Home / Book Reviews / Review: 5 Reasons to Leave a Lover: a Novella and Other Short Stories by Carolyn Moncel

Review: 5 Reasons to Leave a Lover: a Novella and Other Short Stories by Carolyn Moncel

In Set Yourself Free Ellery, Ellery Roulet is an American with a career in Paris and she has made an emotionally crushing discovery.  It threatens her marriage to Julien and the life she knows as a mother to twins Evie and Maddie.  The story is told from Ellery’s point of view as well as that of Julien and his lover, Katrine.  Carolyn Moncel presents a compelling story and in fifty pages conveys the hopes and angst of all three.

While Ellery’s struggle is perhaps the most developed, Julien and Katrine weigh their choices with equal depth of feeling.  Moncel is adept at presenting the characters as scoundrels, in the minds of the others, and then conveying each person’s feelings in such a way that it is possible to have sympathy for each, in turn.

Because it is a short work, it is difficult to talk about most aspects of the plot without revealing too much about it.  There is a wonderful scene in which Ellery and Julien’s twin daughters become aware of how upset Ellery is and discuss their fears about their parents’ presumed marital discord.  It is the only part of the book shown through the twins’ point of view, and their perceptions and qualms are very realistic.

There is occasional dialogue in French, and in some books this is presented clumsily.  Not so here.  As one who has been to Paris several times, I could envision the backdrop.  There was little description of either the apartment or the unique environment that is Paris.  Sparse writing can be beautiful, but I was glad to have my own mental pictures so I could “see” the characters in their respective settings.

The novella’s ultimate question is can love survive betrayal?  Moncel shows there is not only no easy answer but there are many ways to consider the question.

The two short stories are Maybe Just Leave, Steve and Maybe in Death, Beth.  Betrayal and loyalty are again themes in Maybe Just Leave, Steve, which is told from Cinnamon’s point of view and show’s Cinnamon’s evolving feelings for Steve’s wife, Leah.  There’s a neat twist at the end.  While I saw it quickly, not all would, and it is handled deftly.

Maybe in Death, Beth shows the rewards of “working it out.”  Herman and Beth, in their mid-nineties, had their relationship struggles early in their life together, but they have made it to the point of not just love but total comfort with one another.

The two short stories are set in Chicago, which was Ellery’s American home, and it is Paris that Leah wants to live in and work in for a time.  The quick mention of “great granddaughter Leah” in Maybe in Death, Beth seems to add another link among the three stories.

I did not count to see whether Moncel actually presents five reasons to leave your lover, but that’s not important.  Set Yourself Free Ellery and its companion short stories provide a pleasant, and provocative, evening read.  I give them five stars.



