Home / Member Blog / What’s The Writer’s Job? Recording Or Creating?

What’s The Writer’s Job? Recording Or Creating?

zoltaiI’m venturing into dangerous territory with the title of this post…

Let me clarify the exact bit of territory I want to defend.

First, when I ask if the writer’s job is recording or creating, certain easy and obvious answers come up:

* Journalists mostly record, though they can do it creatively.
* Essayists and article writers can slide back and forth between recording and creating.
* Fiction writers create, though there may be a bit of recording in some of their work.

In this post, I’m only going to talk about fiction writers and the specific territory I want to defend is this:

Even if a fiction writer uses real life settings, or even, at times, real life people in their work, they should always have the creation dial set at max and the recording dial turned way down.

Some of you might consider that last sentence as being too obvious to need any discussion.

Some of you might want to start an argument with me.

I’ll address my defense to the people who want to argue. The rest of you might wonder what the heck there is to argue about. Fiction is creation, and that’s that. Well…

Some fiction writers feel that their job is to record life; maybe do it with some creativity, but capturing what exists and rendering it is their prime function. I, almost violently, disagree.

I’ll include a link here to an article on Naturalistic Literature but not as any sort of proof of what I want to say. It’s merely to give you an example of the worst type of fiction writer–not necessarily worst as far as how they use words (they may be quite literary) but worst because of what their writing says about humanity.

Naturalistic literature gives what some folks might say is a true picture of the human condition, an almost scientific recording of the plight of certain people. Well, even a highly creative fiction writer might include a rather reportorial rendition of someone in their work; but, if they are true creators, they’ll find a way to infuse what may be sordid or terrifying conditions with a sense of underlying hope or faith. Let me try a short, and simplistic, example:

Take a character who’s a day laborer, beats his wife and children, and discovers he has terminal cancer.

The naturalist would merely record the conditions and have the character die off. The reader would receive no more value than if they actually knew such a person and stood by and watched the man come home every day, beat his wife and kids, then die of cancer.

The creative writer could take the same character and use their circumstances to show any number of human principles that could raise the man’s actions and death to a level that could inspire the reader–possibly to help abused women and children, or investigate the relationship between anger and cancer, or at least serve as moral food for thought.

My firm belief is that fiction’s proper purpose is to help humanity raise its sights, improve its situation, and strengthen its resolve to make life really matter…

I’m not trying to advocate some sort of sterile, moralistic fiction. We still need a damn good read and we don’t need a book telling us how to live our lives. Still… Showing the reader that even the worst conditions can hold some promise for improvement, even if the characters fail miserably to attain that promise, is, to me, a job that fiction writers should always be working to master.

Would you want read a book in which the characters always fail at life?

Would you like to read a story that had a few characters who failed but you still had your feelings affected in a way that helped you, in your own life, to understand or heal or help?

O.K. That’s as far as I can take my foray into this dangerous territory; at least, in this post…

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Follow the “co-author” of Notes from An Alien, Sena Quaren:
On Facebook
On Twitter
Buy on Amazon

  • http://jim-murdoch.blogspot.co.uk/ Jim Murdoch

    I think once you accept that what happens in books at best can be described as ‘realistic’ you have your answer here. All writing is fiction. Even with the very best of intentions you fictionalise, you take real life events and try to find words to match them. No words can express how I felt when my parents died. We actually say that in so many words as if the expression “No words can express how I feel” somehow articulates how we feel. Words are so inadequate and yet they’re also wonderful because the lies on the page when brought in contact with the ideal reader produce something we like to think of as truth. It really is amazing how that happens.

    As regards failure all I can do is point you to the writings of Samuel Beckett. I don’t think he wrote a single character that succeeded at anything other than failing: “Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better.” (Worstward Ho). Granted he’s the exception rather than the rule but I’m not a huge fan of the happy ending—hated with a vengeance what they did with Blade Runner—because they’re either not true to life or they story’s been cut short and if we just hung around for another few chapters we’d see what really happened.

