Home / Features / Is a Self-Publishing Backlash On the Way?

Is a Self-Publishing Backlash On the Way?

It’s been a good run.  2011 was the year when self-publishing broke open with the successes of Amanda Hocking, John Locke, and JA Konrath.  The stigma is gone.  No one thinks a self-published book is bad just because it’s been self-published.  But people are creative – there are some out there who actively want to dislike self-publishing, and will look for reasons to criticize.  There are also plenty of people who still want to believe in the validation of a traditional publisher: if an agent and editor like it, I must be good.  So now the stigma is not: self-published books are bad, but self-published books are hard to sell.

This post is so wrong it’s almost not worth linking to, but it’s an interesting sentiment with a provocative title: Self-Publishing is Over -

I’m not saying self-publishing doesn’t work. The fact that I’m spending my days building a 40′ ocean going catamaran is proof that it does, or at least that it did for me.

I am saying that it takes a very particular sort of person to do it, and that person has to be comfortable with the idea that they’re going to spend upwards of 75% of their time and effort doing things they (probably) regard as secondary to the creative act, and that there’s no (longer) special reward for undertaking the effort. The chances of your work being embraced by the market are not higher than going the tradition route; the return on your investment of time and effort (and in the case of movies, money) is not higher than going the traditional route.

And self-distro is certainly not the (much hyped) solution to the chaos and uncertainty that reigns in music or movies or publishing. It’s simply another route that might work, but probably won’t.

Perhaps with all the hype about self-publishing’s successes, people have gotten the impression that self-publishers think it’s easy to make it rich. But most know that self-publishing is hard.  That doesn’t make it “over,” just…hard.  As is releasing any book.  And the argument’s so old but – traditionally published writers need to do a lot of work they didn’t used to do as well: social marketing, arranging book tours, etc.  All publishing has elements of self-publishing.

That post was responding to another in The Atlantic:

One of the illusions most common to writers — an illusion that may make the long slow slog of writing possible, for many people — is that an enormous audience is out there waiting for the wisdom and delight that I alone can provide, and that the Publishing System is a giant obstacle to my reaching those people. Thus the dream that digital publishing technologies will indeed “disintermediate” — will eliminate that obstacle and connect me directly to what Bugs Bunny calls “me Public.” (See “Bully for Bugs”.) And we have heard just enough unexpected success stories to keep that dream alive.

Well, here’s hoping. But a couple of months ago I decided to dip my toes into these waters: I wrote a longish essay called “Reverting to Type” about my own history as a reader — a kind of personal epilogue to The Pleasures of Reading — and decided to submit it as a Kindle Single. Amazon wasn’t interested, so I decided to publish it myself using Kindle Direct Publishing. I announced its existence to the world: that is, I posted a link on my tumblelog and tweeted about it. A few people downloaded it; some pointed out typos that I had missed, but that a copy editor surely would have caught. I thought about ways to promote it better but haven’t been able to come up with anything other than becoming a self-promoting jerk on Twitter. Last time I checked it had sold 98 copies.

This reflects the narrative that self-publishing can lead to more failure than success. There are likely huge swaths of writers who are now taking self-publishing seriously who may have never before.  They self-publish to the Kindle and – alas, nothing happens.  I can share the frustration.  I can’t claim to be an astounding success either.  But the “new stigma” of self-publishing doesn’t make any more sense than the old one. In the past saying all self-published books are bad is like saying all people with brown hair are bad – seriously, it’s that dumb.  And the new stigma that books won’t sell is also pretty myopic.  We’re just at the beginning: e-readers are just now getting into people’s hands.  Ten years from now, that Kindle single might sell more than 98 copies.

But it is understandable if people are disappointed if they don’t reach readers.  The freedom to publish what you want doesn’t always outweigh the deflation that nobody’s reading it. But that experience doesn’t represent all of self-publishing any more than some terrible novel represents every Kindle book.

The Hype Cycle

There’s a fascinating post on Forbes about The Hype Cycle – the bubble of positive hype that eventually bursts and levels out.  She compares self-publishing to blogging.  In the early days of the blog, there was also talk of astounding successes, but she adds, “Now, only an idiot thinks that they can make it rich by blogging.” Getting rich with self-publishing can happen, but counting on it to happen doesn’t really make a lot of sense, any more than it does with blogging. She continues,

Self-publishing, though, is still in the early stages of the Hype Cycle. The Technological Trigger in this case was Amazon’s Kindle Store which provides anyone with the ability to publish an ebook and gain access, theoretically, to a massive market of avid readers. The explosion in ereaders that people actually want to buy and read on, the expansion into ebook sales by vendors such as Barnes & Noble, and the development of ebook tools have all made the technical side of publishing an ebook almost trivially easy.

