Home / Features / What is Literary Value?

What is Literary Value?

The post about the ways that people criticize self-publishing brings up the idea that a traditionally published book has a stamp of approval and so traditionally published books are more reliable.  This is true.  Some amount of vetting does count for something, but in an age when it’s more difficult to get published, it is not the only measure of a book’s worth.

What’s also problematic is that writers may take this one step further and consider that their writing is indeed better because it has been accepted by an editor.  I don’t want to limit the idea that getting accepted by an editor and receiving a paycheck is enormously validating.  Of course it is.  I’ve been traditionally published as well with Soft Skull Press in the U.S., Canongate in the U.K., and Hachette Litteratures in France.  I come to self-publishing with a sense of both sides of the aisle.

But just because a book has been accepted by an editor does not mean it is automatically better – and dispelling this idea could help self-published books gain more clout, and reduce the amount of prejudice.

Let’s look at a writer like Jack Kerouac.  Most people think of Kerouac as a fifties writer.  Actually, Kerouac was going on the road in the late forties, after the war.  On the Road was written in 1951 – but it was not published until 1957, towards the end of the decade.  Jack Kerouac did most of the writing that’s part of his legacy before On the Road was ever published.  Is On the Road a better book in 1957 than it was when it was initially written in 1951?  I think most people would say no: publication doesn’t determine worth.  The book is the book.

Take other writers like Herman Melville and F. Scott Fitzgerald.  They both died unheralded and Moby Dick and Gatsby become a part of the literary canon only posthumously.  The same goes with a writer like Philip K. Dick.  Read to some degree while he was alive, but not nearly as regarded as he is today, with editions being put out by the Library of America.  Crime writer Jim Thompson is another one, who had a renaissance in the nineties.

Obviously, not all self-publishers are geniuses like the writers mentioned above.  They don’t have to be.  This is just to point out that a book’s success or lack of success does not determine if a book is worthwhile.  It can take decades for a writer to be discovered and reexamined.

Literary Longevity

One of the major problems in the publishing industry is the fact that they gauge writers one book at a time – if one book doesn’t sell, writers are boxed out.  But really, this isn’t how writing – or any art – unfolds.  Someone said that writers generally write the same book over and over again in different ways.  Not to say those books can’t be unique, but personally I feel like I’m writing one long novel made up of smaller novels.  Each novel builds on the last.

So writers should be gauged on what they’ve accomplished during their entire careers, not based on one or two books.  Supposing a writer self-published five novels, and then the sixth novel gets picked up by a traditional publisher, who then puts out traditionally published editions of the first five books – which are all successful.  Are those five self-published books now better than they were before?  No, because that would be like saying that book sales equals artistic worth.  It doesn’t – it’s just that the books are more accessible now that they’re distributed traditionally.

There is some proof in consensus.  But Dan Brown sells more books than, say, Michael Chabon.  Is Dan Brown a better writer?  “Better” is subjective, not based on sales figures.

This idea that editorial acceptance means that a book is more worthwhile just needs to go away.  Books have worth regardless of an editor’s stamp of approval – even the number of readers.  That’s just an example of how much money has changed hands.  To claim that is proof of a book’s worth is a seriously corrupt model of how art should be valued.

  • http://www.jmreep.com/juvenilia J.M. Reep

    This is an excellent article. It’s true: the literary value of one book over another is entirely subjective. And even when there’s something approaching a consensus — when you encounter many people agreeing about the worth of an author — that consensus is subject to change over time. Today, the consensus would rank Dickinson over Longfellow — but that rank was reversed a century ago.

    And I think all writers — even those who put down self-published authors — recognize that this is true. After all, if there were such a thing as objective literary value, and if agents and publishers made their decisions based on that objective determination, then there wouldn’t be any point in sending a manuscript off to more than one agent or publisher. If literary value were objective, then that first rejection that you would receive would be enough to convince you that your manuscript ought to be thrown in the trash. But the fact that writers send manuscripts and queries to dozens of agents and publishers is at least an implicit recognition that judging the value of a piece of writing is always a subjective process.

  • http://brentrobison.blogspot.com Brent Robison

    You’re absolutely correct, and it’s perhaps even more clear in music, film, and visual art. Acceptance by the industry’s established gatekeepers has no relationship to quality, in either content or execution; as you say, it’s just about “how much money has changed hands.” We live in a celebrity culture that would have us believe that fame equals talent. But I’ve found that whether I want attention from the masses or not is meaningless, because I can only write what I can write. I express who I am, and it does not fit current trends, it falls way outside the zeitgeist, but it is what it is. I’ll be grateful for s small audience of discerning readers; there must be a few who share my sensibilities, and so I’ll count them among my friends. Making a living from my fiction is a fantasy that I can use for a moment’s entertainment, but I’m too old and realistic at this point to imagine my quiet little stories will set the world on fire. Still, if a few people beyond my freinds and family think they’re good, I’m happy. Maybe that’s literary value.