    Writing to my mind should be all about meaning. It doesn’t have to be cheery and optimistic. It can present the bleakest of futures (e.g. The Road) but we don’t have to go there. The characters on the page are our proxies. They get to experience these possible futures for us so that we can (hopefully) learn from than and not go down that path.

tomei viagra generico generic levitra tablets lasix 500 mg romania wellbutrin generic works cheapest cialis 5mg generic cialis, 40mg cialis becoming generic cheap dubai viagra 10 or 20 mg lexapro wellbutrin generic images buy 12.5 mg lasix viagra as generic levitra 5mg purchase cipro 100 mg im 100 mg lisinopril viagra generico venta prices viagra 100mg buy synthroid cheap augmentin de 125 mg glucophage generic name bactrim forte 920 mg 40 mg lasix iv buy bactrim overnight bactrim mg uti 100 mg viagra no viagra sildenafil 50 mg lexapro 5mg au cipro 500mg online augmentin 750mg nedir online medicines cialis lexapro panic disorder generic zovirax available generic levitra buy take 50mg cialis cialis buy mastercard 15 mg cialis review take cialis 10mg citalopram generic philippines doxycycline online mastercard buy cipro xl buy amoxil online kamagra 100mg info prednisone 20 mg bronchitis phenergan 25mg cost 50mg zoloft zoloft 6.25mg 200 mg cialis safe site cheap viagra buy doxycycline canada cialis 2.5 mg canada order zovirax ointment propecia online shopping 5 mg propecia descriptions bactrim adultes 400mg will lexapro generic levitra 20mg canadian 60 mg buspar bali viagra buy buy zovirax injection generic viagra american xenical 120 mg sale teva generic zoloft kegunaan nexium 40 mg 75 mg clomid kamagra online schweiz levitra 40 mg viagra 600 mg metformin pcos mg buying celebrex mexico generic viagra coupons cheap viagra pharma cialis generic express cialis generic manufacturer clomid success 150mg spain kamagra online lexapro de 20mg nolvadex online paypal cipro 500 mg po viagra 25 mg hinta is 80mg cialis propecia generic buy propranolol 10 mg bijwerkingen aventis phenergan 10mg 100mg of doxycycline hmgr metformin zovirax online kaufen cialis com 5 mg clomid 100mg day 4 zithromax 500mg preis generic nexium when levitra generic viagra kamagra 50 mg viagra bestellen online buying viagra cvs order diflucan pill buy diflucan powder wellbutrin mg dosage precio viagra generico prednisone pack 4 mg buy valtrex europe cheap kamagra caverject 20 mg levitra 20 strattera order cialis online express rate generic viagra genuine cialis online wellbutrin xr 75 mg generic levitra generisk cialis 20mg viagra generico mercadolivre lisinopril 2.5mg tablets 100mg viagra professional zithromax 500 mg 7 days diflucan 250 mg tadalafil dapoxetine online generic purchase viagra viagra 100 mg reimport asda generic viagra levitra 20mg used nexium dr40mg 300 mg lexapro overdose wellbutrin generic global generic viagra instructions online philippines viagra nolvadex order online ten cheapest viagra viagra 100 mg kaufen take 2 100 mg viagra cialis 5mg journalier lexapro generic withdraws lexapro 5 mg shaky doxycycline 100mg tabs 50 mg lexapro ocd levitra generico 5 mg lasix 40 mg iv pfizer buys nexium buy ayurvedic viagra cialis 5 mg take 2 buy 36 hour cialis lisinopril 5 mg bijsluiter levitra 180 pills online buy roche xenical generic viagra international buy bactrim cream cipro uti 500 mg overnight generic viagra generic viagra help kamagra viagra cheap much generic wellbutrin nexium sachet 10mg cipro xr 500 mg viagra online jersey buy 40mg cialis prednisone 2 mg pack propecia generic form bactrim online buy cialis 30 mg paypal trouble viagra online order metformin uk generic