Home / Member Blog / What’s The Writer’s Job? Recording Or Creating?

What’s The Writer’s Job? Recording Or Creating?

zoltaiI’m venturing into dangerous territory with the title of this post…

Let me clarify the exact bit of territory I want to defend.

First, when I ask if the writer’s job is recording or creating, certain easy and obvious answers come up:

* Journalists mostly record, though they can do it creatively.
* Essayists and article writers can slide back and forth between recording and creating.
* Fiction writers create, though there may be a bit of recording in some of their work.

In this post, I’m only going to talk about fiction writers and the specific territory I want to defend is this:

Even if a fiction writer uses real life settings, or even, at times, real life people in their work, they should always have the creation dial set at max and the recording dial turned way down.

Some of you might consider that last sentence as being too obvious to need any discussion.

Some of you might want to start an argument with me.

I’ll address my defense to the people who want to argue. The rest of you might wonder what the heck there is to argue about. Fiction is creation, and that’s that. Well…

Some fiction writers feel that their job is to record life; maybe do it with some creativity, but capturing what exists and rendering it is their prime function. I, almost violently, disagree.

I’ll include a link here to an article on Naturalistic Literature but not as any sort of proof of what I want to say. It’s merely to give you an example of the worst type of fiction writer–not necessarily worst as far as how they use words (they may be quite literary) but worst because of what their writing says about humanity.

Naturalistic literature gives what some folks might say is a true picture of the human condition, an almost scientific recording of the plight of certain people. Well, even a highly creative fiction writer might include a rather reportorial rendition of someone in their work; but, if they are true creators, they’ll find a way to infuse what may be sordid or terrifying conditions with a sense of underlying hope or faith. Let me try a short, and simplistic, example:

Take a character who’s a day laborer, beats his wife and children, and discovers he has terminal cancer.

The naturalist would merely record the conditions and have the character die off. The reader would receive no more value than if they actually knew such a person and stood by and watched the man come home every day, beat his wife and kids, then die of cancer.

The creative writer could take the same character and use their circumstances to show any number of human principles that could raise the man’s actions and death to a level that could inspire the reader–possibly to help abused women and children, or investigate the relationship between anger and cancer, or at least serve as moral food for thought.

My firm belief is that fiction’s proper purpose is to help humanity raise its sights, improve its situation, and strengthen its resolve to make life really matter…

I’m not trying to advocate some sort of sterile, moralistic fiction. We still need a damn good read and we don’t need a book telling us how to live our lives. Still… Showing the reader that even the worst conditions can hold some promise for improvement, even if the characters fail miserably to attain that promise, is, to me, a job that fiction writers should always be working to master.

Would you want read a book in which the characters always fail at life?

Would you like to read a story that had a few characters who failed but you still had your feelings affected in a way that helped you, in your own life, to understand or heal or help?

O.K. That’s as far as I can take my foray into this dangerous territory; at least, in this post…

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Follow the “co-author” of Notes from An Alien, Sena Quaren:
On Facebook
On Twitter
Buy on Amazon

  • http://jim-murdoch.blogspot.co.uk/ Jim Murdoch

    I think once you accept that what happens in books at best can be described as ‘realistic’ you have your answer here. All writing is fiction. Even with the very best of intentions you fictionalise, you take real life events and try to find words to match them. No words can express how I felt when my parents died. We actually say that in so many words as if the expression “No words can express how I feel” somehow articulates how we feel. Words are so inadequate and yet they’re also wonderful because the lies on the page when brought in contact with the ideal reader produce something we like to think of as truth. It really is amazing how that happens.

    As regards failure all I can do is point you to the writings of Samuel Beckett. I don’t think he wrote a single character that succeeded at anything other than failing: “Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better.” (Worstward Ho). Granted he’s the exception rather than the rule but I’m not a huge fan of the happy ending—hated with a vengeance what they did with Blade Runner—because they’re either not true to life or they story’s been cut short and if we just hung around for another few chapters we’d see what really happened.