  • Steven Reynolds

    Since Roland Barthes proclaimed “the death of the author” and the emergence of the reader as the sole arbiter of meaning, “literary value” has been seen as an entirely subjective, not to mention deeply suspect, notion – in academic circles at least. No student of literary studies would attempt seriously to define it.

    Back here in the real world, we assign literary value all the time – as individuals and as a culture. I love certain books; I can even come up with my own personal literary canon. So does the culture at large, and here in the English-speaking West that canon would include books as diverse as “The Da Vinci Code”, the Harry Potter series, “The Catcher In The Rye”, “To Kill a Mockingbird” and the Bible.

    People assign literary value for all kinds of reasons: books they enjoyed; books that spoke to them about their own lives; books they read at school and remember fondly; books they feel morally obliged to say they enjoyed, even if they hated them. I’m sure millions of people could assign “literary value” to thousands of self-published novels if only they got the chance to read them. But they don’t. And they won’t get that chance until self-published books get taken seriously by bookstores (because, despite Amazon, physical bookstores are still where most people prefer to browse and buy) and taken seriously by mainstream reviewers in the mainstream media. And that won’t happen until a singular self-published novel comes along that is either so good or so word-of-mouth-popular that it forces the world’s attention en masse towards it, AND the author subsequently REFUSES to sign it over to a mainstream publisher.

    I’m not sure that will ever happen, though. Most self-published authors crave the mainstream’s stamp of literary credibility – of literary value – as much as readers do, don’t they?

  • http://www.johnnydenovo.com Andrew Kent

    A well-executed self-published book (good design interior and exterior, good marketing, good writing, good story, good characters) can erase the perception that the book wasn’t vetted by a traditional publishing house. I still have people congratulating me on being published (and gushing over the book after reading it), which I accept, since it demonstrates that I’ve reached my goal of obscuring the fact that my book is self-published. There is still a stigma, and I wanted to leap it so readers would engage with the book.

    Your statement really resonated with me: “This idea that editorial acceptance means that a book is more worthwhile just needs to go away.” Editorial acceptance is virtually meaningless for fiction as far as assessing its quality. The big publishing houses can assert that they improve the quality of the books they choose, and that their selection process is meaningful, but we’ll never know, will we? Do interventions from commercial agents and editors preserve and enhance a new voice’s interesting qualities or mainstream them out? There’s no transparency without self-publishing to show what can go on otherwise. Given the number and consistency of successful self-published books, I’m becoming convinced the editorial selection and editorial processing of commercial publishers probably weren’t all that helpful to many good writers.

    In some fields — scholarly communication, for instance — peer-review and editorial processes are extremely important, because what is being pursued is an approximation of the truth, if not actual new immutable facts of physics, biology, or earth sciences. The reports of researchers need to be able to withstand a crucible of scrutiny and validated by experts. But for fiction, where it’s art and entertainment, why shut down a motivated author with a story to tell?

    The “scarcity model” of marketing, printing, and distribution is going away. Mass media is fading. Niche media is emerging. The guardians of resources at old-guard publishing houses will have less and less to do as time goes by.

  • http://www.mattybyloos.com Matty Byloos

    This I found yesterday on Bookforum from David Ulin — a great read and another take on Kerouac if anyone is interested.

  • http://www.selfpublishingreview.com Henry Baum

    Great article, thanks for posting that. His cover for OTR is amazing – how is it I’ve never seen that, and how is that an edition was never released with that illustration? It’s amazing that Kerouac still needs to be trumped up as a legitimate writer, and not just a fad or a spokesperson, but an actual artist. A book like “Why Kerouac Matters” shouldn’t have to be written.

  • Harry Toder

    My comment/question does not have anything to do with literary value and self-publishing. I am convinced that a self-published work can have literary value.

    I have another question, for someone to answer: Going the traditional route, is there ever a concern about recycling your work to multiple publishers(in the fact of rejections) that the ideas can be “stolen”(i.e. recast in just different words)? I realize that the likelihood of this is small. Still, an individual who has put in so much work can’t afford to take a chance. One possible value of self-publishing is that it is “submitted” once and accepted. Is the issue that I have brought up ever been referred to before, or is it even a realistic concern?

    Thanks for your help.