And it is this ease that has attracted vast numbers of people to take a punt on becoming an author. The success of edge cases such as Amanda Hocking and John Locke serve only to fuel the hopes of hundreds of thousands of people who want to repeat their success. Writers, like bloggers before them, are throwing themselves at self-publishing with expectations that simply can’t be met by reality. Like gamblers who see someone else getting a massive payout, they think that all they need to do to win is to play the game.

But anyone taking an objective view of self-publishing can see that it shows every sign of reaching the Peak of Inflated Expectations. And that can mean only one thing: Soon it will take that inevitable, unavoidable tumbling slide down into the Trough of Disillusionment. Just because new tools make the technical aspects of something easy doesn’t mean that the creative side of it becomes easy too.

Everything she says is true.  It’s just that self-publishing was so recently the armpit of the publishing world that you could see people quickly falling back into old habits.  A chorus of gloaters saying, “See?  I told you self-publishing was bad!”

This will happen.  However, it won’t stick the same way that the old stigma stuck for decades because e-readers are going to become more entrenched in everyday life.  I’m waiting for the time when Walgreen’s sells e-readers for $15 the way you can find a cheap CD player.  This will also happen. And while it will still be difficult to find readers, so much of publishing will be via ebooks that you won’t be able to blame self-publishing for the shortfall.  It’s just hard to sell books.  If you’re going to blame self-publishing that it’s hard to sell books, you may as well blame traditional publishers as well – because they’re facing the same market.

  • http://onewomanseye.blogspot.com Joanne Tombrakos

    Great post! As a self-published author, I never jumped in because I thought it would be easy. My corporate media background had taught me enough about distribution channels and marketing to know the challenges. But I find it increasingly hilarious how those in the traditional world continue to find 1001 reasons why self-publishing is over when it is just getting started. But that’s what happens when change occurs. The group not part of the change tries desperately to hold on to what was, thinking that will stop the tide.

  • http://www.pigeonweather.com Tom Lichtenberg

    I found The Hype Cycle article interesting, but comparing blogging with self-publishing might be a bit off the mark. Blogging was an entirely new internet creation – you could never have sold your diary-in-progress before, and the money to be made from it is largely in ads and click-throughs – nothing at all like books or the history of bookselling. Nor is self-publishing a monolithic prospect. I think we can already see that certain genres – romance and erotica come to mind – are likely to sell better than others and perhaps even better than they ever did in physical book form, erotica especially! Other types of books are never going to do well in ebook form (coffee table books, for example).

    Also, the overall picture of people jumping in hoping to get-rich-quick and then having that overgrowth die off is natural in any kind of gold-rush scenario – you hardly need a theory like ‘The Hype Cycle’ or some fancy chart to figure that out. Just check out the classic book ‘Extraordinary Popular Delusions and the Madness of Crowds’ (free from Project Gutenberg – http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/24518 ) …

    What’s classic here is the irony of people jumping on the “bash self-publishing’ bandwagon while it still sells magazine articles! Let’s watch that hype cycle hit the doldrums in due course :}

  • http://www.selfpublishingreview.com/members/ronfritsch/ Ron Fritsch

    You said it, Henry: “It’s just hard to sell books.” Despite that “Trough of Disillusionment,” though, this independent author isn’t giving up.

  • Mark Say

    Interesting piece. I’m planning to self-publish this year and don’t have any expectations of a runaway commercial success, but feel it’s better than the book sitting on my hard drive for just a handful of friends to have access to a Word doc or printed copy.
    Also, I can see that self-publishing gives authors the chance to take advanatge of a trend similar to that in the music industry over recent years – making it possible for artists to get their work out there without major backing and build a following online.
    I don’t expect it to be easy or to have any guarantee of success, but for someone who’s spent years trying to get published through the traditional route with no success, it offers something positive.

  • http://endless-satsang.com/ Nirmala

    My wife and I have been self-publishing for several years. When we first started out, we would have been thrilled to sell 98 copies of one of our books in a couple of months like the author of the article in the Atlantic. We were lucky to sell 5 copies a month. But we kept at it and have published 20 books now and they still only average about 100 copies a month. Well guess what: 20 x 100 x $2.09 (70% of 2.99) in royalties equals $4180 a month. Not exactly Amanda Hocking territory, but all of our hard work is paying off. I guess maybe we have made it to the plateau of productivity!