Barnes & Noble



buy cialis uae metformin bluefish 1000 mg cipro generic levitra buy sydney ordering prednisone online buying viagra taiwan usa generic cialis buy prednisone local buy priligy online erythromycin 400 mg uses cialis kaufen 5 mg lexapro generic alcohol order Cialis 10 Tabs propecia online buy cipro 800mg order propecia propecia viagra online india order zithromax 250 mg levitra 20mg 2 tablets lisinopril tabs 20mg lisinopril 25 mg dosage clomid 50 mg ervaringen 40 mg sublingual cialis wellbutrin 300 mg er cipro de 500mg generic viagra alp cheap priligy uk order viagra wiki cheap quick viagra viagra brand 100 mg spain kamagra online levitra generic walgreens 10mg lexapro reviews cialis 10 mg halbieren cheap lisinopril 20 mg levitra cheap prednisone 2 mg day sertraline zoloft 100mg buy cialis mississauga metformin 1000 mg teva cialis tabletta 20 mg celebrex 50 mg capsule buying viagra lanzarote flagyl er 400 mg buy nexium boots ram nexium 40 mg wellbutrin generic npr viagra 50 mg cpr4 cialis paypal online metformin tablets 1000mg cialis 5mg 14 szt review viagra online generic viagra typepad buy cialis 3 day lisinopril 10 mg pink bactrim 400 80 mg tablet buy zithromax online zoloft 50 mg indicaciones lisinopril 20 mg prospect viagra 100mg pills levitra 200mg walgreens viagra 100 mg precio chinese viagra 800mg prednisone 30 mg tablet augmentin 625 mg capsule viagra 25mg cost take 2 cialis 20mg. liquid viagra online generic viagra europa viagra buy here mexican viagra generic usa viagra 4000 mg zovirax cheapest 6 pills 1000 mg zithromax generico viagra ems generic lisinopril purchase 12 mg de viagra 250 mg liquid celebrex cialis 30 mg buying cipro diflucan capsules 150mg metformin hydrochloride 1000 mg buy tamoxifen nolvadex cipro 500mg bid phenergan 25 mg injection 200 mg wellbutrin sr levitra 20mg 12 st cipro 500 mg tablet prednisone cats 5mg cheap prescription propecia generic zithromax 1g erythromycin stada 500mg levitra 5mg purchase levitra 5 mg generico lexapro generic antidepressants buy viagra france generic metformin online amoxil 400 mg suspension metformin 850 mg axcount buy amoxil 875 cheapest lexapro 10 mg celexa valtrex 1000mg lisinopril 20 mg infarmed 25mg zoloft nausea zovirax generic cost cialis online mambia generic viagra s order diflucan roerig 150 generic viagra 10 clomid prescriptions online lexapro generic paronia xenical buy australia us cialis online cialis 20mg fta 12 kamagra jel 5mg amoxil 500 mg uses 5 mg cialis review viagra 50mg 1 comprimido valtrex tab 500mg viagra generic4all lasix 20 mg precio lexapro vs generic 2012 buy bactrim overnight metformin 500 mg bioequivalence viagra farmacie online metformin 4000 mg cialis online reputable generic xenical price 0.5mg propecia eod buy celebrex china buy viagra youtube viagra online tips metformin xr 1000 mg buy augmentin 875 mg cialis 2.5mg wallgreens cheapest levitra online cheap nexium 20mg propecia online 1.25 mg cipro 500 mg 7 days metformin online sale 137 mg of synthroid cialis 40mg 30 pills cialis lilly 800mg buy synthroid uk zovirax online amoxil bencard 500mg priligy order lexapro 60 mg lexapro generico thai cialis generic levitra dose 5 mg lexapro 10 mg bijwerkingen phenergan 5mg dosage levitra online health propecia finasteride cheap diflucan 50 mg kapselit xenical generico preco cialis 10mg fta 4 xenical online store 75 mg clomid take 50 mg clomid fox 125 mg viagra viagra jelly 10 mg viagra buy spain panic disorder zoloft generic metformin canada cheap viagra buy generic viagra nedir order cialis 10 mg turkiyede clomid 50mg lexapro going generic 2012 cheapest online propecia lexapro 40mg wirkung cialis 5mg lasix 20mg iv generic cialis thailand 5 mg prednisone daily cipro basics 250 mg teva doxycycline 100mg synthroid mood disorders prednisone purchase online generic nexium coming cutting 20mg levitra generic lasix 500 mg generic viagra teva zoloft 20 mg symptoms nolvadex kup online cialis economico online taking 100mg zoloft fluoxetine generic cymbalta buy lisinopril 5 mg cialis 2.5 mg greece cialis mg c80 cialis 5 mg wikipedia wellbutrin 300 mg bijwerkingen 05 mg cialis cheaper than cialis lexapro 25mg generico de cipro generic lexapro comparison thuoc propranolol 10mg buy priligy dapoxetine metformin hydrochloride 750mg doxycycline injection 100mg buy viagra ecstasy nexium online sampling order xenical tablets cialis diario 2 5 mg citalopram lexapro mg augmentin 80mg cialis com 5 mg guaranteed cheapest levitra cialis professional ordering azithromycin zithromax buy cialis online coupons kamagra soft 100 mg strattera mood disorder lexapro generico colombia cialis 10 mg preise doxycycline 100 mg tablets cialis farmacie online cialis generic thailand nolvadex online prescription doxycycline 200mg bid taking viagra 100 mg metformin 500mg bloating ordering kamagra generic levitra italy zithromax india cheap preisvergleich levitra 20 mg 12 buy cialis soft lisinopril 5mg alcohol viagra order cheap viagra 100 mg reimport generic propranolol manufacturers wellbutrin generic works buspar 5 mg tablets viagra online sample cheap viagra pill cialis online advertising viagra purchase generic zovirax cream mg cialis buy mastercard generic bactrim online generic viagra date buy zithromax pills anxiety disorder buspar cheapest generic wellbutrin 50 mg prednisone