    • http://www.selfpublishingreview.com/members/henry-baum/ Henry Baum

      Good question, but honestly I don’t know the rate of stories getting stolen so I’ll have to look into it. I imagine though that a virtually unread self-published book could get stolen as well, and the publisher could claim ignorance about the previous book – with even more cover because the book was never submitted.

      I’d ask this question again in one of the forums because it’s likely that a lot of people won’t see this on an old post.

      • Harry Toder

        Thanks, Henry. Someone was telling me about the “poor man’s copyright”(mailing it to yourself). Once again, I think it unlikely that anyone would risk his/her reputation, but it doesn’t hurt to error on the side of caution.

  • klcrumley

    I agree that it’s all subjective. Look at LORD OF THE RINGS. It has a cult following. You either love it, or hate it.

    I’ve said before and stand by this statement: the ratio of good books and bad books in both forums (SP & TP) is 50/50. I even had a sales girl at Borders tell me about 50% of what she comes across in the store is total trite, overdone garbage & formula fiction.

    OF course it’s all subjective. Today you could meet a person who says ERAGON is crap, but PERN books are “LYK OMG AWESOMENESS11!!!”
    And, one week later you get a person telling you how much Pern books suck…

    ART, as a whole, is subjective. And literature is art.

    IMO, there are more true artists self/indie publishing & small press publishing. And more writers seeking commercial publishing are just looking to “get rich quick.”

    A friend of mine told me she’d rather get commercially published because then her children’s stories can get made into a cartoon…

    I’d be offended if someone made Wishful Thinking into a cartoon. Well an anime film maybe…but not like
    a cutesy, disneyesque thing. That would bother me.

