence that would not seem out of place in The Hundred Acre Wood. Yet after establishing an almost nursery-rhyme cadence and silliness, Miller drops in deep observations about war, child abuse, inequality, and a great deal of social, political, historical, and economic commentary. But the heart of the book is an exploration of the contours of grief, particularly grief over the deaths of children. As the author puns in an afterword, Death And Other Taxes is a “grave allegory.”

This e-book includes frequent links to websites that explain or elaborate on scientific points that come up in the book. For example, you can pop over directly from the text to a website about termites to find out the facts behind the Term-Mights. In one place, readers are directed to a Wikipedia site giving statistics on teen pregnancy, in another, to an academic paper on the biology of eunuchs. The simple inclusion of these links, independent of their content, is fascinating on a thematic level. The story is wildly fantastical, yet these links provide frequent reminders of the real, hard-core world of modern science, as if to reassure the reader that stories of an afterlife are only imaginative means of coping with grief, lest the reader mistake them for some kind of reality. Even though I found the links bothersome in the extreme, I do think that being jerked out of the story and back to the “real” world from time to time somehow reinforced the theme of this book. Joan Didion wrote that “We tell ourselves stories in order to live.” Miller is telling himself, and us, stories to help us deal with death. As Wit eventually comes to accept and understand his death, the reader comes to accept the deaths of us all.


Barnes & Noble