    And my wife was published by several traditional publishers in the past, but they all managed to not sell many books. So for us, self-publishing is a no-brainer!
    https://www.smashwords.com/profile/view/Nirmala
    https://www.smashwords.com/profile/view/GinaLake

  • http://www.SelfPubSmart.com Andrew Chapman

    As someone who first self-published in 1987 and has been thoroughly immersed in “indie publishing” long before that term was coined, I can tell you firsthand that — really — nothing has changed in terms of what it takes to succeed. The secret, and only secret, is work. You work at it. The times may change and the tools may change, but beneath it all is just plain work.

    The process for getting a book out to the world has changed immensely, and self-publishing has largely shed its longtime stigman, but it still all comes down to gaining the attention of your intended audience. And although there are many more ways to do this in 2012 vs. 1987, anyone’s intended audience is also far more overwhelmed with information than ever before. The term “attention economy” is very apt. What we self-publishers have effectively traded is the monetary cost of our venture (e.g., expensive print runs; paying for classified ads and selling via mail order) for time cost (e.g., hours on social media; slowly building an email list).

    But there’s no way on earth I would trade self-publishing today for what it was 25 years ago. As others have pointed out, we’re only seeing the beginning of an amazing time to be able to create and publish our works to a worldwide audience.

    • http://www.SelfPubSmart.com Andrew Chapman

      *longtime stigma (what the heck is a “stigman”?)