buy kamagra soho clomid generic cost lexapro alternatives generics celebrex 100 mg capsule zoloft 12.5mg propranolol 40 mg tablet propecia generic pakistan clomid 50mg buy order propecia proscar zovirax 800 mg pregnancy zoloft generic forms zithromax 500 mg n2 synthroid 0.025mg co wellbutrin 150 mg experience buying levitra line generic brand levitra augmentin 475 mg prospect levitra 5mg erfahrung doxycycline 200 mg buy phenergan canada cialis 10mg street cialis 20 mg soft cheap levitra viagra strattera 40mg dosis buy nolvadex india original nolvadex 20 mg 10 or 20 mg lexapro generic zithromax 1g buy zoloft usa nexium generic patent buy cipro tablet order brand zithromax buying colombian viagra levitra 20 mg generic using 5mg cialis viagra generico funciona hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg pharmacokinetics lisinopril 2mg pastiglie levitra 10 mg generic lexapro comparison zovirax online price generic cialis chicago prednisone 5mg medicine viagra generic au cialis generic ranbaxy 100 mg synthroid cialis 20 mg brasil 10 or 20mg cialis strattera generic 2011 zovirax ung generic prices cialis 5mg 25 mg viagra recreational order periactin order viagra usa intravenous lasix 20mg celebrex 200mg medicine prednisone dog 5mg prednisone dogs online cheapest kamagra gels levitra 20 mg bestellen nolvadex 40mg ed generic viagra grece online prescription diflucan lisinopril teva 10 mg cipro 500mg xl zoloft mg dose koop kamagra online lisinopril 40 mg viagra 50mg reviews augmentin 875 mg generic cialis 20 mg information propecia generic propecia levitra 10 mg 4 comp generic viagra quality doxycycline 400 mg tablet cialis 5mg tallinna propecia buy boots lexapro generic pap mg viagra 325lb levitra not workimg cheap xenical thailand buy cheapest cialis wellbutrin 450 mg review cialis 60mg levitra 100mg facts cialis tadora generic viagra generic medication 10 mg cialis review 50 mg equivalent viagra strattera 10 mg fiyat 5mg cialis tablets viagra online fda diflucan generic walgreens buy propecia review clomid buying online viagra sildenafil 50 mg 5mg lexapro nausea propranolol 20 a 40 mg zithromax injection 500mg zoloft vs generics erythromycin thiocyanate buyer information viagra 100mg generic prednisone 6 pack 10 mg cialis online propecia vs. generic wellbutrin generic a102 lisinopril 20 mg infarmed lexapro 15 mg reviews about viagra 800mg wellbutrin xl cheapest australian online viagra augmentin 156 mg syrup glucophage 1000 mg kullanimi generic viagra indian levitra buy discount valtrex generic equivalent prednisone pack 4 mg 1 cialis 5mg prednisone 1mg qualitest nexium iv 40 mg buy zovirax ointment buy cipro 500mg generic lisinopril safe buy doxycycline prescription generic cialis propecia cheapest online valtrex caplets 500mg 500mg cipro strep viagra online doctissimo aust generic viagra propranolol 40 mg overdose valtrex 5 mg generic strattera canada generic 25mg viagra propranolol hcl 60 mg augmentin 375 mg cena doxycycline 100mg eyes levitra 100mg varmi xenical buy melbourne generic viagra alp fungsi doxycycline 50 mg prednisone 20 mg phenergan generic price lexapro generic paronia nolvadex 20 mg nebenwirkungen lasix 60 mg tablet cialis buy cheap kesan clomid 50 mg wikipedia 150 mg viagra erythromycin buy canada diflucan 60 mg xenical cheap online diflucan 100 mg zoloft berapa mg cheap fast kamagra generic cialis kolkata generic levitra article wellbutrin 150 mg precio zovirax buy usa cheap legal viagra viagra 100 mg uso buy viagra 20mg buy generic amoxil erythromycin motility disorders amoxil online cats 1 5mg propecia propecia cheap purchase glucophage generic metformin lexapro cheap prescription dosis lexapro 10 mg metformin teva 850 mg generic viagra europe buying 5mg propecia order cialis here clomid order paypal buy doxycycline suspension buy clomid 100mg viagra 25mg preis levitra 20mg generika cialis precio 5 mg diflucan 150 mg homme levitra price online propecia australia 5mg viagra purchase online genericky cialis prednisone arrow 5 mg viagra buy sildenafil viagra online bali doxycycline 15 mg nexium 20mg breastfeeding metformin 1500mg xenical buy singapore levitra 20 mg priceing lexapro 10mg india ordering levitra online cialis generic manufacturer cipro 500mg paypal cialis everyday online nbieding cialis 5 mg prednisone burst 200 mg buy doxycycline nairobi metformin hcl 1000mg buy viagra where zovirax generic canada 50mg zoloft pregnant amoxil 500 mg suspension sintofarm propranolol 10 mg cod generic cialis kamagra 100mg nebenwirkungen cheap viagra 50mg prednisone 50mgm levitra pills 10mg efeito viagra 100mg generic cialis health cialis online order metformin buy australia strattera 60 mg fiyat buy clomid store viagra cobra buy cialis 5 mg comprar pastillas cialis 20 mg kamagra 8000mg lisinopril 25 mg dosage nexium 40 mg online cheapest uk cialis glucophage 500 mg daily buy lexapro overnight lexapro 5mg fatigue lisinopril 2.5 mg generic brand cialis zovirax 200mg tablet prospect viagra 50 mg harga nexium 10 mg xenical online us lexapro 10 mg breastfeeding canadian cheap cialis buy injectable zithromax generic viagra gel diflucan 150 mg cena blackking generic viagra lasix 400 mg 150 mg clomid follicles cialis 80 mg buy cialis 20 mg confezione generic phenergan medication celebrex 200mg cena zithromax dogs buy zithromax online paypal strattera mg doses 10 mg levitra online lupin lisinopril 5mg zithromax 500 mg prospecto buying