Home / Member Blog / Paid Reviews – A Reality Check

Paid Reviews – A Reality Check

FireShot Screen Capture #591 - 'About I Caribbean Book Blog' - caribbeanbookblog_wordpress_com_aboutThe New York Times exposé on the infamous GettingBookReviews.com and the shenanigans of its founder Todd Jason Rutherford, has unleashed the mother of firestorms on the Internet. Bloggers from all over the blogosphere have pounced on the scandal and many of them are gleefully fanning the flames. Smelling blood, some traditionally published writers are circling the indie publishing camp, happy to remind all who care to listen that they had been warned.

Initially, the source of the public outrage was the mercenary nature of Rutherford’s book-review scheme and the blatant collusion of writers like John Locke. Justifiably, many viewed the whole business as a web of deception, totally dishonest and unscrupulous.

Increasingly, though, the focus of the criticisms seems to be shifting. For many it’s the whole business of paid book reviews that’s the problem, not just Todd Rutherford et al.

I get the impression that there’s long been a widespread perception, especially among readers, that genuine book reviewers, including those who critique books for newspapers and trade magazines, are not paid for their services; that they’re just volunteers. This, of course, is far from the truth. It’s a misconception that I think needs to be debunked once and for all.

Normally, publishers send free review copies to publications who then pass the books on to reviewers.

Publishers Weekly currently has a deal with Amazon and Barnes & Noble. According to Slate.com, “Their reviews — 300 or so words of plot summary, context, and a quick verdict — influence which books get noticed, bought, and promoted in the media.” PW reviewers are reportedly paid $45 to $60 per review.

Patti Thorn, former book editor of the Rocky Mountain News and co-founder of BlueInk Review, said that when she started out as an editor, she “inherited five reviewers who were getting paid a measly $20 per review.” Meagre as it was, the bottom line is they were not expected to be volunteers. Evidently, Thorn not only believes book reviewers deserve remuneration, she feels they ought to be well paid for their services. As cofounder of Blueink Review she can now declare unabashedly, “We pay our reviewers well by book review standards …  and we require informed, professional evaluations in return.”

Patricia Ann Jones, a professional book reviewer for The Tulsa World told the business website Business Know-How.com, ”Some papers pay very little, some not at all. Then, there is the New York Times which pays very well indeed. The Los Angeles Times also pays upwards of $300 for a review, more depending on the reviewers’ expertise and reputation.”

Publications like Writers’ Market Deluxe Edition, Writer’s Digest Books and classified sections of writing magazines such as Writer’s Digest and Poets & Writers provide copious listings of publications that pay for book reviews.

Can we trust a reviewer who is a salaried employee of a newspaper or a freelancer paid by an editor? Some say yes because there’s a firewall between the reviewer and the author of the book. What’s more, strict guidelines are enforced and due diligence is taken to ensure their reviews are independent and unbiased. Interestingly, few, if any are fazed by the fact that many of the publishers whose authors’ books are reviewed in publications like PW and the New York Review of Books (especially the so-called ‘Big Six’) help to sustain those publications with advertising. Magazines and newspapers live or die on advertising revenue.

When the New York Review of Books hires an author to review a book released by a publisher that is a regular advertiser in the NYRB can we expect the review to be unbiased? What if the reviewer and the book’s author share the same publisher? Does this compromise the publication and negate its ability to ensure its reviews are genuine? Not necessarily. The general consensus is that the checks and balances instituted by these publications, and the firewalls they have erected between reviewers and authors, will hold and keep everyone honest.

But what about publications like PW Select, PW’s new quarterly supplement specially designed for self-published books – a venture which caused raised eyebrows when it was unveiled. If you’re a self-published writer and you’ve got $149 to burn, they encourage you to invest it in PW Select to gain access to their readership. If you’re lucky, your book could even end up among the “approximately 25%” selected for a published review in each supplement. Is PW likely to have second thoughts as a result of the New York Times exposé? Don’t bet on it!

Texas novelist Clay Reynolds was a longstanding PW book reviewer. In The Texas Institute of Letters Newsletter (February, 2004), he gave a behind-the-scenes look into PW’s review policies and that of other publications, including the Library Journal, Kirkus Review and the New York Times Book Review. He made a very interesting disclosure about PW’s review practices.

“What’s interesting about the PW reviews, though, is that copy is sometimes altered before printing. On a few occasions, I’ve had opinions utterly reversed from what I wrote. I’ve questioned this, but I’ve never received satisfactory answers. I keep doing it because it’s good work and satisfies the university administration.”