viagra go generic buy 30 mg prednisone cheap cialis pillstore generic viagra 50mg buy lisinopril india levitra 40 mg amex lexapro tabs 20mg tetracycline 500mg cap diflucan 50 mg capsule brand viagra buy online viagra shops lisinopril 10 mg vision augmentin 675 mg dosage custa cialis 5mg clomid prescription online nolvadex 40mg ed cialis 800mg yellow compra buy doxycycline generic of lasix lexapro withdrawal 30mg bupropion generic wellbutrin clomid success 50mg cialis online questions cialis onlinenline stockholm 200 mg generic cialis buy 150 mg. viagra augmentin bd 1000 mg augmentin bid 200 28 mg cialis 20 mg yorum zovirax cream mg generic of zithromax viagra 100mg prix 400 mg doxycycline daily buy 1000 kamagra medication levitra 10 mg buy kamagra soho 75 mg clomid buy generic dapoxetine buy cialis in lexapro 10 mg pregnancy buying cialis 20 mg celebrex 220 mg fungsi doxycycline 50 mg generic lexapro 10 viagra online online online levitra viagra buy viagra southampton lexapro 5mg work sildenafil viagra online cialis 5 mg picnogenolo buy prednisone 20mg buy generic lexapro 50 mg of phenergan ic propranolol 80 mg cialis 5mg generika 40 mg nexium dosage cheapest cialis california cialis 5mg recreational cialis 5mg anwendung xenical usa buy harga doxycycline 100mg cipro 500 mg use cialis 5mg czech cheapest valtrex generic 600mg zithromax doxycycline 400 mg tablet levitra 10mg uk xenical 120 mg priser lisinopril anxiety disorder buy prednisone medication online pharmacy viagra 300 mg viagra brand viagra cheap buy dapoxetine 60mg lexapro online 20mg doxycycline 100mg doziranje levitra 10mg paypal lisinopril 10 mg 12.5 mg wellbutrin 300 mg beipackzettel strattera 40 mg dose cialis prescribtion online existe viagra 800 mg cialis lilly 20mg 50 mg generic cialis generic cialis patent prednisone prolix 20mg online valtrex ordering dosage zithromax 500mg cialis 5 mg funciona cipro 500mg uses levitra order cialis xenical 120 mg beipackzettel cheap propecia reviews levitra generic cheap propecia generic 2013 price using 80mg cialis kamagra generic uk levitra 400mg 1.19 but 2.5 mg cialis xenical tablets cheap lisinopril 10 mg medication 50 mg of strattera online viagra 25mg generic viagra 100 generic lexapro 10mg international viagra online propranolol 80 mg er diflucan online kopen cheap cialis online .50 cialis 20mg dosage viagra generic fake buy viagra 3 day doxycycline 200mg coupon 0.5mg propecia results viagra 110 mg buy clomid 200mg prednisone winthrop 20 mg purpose metformin 500 mg clomid compresse 50 mg diflucan 150 mg prospecto lisinopril 10 or 20 mg canadian cialis online buy priligy 30mg comenzi online viagra levitra 10 generico propecia 1 mg 28 tablets 225 mg synthroid indicaciones cialis 20 mg boots generic viagra cialis 5mg young cialis 40mg dose generic 150 mg viagra online viagra cheap cialis 5 mg din generic lexapro comparison cipro generic prescription cialis generica net buy doxycycline 150 mg buy viagra germany generic 3 day cialis thuoc bactrim 480 mg prednisone 20 mg apo propecia generic usa generic zoloft camber viagra 50 mg prices order nexium online viagra generico vendas online buy viagra amoxil 500 mg price generico nexium 40 mg lisinopril 20 mg cost cialis dosage 100 mg lisinopril 5 mg hypertension 10 mg lexapro withdrawal viagra 100 mg beipackzettel dapoxetine buy china 5 mg lexapro usage buy priligy china Cialis 20mg 60 Tabs bali viagra buy nexium 40mg barato amoxil 500 mg capsules tetracycline antibiotics buy cialis 5mg lilly 5 mg of lisinopril zithromax 500mg preis zithromax chlamydia 500mg lexapro generic alcohol buy phenergan infant cialis rezeptfrei 20mg cialis 20 mg canada commander kamagra 100mg zoloft 50 mg bid zovirax 400 mg celebrex 200 mg pret generic nexium coming buy some cialis buy nolvadex tablets generic cialis wordpress 12 viagra 100mg buy 40 mg levitra cipro hcl 250 mg take 2 levitra 10mg cheap cialis daily medicamento levitra 10 mg doxycycline 260 mg cialis generics cheap prednisone 10 mg pill cialis generico prezzi viagra online toronto doxycycline 100mg iv doxycycline hyclate 75mg online levitra mastercard cheap viagra 150 lexapro 10 mg depression doxycycline doxin 500mg lasix da 500 mg buy viagra rss 20mg cialis effects propecia vs. generic celebrex 200mg forum nolvadex buy pct cipro 750 mg generic cialis 20 mg discount pfizer zoloft 100mg 150 mg de viagra nexium 20 mg prospecto prices viagra 50mg buying kamagra online xenical 120 mg results rosacea doxycycline 100mg viagra internet order viagra online paypal prednisone 7 mg cialis cheapist bactrim 80 400 mg tablets kegunaan zithromax 500 mg online kamagra maestro cyproheptadine generic periactin viagra cheap usa 5 mg cialis pricing cialis 10 mg forum doxycycline posologie 20mg lexapro 10 mg pharmacy 0.5mg propecia eod augmentin 312 mg 5 ml lisinopril 40 mg 4214 v remedio generico xenical 5 mg propecia day levitra perscription online levitra 10 mg bugiardino diflucan 150 mg 1 capsule buy cialis near 32901 80 mg propranolol effects propecia online hong 1000 mg er metformin lisinopril 20 mg beipackzettel bactrim 800 mg dose buy nolvadex india order cialis us buy nexium tablets cialis 5 mg ho metformin abz 500 mg periactin comp 4 mg cialis generic pharmacy lexapro 20mg engorda synthroid pharmacy online viagra tablets order prezzo cialis 2 5mg wat kamagra 100mg cialis 