viagra dublin price lexapro generic levitra 10 mg siparis buy viagra humboldt buy cialis 75 cents cialis mg strength nexium 20 mg contraindicaciones generic lisinopril 2.5 mg propecia go generic kamagra 100 mg contrareembolso lisinopril anxiety disorder levitra tablet 60 mg 230mg viagra lexapro generico colombia buy celebrex usa buy strattera prescription acquisto levitra generico viagra pills online generic cialis c 800 cialis online china brand cialis 100mg prednisone 20 mg withdrawal diflucan 100 mg costs generic cialis exists 5 mg dose lexapro cialis buy quebec doxycycline 50 mg cost cialis 100mg 20mg cialis pills 5mg 800 generic viagra online buy levitra johor generic propecia available 2011 buying online viagra prednisone 50 mg po zoloft 200 mg dosage where order cialis viagra generica farmacias canada viagra 50 mg ic propranolol 40mg toronto viagra online 30 mg lexapro dose kaufen viagra online 1000 mg metformin hydrochloride buy genuine xenical cialis 10mg indonesia cialis 2.5 mg dosage generic wellbutrin reviews hydrochlorothiazide 125 mg generic levitra reliability cialis 20mg cpr 4 order sertraline zoloft meds supportonline lexapro viagra generic 2019 prednisone 80 mg daily 30 levitra 10 mg holland strattera 18 mg generic viagra spray strattera 60 mg bijwerkingen hydrochlorothiazide tab 25 mg levitra original 10mg taking 25 mg clomid cheapest cialis uk order viagra cheap phenergan suppository 12.5 mg cialis 5 mg prodaja valtrex stomach disorder online viagra liquid lexapro generic equivalent kamagra ert 100 mg doxycycline dci 100 mg lasix tabletten 40 mg walgreens cialis 20mg malaysia buy cialis kamagra tablets 5 mg buy 40mg cialis dosage levitra 20mg buy generic dapoxetine kamagra 100mg chewable 30 mg lexapro breastfeeding lupin lisinopril 5 mg 750 mg wellbutrin zoloft generic problems cialis 20 mg malaysia viagra 50mg relato zithromax 500 mg azithromycin soft generic viagra prednisone 500 mg daily lexapro 10 mg uso propranolol 20mg bula glucophage metformina 850 mg effetti cialis 20 mg fast cialis online lexapro generic date buying legit viagra metformin 1000 mg day kamagra order silagra cialis 40mg cipla walgreens wellbutrin generic buy viagra australia erythromycin 333 mg dosage zoloft 100mg reviews prednisone 7 mg generic viagra 150 mg. 1000 mg augmentin dosage 25mg viagra experiences lexapro generic discussion propecia 5 mg online generic metformin xr apa nexium 20mg generic viagra onlineusa is cialis generic propecia 1mg cost viagra plus 100 mg. buy priligy buy cialis jakarta viagra 50 mg erfahrung buy unprescribed clomid buy safe propecia 20mg lisinopril buy nexium dublin medicamento celebrex 100 mg cialis 2 x 5mg zoloft ou generico 12 viagra 100mg cialis pills cheap prednisone 20mg watson valtrex 500 mg posologia cialis 2.5 buy online viagra 100 mg endikasyonlari medco generic propecia viagra 100mg 4 st cialis 40mg day 60 mg prednisone breastfeeding cheapest propecia generic 360 xenical online 120mg generic clomid 100mg cipro 500mg generic levitra 10 mg kaina buy zovirax canada cipro 500 mg espanol levitra 20mg longevity hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg usos viagra femenina generico levitra de 100 mgs buspar 15 mg dosage kamagra order online take 2 10mg cialis ranbaxy generic viagra celebrex 200 mg malaysia xenical 120 mg acheter prednisone 20mg effects prednisone pill mg clomid 150mg ovulation zithromax bestellen online buy lasix canada clomid 50mg pregnant levitra 20mg france propecia finasteride cheap 30 mg nolvadex discount viagra generic cytotec tab 200 mg cialis buy france lexapro generico anvisa order propecia 1mg online pharmacy zovirax viagra buy thailand propranolol 20 mg bid doxycycline 100mg horses generic strattera 10 mg nexium generic costco lexapro 10 mg contraindicaciones lexapro 5 mg tired cipla clomid 100mg doxycycline malaria 100mg buy doxycycline cvs valtrex order online doxycycline 100 mg kat online philippines viagra farmaco generico augmentin cheap legit cialis order cialis generic cipro 750 mg bid lasix 40mg thuoc buy cytotec uae lisinopril 20 mg safe zithromax 500 mg used lexapro 30 mg dosage compuesto generico viagra metformin 4000 mg cialis 10 mg sulit generic lexapro 2012 price wellbutrin generic wellbutrin bactrim 875 mg 100mg clomid zwanger celebrex 200 mg alkohol generic stats viagra buspar backorder ordering bactrim online viagra generic uae strattera 60 mg uk levitra 20mg nedir cialis ordering online cialis dosage 40mg prednisone 50mg beneficiios zithromax klamydia 500 mg 5 mg prednisone daily 25mg viagra pills nexium 40 mg pvp buy viagra doha viagra 200mg pfizer cheap cialis 32 singapore buy nolvadex cialis 20 mg brands stopping zoloft 50 mg lisinopril 40 mg tabl harga nexium 40 mg cialis 20mg tabs levitra tablets 100mg viagra 50mg sverige viagra 25 mg srbij clomid uk order prednisone 5 mg bronchitis zovirax 400mg dose cialis 20mg almanya npr wellbutrin generic metformin 1500 mg daily 1000 mg zithromax chlamydia levitra original online lexapro alternatives generic viagra generico dosis levitra 20mg cpr 8 viagra 100mg apotheke augmentin buy online propranolol 10 mg contraindicaciones generic nexium when propecia 4mg prednisone 2 mg day viagra 50mg buying prescription levitra 20mg aquisto viagra generico generic levitra review propecia biotin 5 mg cialis thailand buy nexium esomeprazol 20mg purchase cheap viagra 400mg of zithromax xenical generic online viagra generic legitimate