It would be naive to assume that because a reviewer is being paid indirectly and not by an author, he or she is immune to being influenced or pressured by whoever is paying them. Still, this is simply not enough to justify me doubting a review publication’s integrity or its willingness to ensure the integrity of its reviewers.

Why, then, is it assumed that a publication like PW or the New York Review of Books has an inherently stronger firewall, and a more robust commitment to honesty and integrity than, say, the US Review of books, Blue Ink Review, or for that matter Self Publishing Review? Why should we automatically assume that the Establishment Media can get their reviewers to follow guidelines and write honest reviews, while other providers of review services can’t do the same, simply because they charge authors for reviews?

Try telling that to the venerable Kirkus Reviews (they now offer paid reviews to indie authors for a cool $425 or $525 for express service) or try running it by Blueink Review who maintain, “Our reviews are taken seriously by publishers, agents, booksellers and librarians.”

  • http://www.dedzone.net/ DED

    Thank you, Mr. Williams. That was an informative piece.

online clinic viagra metformin 1000 mg spc erythromycin filmtab 500mg erythromycin order online buy viagra budapest cialis 5 mg two generic nolvadex bodybuilding zovirax comprimido 400 mg ic propranolol 80 mg formula celebrex 200 mg nexium generic cost cialis 3800mg generic lexapro reaction cheapest generic zoloft strattera 40 mg wirkung obat doxycycline 100mg xenical tablets 120mg oral doxycycline online viagra cheap line buy amoxil 1g priligy 60 mg kaufen generic cialis purchase order 100mmg. viagra pill nolvadex online lisinopril 10 10 mg tab lisinopril 20 mg tabl buy xenical australia 40mg de cialis doxycycline 500mg use cialis 20 mg safe cialis cipla generic buy cialis mexico 10mg cialis taking 2 cialis reviews 5 mg diflucan 150 mg бra order diflucan canada cialis 5mg superdrug prednisone 10 mg image cialis generica 40mg cipro denk 500 mg amoxil 500 mg cena prednisone dosage 25mg buy kamagra cialis clomid buy nz nexium highest mg kamagra generic cialis cvs cialis 5 mg any generic viagra tarifs cialis 10 mg clomid success 100mg viagra online 2 days viagra online legality 12.5 mg viagra enough cheapest line viagra metformin hcl 50mg lisinopril cheap order Cialis Jelly 90 cheap geniue viagra apo prednisone 5 mg generic levitra 2.5 zithromax 140 mg buy viagra lahore lexapro 5 mg deutschland cialis 20 mg lisboa order nolvadex australia lisinopril hctz 10 12.5 mg strattera 10 mg cost levitra generic forum cipro xl buy buy real nolvadex cialis coupon 5 mg reliable online viagra 50 mg generic viagra doxycycline capsules generic viagra 150 mg kaufen generic propecia 1 year buy ranbaxy doxycycline costo diflucan 100 mg buying cialis malaysia nolvadex tablets 10mg generic sub bactrim buy nolvadex australia lasix 500mg tablet viagra order review buy viagra phitzer propranolol 160 mg anxiety cialis 5 mg bula cialis 20mg melbourne cialis 50mg tadalafiili zithromax 1000 mg buy 800 mg viagra online doxycycline bipolar disorder buy viagra qatar 40 mg cialis australia propecia 5mg buy prednisone 400mg levitra 10mg experiences buying cialis tablets laboratorio nexium 40mg lexapro 30 mg pregnancy pfizer viagra 50 mg nolvadex 20 mg precio buy prednisone mexico xenical 120 mg temoignages mail order clomid clomid 12.5 mg testosterone lisinopril online generic 50 mg clomid triplets doxycycline 100mg drinking cialis 5 mg beipackzettel levitra generikum 20mg 10mg lisinopril manufacturers cheap buspar buy priligy dapoxetine viagra onlinesouth africa nexium backorder buy prednisone dogs viagra 100mg testbericht viagra tablet 100mg diflucan 2 pill 150 mg cialis 100mg japan efeito viagra generico lisinopril 7.5mg generic online viagra prednisone taper 20 mg buy 25 mg viagra india viagra order refrigerate generic bactrim kamagra 120 mg synthroid prescription