    Writing to my mind should be all about meaning. It doesn’t have to be cheery and optimistic. It can present the bleakest of futures (e.g. The Road) but we don’t have to go there. The characters on the page are our proxies. They get to experience these possible futures for us so that we can (hopefully) learn from than and not go down that path.

avedox fcebokcom esquina carlos gardel tango show buenos aires sinequanone hong kong stores online viagra commercial girl canadian pharmacy en espanol hydroxyzine hcl 10mg tablet proscar without prescription sifrol pramipexole treatment for boils search http ontariovolleyballchampio cvs viagra price adderall withdrawal symptoms in baby aprovel irbesartan 300mg prozax canada indapamide side effects lozola names female viagra cefamor 250 new emojis flovent hfa 220 mcg inhaler phenergan india cefadroxil 500 mg for bronchitis cialis best price fast delivery paroxetine side effects drugs coversyl 8mg cheapest caverta online buy toradol injection online obagi tretinoin cream 0 1 best price metformin and alcohol consumption risk effexor canada lasixs medicine manufacturer caverta 100mg tablets cipro antibiotic treatment drugs angela womens ginseng epharmacy online timer non prescription tadalafil cheaper version clarisonic brush nimesulide tablets ingredients nolvadex pct effects dalacin c for acne zoot z pack bag amerimedrx complaints viagra samples for women promethazine hcl injection estrofem for transitioning hair lamotrigine medication guide serpina pill forum venta on line la viagra mas barata esomeprazole 40 mg india lasix furosemide side effects erectalis 20 mg prednisone www online generic kamagra trental 400mg budesonide nebulizer side effects ropinirole hcl 1mg abilify weight gain drug betanoid syrup denver buy amitriptylin with no prescription yasmine yousaf instagram non prescription viagra for sale flonase over the counter alternative optimmune eye ointment for dogs adderall withdrawal amphetamines best antibiotic for uti generic lipitor australia valtrex wholesale amoxicillin to buy online uk levlen 28 levonorgestrel cheap doxycycline no prescription best viagra without prescription primox tablets at walmart naprosyn side effects doctor what is duloxetine hcl dr 60 mg cap used for inhouse drugstore usa sertraline hcl 100mg zoloft medameds viagra alternative escitalopram side effects treatment reputable online pharmacies canada myambutol adverse reactions to anesthesia celexa without a script in aruba manly 100mg review tadalafil generic best price buy alli online usa zanaflex side effects tizanidine medomycin antibiotics for tooth diazepam 2mg information amoxicillin and clavulanate potassium dosage where to buy izoniazide drug like viagra but no prescription safeway pres refills black market viagra india sildenafil citrate female viagra cheapest albendazole online generic synthroid for sale secure online pharmacy levitra dosages buy thyroxine erectile dysfunction age suhagraat ka tariqa lumigan eye drops for sale bevispas side effects tamsulosin online betamethasone ointment 0 05 solaraze diclofenac sodium side effects onadron damla o benicar hct 40 12.5 mg allegra printing waltham ma cost of mebendazole voltaren 75mg for toothache depakote toxicity symptoms levitra vs cialis vs viagra cost 1 viagra buy in austria phentermine diet pills for sale amsa fast 120mg terramicina pomada para ojos eprex dose in dialysis patients doqi kidney shipping viagra in 3 8 days pheromones for men to attract men lesofat vs xenical online does viagera help women clomiphene citrate 50mg side effects for men vardenafil hcl 20 mg drug side effects viagra online 100 mg diflucan italiano ibuprofen for dogs with arthritis sildenafil manly stendra online purchase xenical international purchases ed drugs supplies lisinopril hctz 10 12.5mg floxin otic viagra soft tabs ospamox 1000mg pret alli buy canada buy clomid online in the united states ramipril side effects cough pfizer blue pill vgr 100 buy floxin atrovent inhaler prescribing information protonix generic medication mercury drug order online cheap generic cialis in uk donormyl blue 50mg cash on delivery drug store avelox side effects medications condyline podophyllotoxin paint zovirax acyclovir online kamagra canadian how much should viagra cost at costco colchicine side effects liver centurion labratories pil perancang marvelon cialis generic chepest po box delivery rumafen medicine salzarex pharmacyclics comprar cialis barato mastercard terramycin ophthalmic ointment for newborn babies ranitidine for infants how long to work lamisil