viagra busts buspar 10mg information reichen 50 mg viagra viagra 100 mg lasts metformin 500 mg image nexium generic image strattera 18 mg price buying viagra london existe xenical generico generic zoloft fatigue doxycycline 100mg medomycin preisvergleich cialis 5mg cialis generic e20 10 mg prednisone acne lisinopril generic identification viagra generico lima propecia generic buy viagra 150 mg dosage buy viagra manchester generic levitra review buy brand zoloft qual viagra generico doxycycline 100mg eyes viagra 25 mg dauer paxil generic prozac lisinopril hctz 25 mg legit generic viagra cheap viagra alternative buy viagra 50 mg cialis best buy buying viagra pattaya 2011 clomid days 3 7 50mg phenergan seizure disorder buying viagra holland 200 mg zoloft alcohol zithromax 250 mg chlamydia strattera kopen online doxycycline mono generic buy 10 mg cialis propranolol 40 mg gador buy viagra user nexium 20mg rezeptfrei levitra de 40 mg cialis buy nz metformin hcl 750 mg viagra 50 mg fiyati levitra not workimg buy nolvadex 10mg lisinopril 10 mg used cialis 5o mg 500 mg zithromax chlamydia 200 mg cytotec generic cialis review kamagra polo online xenical generico opinioni cheapest daily cialis buy viagra dc valtrex 500 mg 10 tb buy cialis mississauga generico de cialis viagra sildenafil 25 mg 380 mg gold viagra zovirax 200 mg harga splitable generic viagra amoxil dosage 250 mg buy augmentin 875 mg lisinopril 10 mg medication augmentin 400 mg fiyat cipro 5oo mg cheap valtrex 1000mg purchase viagra 150mg 25 mgs of cialis preco amoxil 875 mg viagra generico bonifico 200 mg generic viagra buy real priligy prednisone tablets 20mg buying cialis london viagra vegetal 200mg taking 200 mg viagra indian viagra 50mg cialis online contrassegno buy prednisone mastercard cialis diario 2 5 mg cialis generic 40 mg cialis tabletta 20 mg cheapest cialis 10mg viagra 100 mg 100 pills cipro 1000 mg yanetkileri buy nolvadex uk medicine lexapro 10mg viagra tab 100mg propecia finasteride cheap nolvadex generic drug propranolol 15mg augmentin 1 mg prezzo zoloft 25 mg vidal viagra generico postepay online buy viagra buy tescos viagra buyin viagra online lump nolvadex 40mg prednisone 20mg tabs lasix nome generico generic viagra box 1784 viagra cheap uk cialis 20 mg tb diflucan tablets 150 mg buy clomid tabs glucophage 250 mg 15 20 mg lexapro cialis 20mg efeitos prinivil lisinopril 10 mg doxycycline hydrochloride 100 online cialis generic cheapest lexapro online pharmacies buy 80mg strattera walmart zithromax generic buy cialis softtabs celebrex generic version cialis generico br generic viagra comparison tescos online viagra 25mg viagra fiyati propecia generic when cipro 500mg generic xenical 120mg europe nexium 10 mg copii metformin mgs nexium 40 mg manufacturer buy doxycycline internet cialis 5 mg 28 tbl viagra goes generic buy augmentin tablets tesco buy viagra 10 tablets 20 mg levitra viagra mg chart 1000 mg of valtrex generic clomid work viagra jakarta online cialis 5 mg duracion buy Cialis sachets levitra dose 5 mg synthroid thyroid disorders diflucan dosage 150 mg diflucan generic walgreens lisinopril 10 mg pink 40 mg of nexium doxycycline 75mg 200mg viagra india acheter cialis 10 mg doxycycline 20mg withdrawal lexapro 5mg zithromax trockensaft 1200 mg lisinopril cinfa 5 mg viagra to order propranolol de 40 mg buy cialis 121doc viagra cheap pattaya online viagra source augmentin 250 mg dose generic viagra caps 100mg viagra street merrick generic propecia order viagra spain buspar 5mg comprar australia generic viagra canine 40mg prednisone buy zovirax canada mg bactrim ds order cipro california difference cialis 5mg cheap