Home / Features / Self-Publishing in the Blogosphere

Self-Publishing in the Blogosphere

There’s a lot of interesting discussion about self-publishing going on in the blogosphere, beginning with Victoria Strauss who writes for the Writer Beware blog.  She calls out a recent article on CNN that paints too rosy a picture of self-publishing.  Not revealing, for instance, that a successful self-publisher also had a high-powered PR firm working for her.  I would argue this is the case with a lot of journalism in general – it errs on the side of being overly positive.  That’s the nature of the puff piece.

But she’s right, in a way.  Self-publishing is not yet a replacement for traditional publishing.  It’s a hard slog to get a book noticed and distributed.  It’s also a hard slog to find an agent and get published in this climate.  The talk about the new paradigm is not necessarily saying self-publishing has replaced traditional publishing, but that it can and possibly will.  This is one story that has not yet fully been written, and it has great potential that has not been fully realized.

Currently, though,  I would make this argument, which may come as contrary to the purposes of the site: self-publishing sucks.  This is my view and possibly not the view of other people who write for this site, but self-publishing is a last resort.  Though you can find distribution and recognition as a self-publisher, it is far easier to have the advocate and machine of a traditional publisher.  What’s preferable:

  1. Marketing and distributing a book entirely by yourself, out of your own pocket.
  2. Marketing a book yourself with help from a publisher, who will also be more likely to secure widespread distribution.

I would much rather not have to hustle so hard to find readers for my books.  While, yes, the criteria for Barnes and Noble carrying a book published by a traditional publisher is narrowing, it’s even harder for a self-publisher.  Plainly, at this stage, getting traditionally published is preferable.  All power to April Hamilton, who has a great piece as a response to this Guardian post.

My indie books DO sell.

My indie books are distributed by Amazon, the #1 bookseller in the world. I could also get them stocked by independent brick and mortar booksellers if I wanted to, and in fact have done so in the past, but I’ve found it’s much harder to move those brick-and-mortar store copies than to simply keep selling online.

Anyway, IMO the brick-and-mortar chain bookstore in its current incarnation is an endangered species, and investing heavily in brick-and-mortar distribution is a waste of money for all but the biggest-selling mainstream books. To be clear, yes, I AM saying that it’s a waste for MOST mainstream-published books, not just indie books. I blogged about it: Big Chain Bookstore Death Watch.

My books get reviewed on Amazon and elsewhere, and they get recognition in the form of personal recommendations, recommendations on Twitter, blogs, and Facebook, and mentions in publications as well known as The Wall Street Journal, Business Week and The Huffington Post.

That’s great, and it can happen, but given the fact that a writer’s going to have to market a book anyway, it seems better to do this in conjunction with the marketing and distribution efforts of a trad publisher.

My purpose for this site is not to say writers should drop everything and self-publish because it’s all gold and rainbows, but to say that self-publishing is a legitimate and entirely useful fallback plan.  So Victoria Strauss is half-right.  She’s right when she says that self-publishers will scratch and claw to get visibility with limited results.  But she’s wrong when she says,

The plain fact is that most self-published books–just like most manuscripts doing the slush pile rounds–are not publishable.

The problem that needs to be continually expressed is this: “Publishable” too often means “Marketable.”  There are self-published books that deserve to be published, traditionally published books that don’t deserve to be, and a lot of things that shouldn’t be either.  But to make blanket generalizations like self-published books aren’t publishable is more than a little old-fashioned.

The New Paradigm

All the talk about the new paradigm is really talk about what the future will be like.  We are on the edge of that future and the rules and system of publishing may eventually be entirely rewritten, with new and better models for writers to reach readers.  This could happen when e-readers are as ubiquitous as cell-phones. This could happen when publishing is all print on demand.  But to say that – right now – self-publishing is preferable to traditional publishing is too much of a fundamentalist position.  It’s a great development, but with serious limitations.  That traditional publishing also has severe limitations does not negate self-publishing’s own problems.