side effects liver damage who found good viragra generic mobic mexico buy celexa without prescription lavitra overnight usa vidalta bosques de puerto beprogel lotion applicator celebrex celecoxib side effects what deos xypresy feel like buy synthroid online no prescription metallica one guitar tabs buy cialis one day receipt online pharmacy promethazine codeine lipothin injections for macular need diamox 250mg in middle east oracea 40 mg coupons prandin side effects repaglinide drug wo gibt es viagra ohne rezept medsindia comcast internet cymbalta medication dosage ezetimibe simvastatin buy pravachol generic ortho 777 online without a prescription effexor and weight gain taking can amoxicillin treat chlamydia brandon boyd long hair pregnant mannequin zoloft side effects experienced citolapram no rx cheapest very very cheap viagra seroxat antidepressant doctors pulmicort respules cheap 20mg nolvedex non percription diflucon furosemide 40 mg how to get free viagra samples coumadin side effects warfarin buy levlen online no perscription jasmine waltz and ryan seacrest heathnet viagra zyprexa 0 dollars 63 cent tylenol side effects in infants buying viagra in usa cialis quick delivery on line clozapine drug study rocaltrol 0 5 mcg to mg where to buy hormonin tablets puppies for sale in ohio estrotab 2mg valium risnia syrup dispenser salbutamol guaifenesin ventolin expectorant mesterolone steroid cycles phamacy canana non prescription prdering levitra viagra online estrace side effects sildenafil tablets canada biotech ciprofloxacin 500 subutex withdrawal in newborns canadian pharmacy prednisone cialis professional 20 mg actos plus metformin 15 850 voltaren gel 1 uses benadryl for infants dosage sertralina bula buy generic viagra paypal ranitidine medication generic free cialis trial pack non prescription prozak generic cialis online cheap imigran tablets in usa order risperdal online rhinocort nasal spray price buy pills from canada ranbaxy pharmaceuticals recalls albendazole for dogs and cats famvir for shingles treatment cialis vendita on linea dal canada retin a canada ciales puerto rico pictures san juan purchase ceftin phenergan with codeine abuse where to get cialis online tidilor loratadine wellbutrin and alcohol moduretic drug abuse colchicine medication for gout cialis kaufen ohne kreditkarte furolin nitrofurantoin dosage terramycin antibiotic eye ointment for dogs cialis moneypak insurance institute for highway safety car seat ratings eurax lotion walgreens rimadyl for dogs veterinarian alli weight loss viagra online kaufen europa amerimedrx cialis free risperdal without prescription eastern canada pharmacy for levitra super viagra active disgrasil orlistat precious metals viagra dont work seroquel medication for sleep propecia finasteride tablets cialis gel uk betnovate n cream in usa indocin side effects medication milnacipran for depression marcumar medication identification dicyclomine side effects phenofibrate efectos atorlip 20 singulair allergy medicine diazepam 5mg tablets progesterone cream and weight loss fentanyl transdermal system patch side effects supreme suppliers mumbai india ibuprofen 600mg tablets dosage vira tadalafil capsules amitriptyline ohne rezept bestellen cockapoo rescue in northern california septrin antibiotic suspension online pharmacy calcis betagesic tablets with windows euroclinix hasselt map levitra sweden cuvarlix capsules 120 mg cialis 5mg daily reviews can women take cialis or viagra alendronate sodium 70 mg price buy medicene from india salibet ointment for burns albuterol nebulizer prescription no perscription prednisone original extenze ingredients promethazine in canada nexium vs prilosec effectiveness novaldex india zantac coupons aciclovir dosis medicamento fucidin cream for acne levofloxacin 750 mg for sinus infection cialis non generic online isoptin sr 240 mg caffeine septrin tablets buying sildenafil citrate buy ampicillin no rx risnia md 1 0002 french pharmacy group lidocaine injections for pain onlie pharmacy with echeck atrovent inhaler peanut allergy sotalex tablettablets online drugstore usa proviron side effects mesterolone steroid benicar medication side effects medrol online no prescription propecia sale nizoral cream side effects adalat tv serial cialis en venta propecia hair loss treatment side effects doxazosin medication doctor can a wellbutrin overdose kill you periactin otc cicloferon without prescription crestor prices at walgreens flomax for kidney stones dosage moduretic hydrochlorothiazide phenergan for sale ornidazole and ofloxacin tablets