5mg warszawa zoloft 50 to 100 mg cialis 5mg italiano cialis 20 mg lasts 20 mg bayer levitra 20mg lexapro effexor venta viagra generica 6mg zoloft starting prednisone 20 mg withdrawal thuoc augmentin 875 mg ordering lisinopril online lasix buy online 20mg lexapro ocd diflucan pret 150 mg xenical 120 mg paraguai buy 1000 mg zithromax prednisone 40 mg constipation viagra plus buy generic periactin cyproheptadi doxycycline 100mg palu phenergan seizure disorder viagra 150 mg online cialis two 20mg viagra 20 mg generic cialis rating viagra 25 mg filmtabletten cialis generico guatemala cialis 5 mg efectos lisinopril 20 mg iva levitra dose 5 mg highest mg zoloft cheap kamagra ireland 40 mggeneric cialis generic levitra usa erythromycin motility disorders buy atomoxetine strattera propecia 5mg pharmaxy 2 25mg viagra buy 40mg cialis zoloft at 150 mg augmentin generico equivalente prednisone uk buy generic viagra 150 mg. cheap 200 mg cialis is hydrochlorothiazide generic is strattera generic cialis 5 mg voucher periactin 4 mg dogs propranolol tab 20mg metformin mg dosage Levitra 10 mg Buy levitra 10 mg etkileri dosis augmentin 250 mg walgreen cialis 5 mg kaboon cialis online kamagra online cheapest zithromax generic name cialis 5 mg opiniones 60 mg prednisone breastfeeding 10mg generic cialis generico viagra nomes buy valtrex australia cialis 40 mg difference viagra generico mastercard phenergan liquid buy propecia merck online viagra 50 mg drug online viagra real viagra online review zoloft 100 mg anxiety doxycycline 100mg twice thuoc nexium 20mg generic brand levitra clomid 100 online cialis 5mg kur prices cialis 5mg cheap viagra generic lexapro fda strattera 40 mg recreational propranolol 20 mg cena viagra 150 mg dose buy nexium spain lexapro 2.5 mg dose 100 mg cialis tadalafil prednisone 20mg. mayo citalopram escitalopram 10 mg kamagra 100mg ervaring synthroid de 50mg online cialis doctor cheapest genuine cialis buy zithromax 1g online cialis 200 mg clomid 150 mg zwanger generic viagra europa buy propecia america comprimido cialis 20mg cialis 30 mg erection zoloft 50 mg erfahrungsberichte lisinopril 40 mg manufacturer cialis 20 mg mexico propranolol 25 mg nexium esomeprazole 10mg zovirax generic uk viagra online sklep buy synthroid cheap lasix 10 mg compresse levitra 20mg 2 tablets clomid 50 mg cipla vendo generico viagra nexium 40 mg harga viagra generico iene acheter levitra 10mg levitra 400mg cipro de 500mg buy branded viagra generic viagra march 27 buy cheap nolvadex zoloft 100 mg withdrawal generic lexapro pharmacy 3rd clomid 100mg 10 mg of phenergan generic viagra rl 50 diflucan 150 mg homme levitra 500mg lisinopril 20 mg wockhardt 20 mg viagra generic viagra illegal nexium 40mg instructions nexium 20 mg esomeprazol phenergan 25 mgs generic propecia reviews 2011 generic viagra mg cialis 20mg directions cipro order online cipro generic manufacturer cipro vs generic cialis 5mg fta 14 order cialis holland propranolol 20 a 40 mg cipro overdose 1000mg viagra 100mg einnahme viagra online jersey generic viagra opinie doxycycline 100 mg nausea viagra generico effetti kamagra 100mg tabletten 50 mg prednisone burst amoxil caps 500 mg pro cialis 20 mg buy clomid 100mg cialis 10mg directions celebrex cheapest 10mg cialis generic legally buy viagra cialis 10mg potecy cialis generico dogana zales viagra 100mg purchase Levitra 10 mg zovirax tabletas 400mg price propecia 1mg cipro 500 mg endikasyonu lisinopril 10 mg anwendung nolvadex buy sydney propecia online 1.25 mg order buspar online cheapest generic lexapro zithromax cheap net prednisone 20mg effects generic 5 mg propecia annunci cialis generico indian viagra 50mg diflucan 50mg used nolvadex 10mg dosage doxycycline 100mg 7 days augmentin 250 mg prospect kamagra 100mg paypal generic augmentin costs buying cialis curacao levitra buy singapore nolvadex 10mg men cialis phone orders cialis 20 mg 12 bactrim mg kg cialis 10 mg compresse cheapest price cialis augmentin 500 mg duration viagra 500mg 100 mg clomid iui vardenafil levitra 10 mg hyperstimulation clomid 50mg diflucan capsules 150mg valtrex 1000 mg 21 tablets generic xenical paypal cialis cincinnati buy levitra 5mg pris xenical generic name cialis 20mg tabs 500mg metformin generico do synthroid cialis 5 mg kosten nexium 40 mg mexico lisinopril 80 mg cialis 20mg overdose propranolol sintaser 10 mg doxycycline 100mg treats buy wockhardt lisinopril zithromax capsules buy order xenical ordering zithromax online diflucan 100mg pret cialis 5mg venda order Cialis 60 Tabs comprar generico xenical lexapro 5 mg day 50 or 100 mg zoloft viagra kanada onlineshop nolvadex order online viagra 25 mg.price cipro bayer 500 mg vestibular disorder prednisone remedios viagra generico buy kamagra ireland viagra online vgr viagra online bali camber generic zoloft lisinopril 2.5mg cough lisinopril 20 mg fish buy digram cialis online viagra order wellbutrin 150 mg bula wellbutrin sr cheapest metformin hexal 850 mg upcoming generic lexapro take 50 mg clomid cipro 750 mg prostatitis about generic cialis viagra fiyati 25 mg nexium generic online 40 mg lexapro alcohol doxycycline rosacea 100 mg order canadian cialis 10mg cialis lexapro 30 mg dosage augmentin 750mg nedir buy viagra nhs nexium 40 mg medicine 800 mg viagra uk google viagra 800mg generic viagra business viagra bestellen online