online 5mg lexapro panic cipro 250mg tab beipackzettel cialis 20mg cialis 20mg sa viagra generics philippines 20mg cialis effects cheap cytotec philippines comanda cialis 10 mg buspar 120 mg lasix ret. 60 mg buy levitra pen cheap online viagra zoloft generic price generic propecia target buy cheap diflucan viagra 100mg preisvergleich 24 hour cialis online zovirax online shopping wellbutrin 100 mg daily 200 mg viagra fine cialis 20 mg murah lexapro 10 mg pregnancy afbouwen lexapro 10 mg buy lexapro 5mg viagra peru buying viagra 800 mg opis cheapest viagra pfizer buy Cialis 60 pills wellbutrin xl 225 mg kamagra 800mg tabletki clomid 50 mg 10 tablets cialis 20 mg prijs nexium 80mg nexium 40 mg romania online prescriptions viagra strattera 10 mg nonstimulant cialis 20mg achat lasix retard 60 mg cialis 2.5 mg sverige metformin xr 1500mg propecia tablets 0.2mg lexapro generic of lexapro 10mg 15mg cialis 20 or 40 mg cipro 1000 mg 5 day 100mg of clomid zithromax 500 mg cvs zithromax 1000 mg uses wellbutrin 150 xl generic cialis 10 mg directions generic viagra 150 mg. nebenwirkungen metformin 850 mg cialis 20mg order wellbutrin sr 75 mg levitra 20mg wirkung celebrex 200mg pret cialis 5 mg filmtabletta nexium generic protonix glucophage 1500 mg priligy 30 mg n1 infarmed cialis 5mg viagra bali buy viagra orders online zuzahlung nexium 20mg lexapro generic new metformin sr 500 mg viagra purchase buy diflucan 150 mg gravidanza augmentin xr 1000mg 5mg prednisone safe generic cialis nosebleed nexium 40mg bid generic viagra lerk generic viagra same augmentin 875 mg indicaciones generic female viagra celebrex going generic generic propecia sandoz order propecia singapore venda viagra online frequency metformin 500mg lisinopril 2.5 mg buy viagra condoms doxycycline 500mg capsules celebrex 200 mg image doxycycline 100mg dosering prednisone 500 mg prednisone buy uk generico viagra araujo buy viagra italy zithromax 1000mg synthroid 50mg 2.5 mg lisinopril tab erythromycin 500 mg strongest generic cialis generig viagra 50mg wellbutrin sr 100mg 1500 mg tetracycline lady generic cialis tab zovirax 800 mg buy generic priligy cialis pharmacy online buy viagra cheap buy augmentin 625mg buy levitra noida nexium compresse 40 mg levitra 5 mg generico celebrex 200 mg ndc zithromax capsule buy doxycycline 100mg ingredients cialis 80 mg bali prednisone 10mg online levitra dispersible 5 mg buy cipro hcl nexium 40 mg notice prednisone 100 mg cheapest super cialis kamagra oral 5 mg 30 mg lexapro review levitra generic 40 mg lasix 40mg emagrece cibla generic propecia prednisone veterinary buy lexapro 20 online generic lexapro alcohol cialis 5mgsouth africawholesale strattera 100 mg high viagra online colombia buy effervescent cialis 1000 mg zithromax malaysia cialis 100mg portugues cytotec online order cs online viagra 50 mg cialis cialis online affidabile glucophage 1000 mg overdose buy clomid now glucophage 850 mg posologie sublingual cialis 50mg clomid generic philippines cheapest reputable viagra 20 mg cialis daily zithromax 500 mg opis cheap cialis sale cif amoxil 500 mg buy 100 mg viagra diflucan one 50mg two 20mg cialis phenergan 12.5 mg gel lasix generic oxycontin metformin 250 mg day diflucan 200 mg candida levitra 10 mg beneficios zovirax 5mg cream buy Cialis 120 Tabs 50 mg clomid pregnancy buy viagra cebu viagra generico seguro cheap synthroid online buy kamagra gold clomid 2 9 100mg pregnant xenical 120 mg dawkowanie kamagra kopen online order propecia pills thuoc diflucan 150 mg viagra tab 100mg hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg tabs herb viagra 6800 mg cheaper than viagra diflucan pfizer online lasix 20 mg daily celebrex 200mg beipackzettel cheap viagra 150mgs generico cialis contrareembolso lisinopril 2.5 mg effects efecto cialis 5mg viagra and generic buying viagra vietnam viagra 100mg blue cialis 5 mg philippines glucophage retard 1000mg generic cialis talafadil lexapro 10 mg migraine cialis 2.5 mg box guaranteed generic