One thing I don’t understand though is the careful attitude towards writers – stating that writers are coddled into thinking that self-publishing is a route to instant success.  Frankly, if you think this way, you’re a strange kind of gullible.  Self-publishing is hard – there’s no way around that.  But it’s also an enormously positive development that will become an increasing part of the overall fabric of publishing.  Are we there yet?  No. Traditional publishing isn’t dead – there’s no reason to dance on the grave yet.  But dying?  Wounded?  Needing to be reworked?  Certainly and self-publishing is an important and exciting part of that process.  It’s something that readers, writers, agents, and editors should embrace.

  • http://madpropstobakedpotatoes.com Brian

    So much of this is true, and the biggest thing is that none of us really know what’s next. Clearly a nice advance and the backing of a bigger machine is preferable. What about a smaller publisher and a smaller advance? Is it even worth it to take that deal, wait a year+ for your book to come out, and then do most (if not all) of the marketing yourself? I’m not so sure – especially if one doesn’t need that mental validation of being released by a “real publisher”.

    What I do know, is much like the newspaper companies, publishers seem to be taking a stance of “let’s figure out how our old business model works in this new world” as opposed to “let’s look at this new world and figure out a business model that works in it”.

    Subtle but important difference.

  • http://www.accrispin.blogspot.com Victoria Strauss

    Responding to your comment about my comment about most self-pubbed books not being publishable (or marketable, or whatever)…Here’s how I see it.

    Since anyone can self-publish, just as anyone can submit to an agent or a publisher, the catalog of a self-publishing company probably closely resembles an agent’s or publisher’s slush pile–that is, there are all kinds of different manuscripts form all kinds of different people with all kinds of different goals and all kinds of different abilities. So the hard truth of the slush pile–that most manuscripts in it don’t even approach publishability–is also the hard truth of self-published books.

    The fact that most self-published books aren’t publishable, therefore, is a reflection of the larger truth that most manuscripts aren’t publishable.

    Are there good self-published books? Yes, of course. But as with the publishable books in the slush pile, they’re very much in the minority.

  • http://BrassCannonBooks.net Francis Hamit

    Well, Victoria, no one said it would be easy. Certainly not me. You admit there that some self-published books are publishable, don’t you? But dealing with the current arrogance of agents, who have gotten a hammerlock on the submission process, is simply maddening. First they demand exclusive access to your work and then take months to reply, if they reply at all. Many of us just got fed-up and refused to play any more. It is a stupid game.

    Among the bad advice I’ve had from agents is to write something like what has already sold and to write to a specific length because the bookstores control how many pages there are in a book. (They don’t. I asked.) Agents are only interested in what they think they can sell and they take big hints from what those editors have already published and offer more of the same.

    With a little care and effort one can turn out a product (which is what a book is) that competes in every way with what the big publishers put out. I actually like taking responsibility for the way my book looks and controlling the editorial presentation. I’ve seen some pretty slap-dash, badly edited and badly printed books from big publishers in the last decade. I’ve seen howling errors in fact that an intern using Google could have caught in five minutes.

    The big bookstore chains all want best sellers because they have enormous overhead and need that velocity, but they still end up returning half of what they order, or more. . Amazon.com harvests this low hanging fruit in abundance by dealing direct with customers that actually want the books, but their real business is the Long Tail. Last year, according to an article I just read, they sold one copy each of two million different books.

    Self publishers would do far better if there were not this rap that says it’s all bad. If we were reviewed on an equal footing with the big publishing houses and if the chains had access policies for small presses that actually would let them in the stores and on the shelves. We don’t do volume sales in “brick and mortar” because few of them give us the chance.

    But, one can break through here and there because some bookstores remember that their business is selling books and not setting cultural policy. So I’ll just have to go on ruining my career.

  • http://wordywoman.com Shelley Lieber

    Why argue with what is? So much time and energy spent on attacking or defending a position when you could be writing about your passion or promoting yourself and your book. Self-publishing in all its forms is here to stay. It just is. So do it, or don’t. What’s wrong with choice? And what makes your choice better than someone else’s?

    I’d rather champion the empowerment of authors to spread their messages however they can, rather than support the suppression of ideas. The reading public can figure out for themselves what they want to read. We don’t need self-appointed gatekeepers to tell us what’s good or bad. Should we not attend indie film festivals because not everything on YouTube is good cinematography?