lexapro seroquel xenical buy xenical malaysian cialis 50mg cialis brand generic price valtrex 500mg 800 mg viagra generico del lasix erythromycin 333 mg kamagra apotheke online augmentin sciroppo 140 mg kamagra 100mg australia lexapro 10 mg valor viagra 10 mg cost levitra 20 mg bestellen metformin 500 mg pdf valtrex 500 mg daily 600 mg of wellbutrin generic viagra europa celebrex 200 mg namecommunity celebrex 200mg capsulas cialis tienda online propecia 5 mg fiyat levitra generic manufacturer cialis 20mg effect viagra generic viagra viagra sample 50mg cialis for order propecia 4mg discount nexium online prednisone 20 mg sciatica valtrex tab 500mg 50 mg prednisone withdrawal costo levitra 5 mg lupin lisinopril 5mg buying doxycycline online prezzo celebrex 200 mg kamagra buy line metformin 850 mg tid a amoxil 500 mg 25 mg of strattera tapering prednisone 3 mg cialis everyday online zithromax 500 mg dosis buy nolvadex london generic cialis 5 mg augmentin 625 generic name generic viagra imprint cialis 5mg cheapest shop cialis 5mg prednisone burst 200 mg prednisone 7.5 mg doxycycline posologie 20mg generic zoloft images cialis besy buy ert generic viagra viagra online prescription glucophage for cheap xenical generico prezzo price cialis 80 mg priligy 60 mg uk generic name amoxil cheap women viagra prednisone 40 mgs amoxil bd 400 mg wellbutrin online uk augmentin 400 mg dosage generic strattera 80 mg online pharmacy dapoxetine buy propecia paypal prednisone teva 5 mg nexium packets 10mg clomiphene generic clomid purchase viagra generic reliable online cialis buy levitra 5 mg 4 original viagra 100mg manila generic cialis augmentin 375 mg used buy nexium medication lexapro nombre generico propecia 5mg prices clomid 150mg twins celebrex 200 mg coupon lexapro generic buy diflucan 10 cps 100 mg strattera 80mg price lisinopril order online prednisone 5 mg tablets viagra discount buy buying cialis 20 mg clomid 150 mg zwanger buy zithromax cvs strattera 60 mg online buy 30 mg prednisone generic viagra europe cheapest viagra singapore buy astrazeneca nolvadex cialis 2.5 mg order doxycycline 100mg indonesia buy priligy safe lexapro 20mg canada xenical 120 mg funciona lisinopril 10mg buy buy cipro singles generic synthroid dosage buy viagra where generic black viagra nexium 10 mg pret levitra 10mg dauer generic lisinopril cost synthroid 100mg augmentin 4000 mg day metformin 850 mg tablets generic propecia reviews 2011 cialis 30 day 5mg online kamagra sales buy nexium ireland buy lasix medication diflucan 150 mg breastfeeding online prescription diflucan farmaci generici levitra zovirax cream mg generic valtrex wiki lexapro vs generics buy levitra chennai prednisone 20mg cancer viagra direct buy generic 100 mg viagra buspar dosage 10mg prednisone 5mg acne order viagra canadian viagra 200 mg generic cialis softtab celebrex 400 mg dosage buy tamoxifen nolvadex generic levitra legitimate viagra 50 mg 4 st celebrex dosage 600 mg levitra 10 mg generico girl viagra buy viagra 150 mg notizte nolvadex 20 mg astrazeneca doxycycline 500 mg dose fabricante cialis generico buy 2 gram zithromax hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg tab zithromax 500 mg azithromycin clomid twins 50 mg 2011 kamagra tablets 100mg buy daily cialis 500mg glucophage propecia 1mg london buy 150mg viagra apo propranolol 80 mg levitra tab 20 mg propranolol 10 mg tabs lexapro canada generic lisinopril 40 mg india cialis cena 5 mg. cheapest generic levitra buy amoxil uk bactrim 240 mg nexium 40mg generico prednisone cost 20mg wellbutrin generic online viagra dokter online metformin buy online buying viagra ireland cialis cheap generic