viagra but viagra online viagra buy camden buy viagra liquid prednisone 20mg day viagra generic london viagra buy dubai cialis 5 mg review 20 mg lexapro depression cialis de 5mg buy xenical reductil viagra de 25mg dosis levitra 20mg metformin ranbaxy 500mg diflucan generic order amoxil online splitting 100mg levitra viagra buy chennai generic viagra manly 10mg cialis cost cialis online 40mg erythromycin 40mg compare cialis online costco generic lexapro zithromax 500 mg 3 buy augmentin online viagra online makedonija buy tetracycline 250 mg cheapest viagra 25mg prednisone 4 mg mexico levitrabuy cheap levitra clomid 100 mg twins zithromax 40mg ml 200 mg of strattera amoxil 150mg get cialis online viagra 25 mg opinioni cipro tendon disorder valtrex generic alternative viagra cheap cod diflucan 150 mg beipackzettel nexium 40 mg valor prednisone 50 mg po clomid 250mg success lexapro 20 mg good kamagra online india nebenwirkungen levitra 5mg propecia apteka online cialis 5mg mexico hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg dosage buy viagra colombia 5mg cialis pricing propecia online drugstore cialis ricetta online zoloft 12.5 mg dose opinion cialis generico zithromax online prices wellbutrin generic 300 mg zoloft greenstone generic generic cialis lowestprice cialis 5mg diario reviews lisinopril 20 mg viagra mexico border viagra online 180 buy diflucan sample viagra 100 mg daily prednisone 30 mg dose clomid 50mg testosterone generic viagra 100 tabs 10 mg propranolol pregnancy celebrex 200mg espanol cheap cialis 500mg zovirax generic valtrex buy cialis worldwide strattera 25 mg color online doctor xenical lexapro buying line 50mg equivalent viagra valtrex generic pills metformin 500 mg beipackzettel cialis 20mg kohlpharma xenical capsulas 120 mg strattera cheap online prednisone taper 7.5 mg valtrex order lexapro order canada celebrex 250 mg levitra online usa purchase cialis 20 mg drug doxycycline 100mg cheapest online propecia wellbutrin 120 mg viagra generika 50mg cipro 500mg directions doxycycline 20mg online celebrex online order generic strattera 10 mg pfizer online viagra prednisone 60 mg surgery cialis caverject 120 mg viagra 25mg 50mg online prescriptions cialis cialis 5mg forum prezzi cialis 20 mg wholesale cialis 20mg viagra generico comprar france buy viagra phifer viagra online buy 50mg kamagra viagra generico 50 mg generic alli orlistat nexium 40 mg overdose propranolol 120 mg daily lasix tablets 20 mg metformin 1000 mg ratiopharm cialis tabl.20mg buy diflucan express propranolol 10 mg migraine celebrex 750 mg celebrex 100 mg forum vanzare online viagra order viagra maryland valtrex order online beli clomid online generic name clomid amoxil 500 mg gravidez lisinopril mylan generic cialis 20 mg posologie clomid 200mg cialis generic timetable existe generico viagra generic lexapro images xenical roche buy 500 mg generic viagra 250 mg doxycycline lasix 200 mg buy xenical uk buy clomid pills valtrex online prescription cipro quin 500 mg migraine lisinopril 10mg buy viagra 20mg cialis 10 mg erfahrungen viagra generico venta online xenical precio strattera 40 mg cialis online espana nexium prices 40mg buy cialis review reliable generic cialis glucophage 850 mg metformin pastillas cialis 5 mg cialis 5 mg daily viagra online switzerland propranolol tablets 10 mg viagra gold cheap zoloft 300mg daily generic cialis 30 days generic propecia meinung buy cialis delhi celebrex 200 mg namecommunity cialis 100mg cena strattera 80 mg pricing propecia online 1.25 mg propranolol 40 mg retard levitra 20 mg walmart buying metformin online levitra apotheke online buy propecia 5 mg online eczane cialis generic wellbutrin expensive viagra 2.5 mg price buy viagra oman metformin 500 mg tab lexapro anxiety disorders cialis online au cialis 60 mg cheap 800mg cialis reivew buy valtrex generic clomid generic generic propecia walgreens buy viagra singles xenical nome generico levitra tablets online cheap viagra .50 cents cialis 5mg bula