    Just because something takes time to learn and to do well is not a reason not to do it. Writing is a passion; publishing is a business. To be successful takes time and effort, no matter what the business. As my mother would say, “If you can’t stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.” But for those who are committed to expressing and sharing their ideas, I say, “Go for it!”

generic cialis cheap blue generic wellbutrin diflucan 800 mg bactrim forte 480 mg priligy generico forum 80 mg nexium cialis online pharmacies buy cream viagra buy kamagra gold viagra 100mg how wellbutrin 100mg tablets manufacture generic viagra generic cialis sweden ttc clomid 50mg wellbutrin 20 mg strattera 60 mg cost celebrex 200mg dosage doxycycline dosage 300 mg phenergan 150mg viagra buy spain diflucan online order buy cialis 200mg propecia nz buy costo viagra 50 mg prezzi cialis 20 mg cialis online legale florida buy viagra clomid 150mg protocol clomid 250 mg lexapro 1 mg generic viagra discreet buy xenical philippines harga cialis 80 mg viagra online switzerland valtrex online bestellen prednisone steroid 5mg lasix 20 mg comprimidos diuretico lasix 40 mg cialis 5mg canada doxycycline 100 mg medication is cialis 100mg buy nolvadex delhi splitting 100mg levitra levitra 10 mg prospecto generic viagra cipra cialis black 500mg valtrex 500mg dose cost 40 mg nexium levitra 20mg usa 1.35 25mg zoloft depression levitra online mastercard viagra online philippines cost viagra 25 mg xenical buy now augmentin amoxicilina 500mg generic viagra same viagra generica china doxycycline 100mg canada 25mg viagra fiyati 5mg cialis canada lexapro 5 mg dose generica viagra clomid pct buy nolvadex online buy viagra 100mg composition buy fake clomid lisinopril online generic viagra 100 mg wiki clomid 50mg dose lexapro 15 mg viagra 7.5 mg cialis 5mg ndc nolvadex 25mg testosterone cheap zithromax online celebrex 200 mg bula generic cialis lilly clomid success 100mg amoxil 250 mg dosage kamagra 100mg fake generic cialis 30 days generic viagra rezeptfrei 10mg prednisone dogs cialis online legal celebrex online order bactrim 500 mg spanish xenical online de lasix 500 mg generic cheap cytotec philippines propecia genuine online viagra and buy lasix online ordering valtrex 500 mg cost pfizer viagra 50 mg diflucan 40 mg metformin 500 mg cost generic lasix 40 mg priligy online pharmacy cialis 3800 mg fake lisinopril 10 mg appearance nexium going generic starting zoloft 25 mg zoloft generic price cipro 200 mg flk zoloft 50 mg prospect 800 mg chinese viagra zovirax cream 5 buy viagra online dot doxycycline 200 mg syphilis viagra generic sale triplets clomid 50mg viagra 100mg apteka celebrex 200 mg dose viagra 50 mg capsules 40 mg prednisone pack augmentin generic dosage durata cialis 10 mg prednisone 500 mg 50 mg clomid triplets cipro antibiotic 500 mg kemasan cialis 10mg viagra buy camden generic levitra purchase cialis 20 mg tablet online levitra kaufen levitra 10 mg online sandoz metformin 850 mg cialis 30 mg kapseln cytotec de 400 mg doxycycline 20mg generic viagra generico seguro dapoxetine 60 mg india celebrex 200mg celecoxib cheap viagra 200 mg generic viagra patent viagra generic launch cheap tetracycline metformin 500 mg rebajar levitra 20mg preis clomid 50 mg pcos lexapro panic disorders buy viagra california cialis 5 mg daily buy metformin er zithromax 500 mg indicaciones buy periactin generic 90 mg synthroid pro cialis 20 mg buy augmentin antibiotic generic viagra craigslist nexium 20 mg directions metformin mylan 500mg doxycycline 100 mg yanetkileri generic viagra spray generic viagra classifieds generic lexapro images dosage prednisone 20 mg cialis 