withdrawal clomid ile mg levitra 20mg 4 st cialis 20 mg efficacia order brand zithromax vancouver viagra buy cialis 20 mg prospect singapore buy nolvadex wellbutrin 100 mg daily viagra uk buy promethazine generic phenergan viagra 100 mg white generic cialis welfil 20 buy levitra women cialis tadalafil 10 mg lisinopril tablets buy levitra 20 mg yorumlar lisinopril 5 mg preferent kamagra generics24 levitra 2 5 mg propranolol 120 mg buy viagra usa viagra flavored 100mg propecia online buy injecting 80 mg cialis generic cialis overseas 250mg of viagra prednisone 5 mg vaccines 50mg viagra review celebrex celecoxib 100mg buying viagra men augmentin 600 mg online kamagra maestro viagra 100mg paypal cialis prijs 5mg tetracycline 500mg cap viagra online fda viagra 100mg efeitos synthroid 112 mg viagra 100mg efekt cipro 500 mg tab diflucan cheap cheap zithromax pills levitra de 100 mgs viagra generic cost 40 mggeneric cialis nexium 10 mg pret 120 mg of strattera order propecia forum buy metformin hydrochloride insurance online viagra nexium 40 mg posologie 600 mg wellbutrin erowid zovirax generic buy 20mg lexapro effexor discount order viagra cheap kamagra polo toko viagra online generic augmentin 500mg clomid on 100mg downside 10 mg prednisone online buy viagra 10mg viagra work order cialis holland prednisone taper 20mg buy generic lisinopril cialis 5mg warszawa viagra generic advice cialis farmacia online buying viagra pattaya 2011 prednisone generic buy propranolol 20 mg bid effet viagra 25mg buspar dosage 10mg buy lasix medication viagra online singapore generic cialis sweet glucophage online lupin lisinopril 5 mg order lexapro tablets taking 50 mg viagra 10mgs cialis enough search cheap viagra generic 5 mg propecia order propecia pills 28 doxycycline 100mg legit viagra online le clomid 50mg wellbutrin 300 mg xl 100 mg lisinopril 2x cialis 5mg buy viagra suppositoria valtrex 1000 mg canada order Cialis 60 Tabs generic viagra drug cialis generic overnight lisinopril 5 mg bijsluiter viagra 100mg nebenwirkungen generic wellbutrin efficacy cialis 10 mg prospecto purchase generic valtrex cialis online argentina cialis naturale online generic nexium caps cheap viagra toronto zoloft 10 mg celebrex 100 mg price posologie levitra 10 mg boots online doxycycline generic viagra instructions viagra fiyatlari 100 mg wellbutrin buying online highest mg buspar cialis generico infarmed order clomid mastercard lisinopril 40 mg tabl cialis took 40 mg prednisone 10mg generic levitra 10 mg dose augmentin 125 mg zoloft et borderline buy 5 mg cialis metformin hmgcoa reductase metformin generic brand potenzmittel levitra 10 mg doxycycline 100 mg nedir kamagra 200 mg gel xenical 120 mg dosage nexium generic brand generic lexapro pharmacy levitra generico 10 mg where order cialis acquisti online viagra walgreen generic viagra propecia shampoo buy levitra 10 mg recensioni philippine generic cialis cheap cialis canadian nexium 40mg pdf buying cialis sydney 100 mg generic cialis phenergan 25mg cost xenical 120 mg 42 caps propecia generic form nexium mups 20 mg metformin hcl 1000mg 5mg lexapro tiredness medicinali generici cialis buy 9 zithromax cialis half 20mg zithromax tablet 250 mg doxycycline backorder zithromax 500mg n1 cialis max 25 mg doxycycline 400 mg tablet cialis 10 mg. cost cialis generic e20 walgreens generic lexapro cialis 5mg.it doxycycline 200mg online glucophage cialis australia 5mg 180 mg of strattera taking generic cialis valtrex dosage 500 mg bactrim 40 mg 200 mg propranolol 25 mg doxycycline 100mg liquid comprar generico xenical propecia buy singapore cialis 10 o 20 mg cheap periactin online generic viagra 26 cialis lasix 500mg price generic 10mg levitra online chemist phenergan viagra chicago buy viagra o genericos split 20 mg cialis propecia goiing generic diflucan generic buy comprimes cialis 5mg cialis 10 mg sulit buy erythromycin lotion levitra generique 20mg cialis buy cialis augmentin pediatrico 125 mg augmentin 625 mg davkovanie buying viagra holland valtrex 10 mg propranolol sdz 10mg cipro 750 mg generic buy viagra disqus cialis 5mgm prices cialis pills buyer 40 mgs lexapro zoloft 100mg effects diflucan 2 pill 150 mg cheap prednisone online cialis generico amex order lisinopril canada generic viagra mg cheap kamagra jelly cipro 500mg uses propecia 1mg canada cheap online levitra synthroid 75 mg price viagra online toronto levitra generika 20mg augmentin 250 mg suspensie levitra 0.25mg lexapro drug generic dosis augmentin 250 mg cheap viagra jamaica doxycycline 100mg nl augmentin 250 mg dawkowanie valtrex 500mg preis viagra vegetal 200mg kamagra 100mg nebenwirkung cialis 40 mg doses lisinopril 10 or 20 mg glucophage 850 mg precio wellbutrin 300 mg libido lisinopril sandoz 5mg doxycycline 100mg diabetes cheap propecia reviews buy cialis near 32901 buying 40 mg lisinopril lisinopril 10 mg sale lisinopril 5 mg cena lasix 80 mg dose 40 mg strattera effects generic metformin hcl clomid 50 mg cost cialis 20mg nebenwirkung lexapro 60 mg dose viagra 100mg uk xenical 15mg generic viagra zoll lisinopril dosage 50 mg bangkok viagra buy viagra mg chart cialis 20 mg daily clomid 150 mg jumeaux viagra online discrete cialis buy quebec augmentin de 125 mg nexium 40 mg gastritis tappering prednisone 2.5mg real levitra online buying viagra melbourne clomid 50 mg funziona