can cialis fail tramol online u k benadryl and zoloft overdose minocin side effects hair loss iraplax orlistat 120mg cheap coversyl plus tablets diazepam information medication otc viagra apoquel buy online canadian pharmacy prednizone mircette without prescription acura viagra celexa withdrawal side effects how long strattera coupons 30 day free trial offer buy revia from india supradol ketorolac english to spanish translation testosterone gel androgel reviews trimetabol usoc buy herbal soma cialis 5 mg costo pinamox amoxicillin insulin pump cases finasteride 5mg proscar alfuzosin uroxatral interactions alli medicina para aselgazar cialis generico en chile zanaflex medication side effects indian viagra tablet names resources for cialis sotalex 80 mg cialis on sale pay pal sustiva side effects efavirenz and pregnancy tadalafil 20 mg sublingual viagara in three days clavupen gutis maximus buy viagra winnipeg sinequanone paris dresses newport gwent viagra online purchase viagra azithromycin over the counter usa cialis phone berifen medicinal antivert medication vertigo pilex tablets review can cialis make you bigger cialis super active 20mg lopressor 25 mg side effects levothroid recall 2015 chevy pravastatin sodium side effects blog famciclovir side effects best drugstore powder order fertility drugs online overseas pharmacy no prescription ciacil tablets for kids pfizer viagra price in india safest cheapest viagra glyprin aspirin vs ibuprofen amoxil dosage for dogs relafen 500 mg almased turbo diet forum levothyroxine synthroid acyclovir 800mg medication canada pharmacy prevacid vs prilosec nexium stanozolol for dogs salbutamol nebulizer dosage donde comprar viagra en usa pillule viagra quebec diltiazem 120 mg and alcohol consumption coumadin side effects coumadin vitamin k foods propecia generico buy 200 mg doryx airol cream arthritis in hands during pregnancy potassium chloride side effects 10 meq provigil 200 mg price valtrex india flovent diskus discontinued canadian retina a no prescription viamedic com vfw store order quickest delivery of viagra to sydney maxalt side effects dose lialda side effects mesalamine dosage safe perscription medication in canada clotrimazole and betamethasone dipropionate lotion metformin online usa no prescription dikloron jellyfish cheap pharmacy forclomid vidalta 10 mg adderall differin 0 3 no prescription virgara winery meclizine medication information tantalum carbide powder xenical weight loss side effects clavamox dosage for kennel cough tofranil pm for sleep imitrex dosage information metrotab chattanooga cipla tadacip eutirox 50 merck mexitil dosage calculations augmentin duo syrup dosage for children acheter viagra pfizer furolin medicine dictionary polarmeds reviews on vigrx myambutol medication identification viagra uk over the counter tadalafil tabs aus malaysia buy lasix online uk provera and pregnancy adderall xr weight loss pilexil capsulas de nopal y lidoderm pain patches drug allergies tadalafil megalis 20 lipothin 200 buy cialis online in usa flexeril 10 mg picture propranolol for migraines side effects cialis strips minomycin dosage calculations domperidone for sale xenical shopping disgrasil orlistat 120mg cheap levitra lowest price generic ed meds indinavir crystals for protection buy viagra in nagpur doxycycline 200 mg viagra canadian check viagra professional a vendre lamisil cream treatment athletes foot confidex pills and potions kamagrafast reviews ivermectin for cats medameds viagra side inderal for migraines reviews asacol 800 hd coupons exelon myhrbenefits mexitil classifications allegra versace feeding tube buy no prescription allegra d meloxicam 7 5 prednisone for poison ivy for sale pharmacies that carry domperidone vendita online intimax100 in italia canadian combivent lamisil pills and alcohol methotrexate online no rx finpecia online verapamil side effects weight loss picareta de diamante minecraft download provigil coupons offers erectile dysfunction medication buy lynarol donde encuentro fluoxetina valtrex for cold sores in nose sibutramine hydrochloride monohydrate medication procalisx reviews for fifty raloxifene vs tamoxifen best price on levitra canada milanuncios escopetas segunda mano 365 pharmacy chlamydia symptoms in women espanol allopurinol drug reactions buspar brand online pharmacy crestor generic hydrocodone cheep trental 400 mg pentoxifylline allopurinol side effects liver pfizer closing stock price today canada drugs online viagra generica barata peru frumil diuretic definition no scrip protonix raymeds complaints against dentists