20mg tadalafil buy lexapro cipralex generic viagra test amoxil online cheap afbouwen lexapro 10 mg order propecia cost cialis professional 20 mg. buy 50 ml viagra viagra buy japan zithromax online discount buy propecia winnipeg zovirax 5mg cream gold viagra 3 000 mg viagra most mg online sr wellbutrin cialis 5 mg bula cialis 5mg 1 box strong propecia 5mg lisinopril 2.5mg tablets generic alcohol cialis fake cialis 3800 mg order zovirax uk online real viagra australlian generic viagra 150mg viagra canada celebrex 200 mg forum buy clomid nolvadex canadian nexium 40 mg cialis wholesale online levitra 20 mg prijs viagra generic 25 mg 4 5 mg cialis metformin xr 1500mg bactrim to buy viagra online legit kamagra 100mg erfahrungsbericht preis kamagra 100mg lasix 20 mg dosage clomid mg ml doxycycline buy vietnam cialis 5mg dubai cheapest viagra chemists cheaper 500mg viagra buy viagra france buy kamagra california tablet glucophage 500 mg metformin hexal 1000 mg uk 200mg viagra prednisone withdrawal 5mg medikament celebrex 200mg lexapro generic webmd generic viagra manufacturer xenical 120 mg online kopen cialis 40mg 60mg lexapro testimonials generic cialis buy bactrim generic buy Cialis 120 Tabs cialis generic softabs metformin 5 500 mg lisinopril 10 mg information prednisone veterinary buy buy authentic levitra doxycycline 100mg dose viagra cheap 100mg lexapro anxiety disorders lasix de 40mg generic doxycycline online buying doxycycline 100mg 33 viagra order online kamagra buy bangkok doxycycline 100mg dosage 60 mg prednisone 5 days cheap cialis warwickshire viagra overdose 200 mg viagra 100 ou 50 mg buy real nolvadex zoloft 100mg pregnancy cialis notice20mg reichen 5 mg cialis nexium esomeprazol 40 mg prednisone 20 mg images generic 25mg viagra lisinopril 10 10 mg tab buy lasix tablet synthroid 0.25 mg tablet diflucan 400mg citalopram 40mg indicacoes nexium 40 mg notice cura cialis 5 mg viagra 50 y 100 mg 100mg doxycycline usage Cialis 5 mg 120 Tabs cipro xr 500 cheap buy 500 mg doxycycline online viagra experiment levitra tablete 10 mg lasix 40 mg furosemid metformin 1000 mg overdose cialis generic singapore viagra online dublin buy doxycycline injectable buy clomid dianabol kamagra gold cheapest buy clomid pills trusted generic cialis levitra online discount viagra canada 25mg tabletki doxycycline 100mg strattera 60 mg costco clomid 100 mg jumeaux viagra portugal online cialis generico seguro cialis and 2.5 mg clomid 250mg posologie valtrex 500 mg zithromax 1000 mg buy doxycycline 100mg dosering zovirax 200 mg compresse cialis lilly 40mg cialis 20mg 4 stk dosage augmentin 500mg levitra generic articles prednisone oral 10 mg super viagra 3800mg viagra approval online clomid 200 mg pcos fda viagra generic generic viagra 100 tabs citalopram buy online lisinopril 2.5 mg headaches stop zoloft 50 mg viagra online reputable skachat propecia 1mg levitra bucodispersable 10 mg legal online cialis prednisone 5mg uses forum generic cialis diflucan 200 mg candida 10 mg lasix bodybuilding generic cialis brasil cialis 5 mg torrinomedica nexium generic wiki purchase viagra 25mg celebrex generic meloxicam kamagra 100mg gebruik buying prednisone online levitra 10 mg 4 st xatral 10 mg viagra valsartan 80 mg hydrochlorothiazide hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg cp generic 5 mg. cialis viagra usa buy buy propecia cvs cialis 20 or 40 mg cialis 20 mg tab kamagra 50mg paypal lisinopril 40mg tablet metformin 500 mg cmax cialis kopen online buy lisinopril online online xenical stronger cialis 2.5mg review thuoc phenergan 25mg cheap kamagra paypal 5mg brand cialis cialis 10mg comprar cialis pills cheap lasix 40mg emagrece hydrochlorothiazide online zoloft 50 mg sevrage diflucan prospect 150 mg buy bactrim us viagra online makedonija metformin 500 mg tab herbal viagra cheap viagra 25 mg бra cheap viagra 25 buy 10 mg lexapro augmentin antibiotico 500 mg diflucan 600 mg remedio cipro 500 mg zoloft 100mg prices 5mg cialis pricing pastillas xenical genericos viagra cheap paypal clomid 5omg tablets generic ert viagra buy viagra capsules zithromax 500mg buy viagra buy toronto order levitra india celebrex price generic propecia online shipping prednisone buy canada online levitra purchase lexapro 20 mg sleep viagra 200mg online cheap viagra shop generic medication metformin cialis caverject 120 mg zovirax medicinale generico order free viagra cipro registrations online doxycycline buy price cytotec 200 mg tablet cialis online stores 5 m mg cialis tetracycline 1000 mg viagra de 25mg cialis sverige generic bestlife generic viagra lasix 40 mg rezeptfrei nolvadex liquid buy danger levitra 40 mg cheapest valtrex online kamagra 100mg term clomid buy nz 20mg cialis take 2 lexapro 10 mg presentacion prednisone 4 mg mexico cialis 10 mg effetto cheap augmentin 875 viagra tablet 100mg celebrex cap 400 mg cipro xr generic cheap cialis india generic strattera pills cialis c50 online 550 mg zoloft nolvadex tamoxifen 20mg walmart generic lexapro 2012 lasix 80 mg online cytotec 200 mg vidal 150 mg wellbutrin alcohol 1500 mg metformin clomid amoxil 250 mg liquid 300 mg of diflucan viagra online masterrcard cialis generico germania prednisone 400mg Levitra 120 pills order 30 mg lexapro withdrawal order levitra canada 25mg generic viagra clomid nome generico starting 5 mg lexapro celebrex 200 mg prezzo cost lisinopril 10 mg lisinopril 30 mg w953 viagra online xplosion valtrex online sales online viagra emails erythromycin 20mg generic viagra facts cialis prijs 5 mg cialis 3600 mg cialis online apotheken buy kamagra cialis bactrim 10mg ic propranolol 80 mg nexium 40mg spain bactrim generico cheap kamagra.com viagra 25 mg review buy clomid vancouver cialis buy chea inhaltsstoffe cialis 20mg herbal 600mg viagra cipro 500mg directions buy viagra chicago buy propecia 5 mg buy cheap clomid cialis 10 mg walmart propecia tablets 0.2mg lexapro 20 mg bijsluiter 200 mg phenergan lisinopril electrolyte disorders 30 generic cialis softtabs generic medication lasix order lasix online propranolol cheap buy cheap priligy generic levitra used dosis augmentin 875 mg buy cialis worldwide celebrex 200mg youtube 50mg equivalent viagra drg generic viagra zithromax 1000 buy lisinopril 20 mg recreational vidal viagra 100mg cialis 10 mg controindicazioni us viagra online celebrex 200 mg obat 600 mg kamagra order doxycycline cat xenical tablets 120mg metformin er generic kamagra 100 gold cheap cialis 20 mg everyday lisinopril hctz 40 25 mg gen 40mg levitra philippines buy propecia buy kamagra fuerteventura 5 mg cialis prices propranolol 80 mg tablet mail order levitra cheap 2.5 mg cialis xenical buy nz lexapro 10 mg pregnancy buy cipro paypal clomid 100mg grossesse two 10mg cialis cialis 5 mg filmtabletta wellbutrin generic teva 10 mg prednisone 3 days 50mg zoloft anxiety cheaper than nexium frequency metformin 500mg tetracycline 250 mg buy viagra maryland levitra online 20mg thuoc metformin 500mg 100mg viagra uk bactrim 600mg cialis gel buy lisinopril hctz 10 12.5 mg buy viagra queensland viagra sordera generic medicine nexium generic cialis canadian cialis online greece very cheap cialis levitra 10 mg fta 4 metformin 500 mg scored 20 mg doxycycline acne Levitra 10 pills order buy clomid 500mg buying cialis malaysia levitra 20 mg pakistan brand priligy online cialis 10 mg kaufen order viagra discreetly