Home / Member Blog / Paid Reviews – A Reality Check

Paid Reviews – A Reality Check

FireShot Screen Capture #591 - 'About I Caribbean Book Blog' - caribbeanbookblog_wordpress_com_aboutThe New York Times exposé on the infamous GettingBookReviews.com and the shenanigans of its founder Todd Jason Rutherford, has unleashed the mother of firestorms on the Internet. Bloggers from all over the blogosphere have pounced on the scandal and many of them are gleefully fanning the flames. Smelling blood, some traditionally published writers are circling the indie publishing camp, happy to remind all who care to listen that they had been warned.

Initially, the source of the public outrage was the mercenary nature of Rutherford’s book-review scheme and the blatant collusion of writers like John Locke. Justifiably, many viewed the whole business as a web of deception, totally dishonest and unscrupulous.

Increasingly, though, the focus of the criticisms seems to be shifting. For many it’s the whole business of paid book reviews that’s the problem, not just Todd Rutherford et al.

I get the impression that there’s long been a widespread perception, especially among readers, that genuine book reviewers, including those who critique books for newspapers and trade magazines, are not paid for their services; that they’re just volunteers. This, of course, is far from the truth. It’s a misconception that I think needs to be debunked once and for all.

Normally, publishers send free review copies to publications who then pass the books on to reviewers.

Publishers Weekly currently has a deal with Amazon and Barnes & Noble. According to Slate.com, “Their reviews — 300 or so words of plot summary, context, and a quick verdict — influence which books get noticed, bought, and promoted in the media.” PW reviewers are reportedly paid $45 to $60 per review.

Patti Thorn, former book editor of the Rocky Mountain News and co-founder of BlueInk Review, said that when she started out as an editor, she “inherited five reviewers who were getting paid a measly $20 per review.” Meagre as it was, the bottom line is they were not expected to be volunteers. Evidently, Thorn not only believes book reviewers deserve remuneration, she feels they ought to be well paid for their services. As cofounder of Blueink Review she can now declare unabashedly, “We pay our reviewers well by book review standards …  and we require informed, professional evaluations in return.”

Patricia Ann Jones, a professional book reviewer for The Tulsa World told the business website Business Know-How.com, ”Some papers pay very little, some not at all. Then, there is the New York Times which pays very well indeed. The Los Angeles Times also pays upwards of $300 for a review, more depending on the reviewers’ expertise and reputation.”

Publications like Writers’ Market Deluxe Edition, Writer’s Digest Books and classified sections of writing magazines such as Writer’s Digest and Poets & Writers provide copious listings of publications that pay for book reviews.

Can we trust a reviewer who is a salaried employee of a newspaper or a freelancer paid by an editor? Some say yes because there’s a firewall between the reviewer and the author of the book. What’s more, strict guidelines are enforced and due diligence is taken to ensure their reviews are independent and unbiased. Interestingly, few, if any are fazed by the fact that many of the publishers whose authors’ books are reviewed in publications like PW and the New York Review of Books (especially the so-called ‘Big Six’) help to sustain those publications with advertising. Magazines and newspapers live or die on advertising revenue.

When the New York Review of Books hires an author to review a book released by a publisher that is a regular advertiser in the NYRB can we expect the review to be unbiased? What if the reviewer and the book’s author share the same publisher? Does this compromise the publication and negate its ability to ensure its reviews are genuine? Not necessarily. The general consensus is that the checks and balances instituted by these publications, and the firewalls they have erected between reviewers and authors, will hold and keep everyone honest.

But what about publications like PW Select, PW’s new quarterly supplement specially designed for self-published books – a venture which caused raised eyebrows when it was unveiled. If you’re a self-published writer and you’ve got $149 to burn, they encourage you to invest it in PW Select to gain access to their readership. If you’re lucky, your book could even end up among the “approximately 25%” selected for a published review in each supplement. Is PW likely to have second thoughts as a result of the New York Times exposé? Don’t bet on it!

Texas novelist Clay Reynolds was a longstanding PW book reviewer. In The Texas Institute of Letters Newsletter (February, 2004), he gave a behind-the-scenes look into PW’s review policies and that of other publications, including the Library Journal, Kirkus Review and the New York Times Book Review. He made a very interesting disclosure about PW’s review practices.

“What’s interesting about the PW reviews, though, is that copy is sometimes altered before printing. On a few occasions, I’ve had opinions utterly reversed from what I wrote. I’ve questioned this, but I’ve never received satisfactory answers. I keep doing it because it’s good work and satisfies the university administration.”

It would be naive to assume that because a reviewer is being paid indirectly and not by an author, he or she is immune to being influenced or pressured by whoever is paying them. Still, this is simply not enough to justify me doubting a review publication’s integrity or its willingness to ensure the integrity of its reviewers.

Why, then, is it assumed that a publication like PW or the New York Review of Books has an inherently stronger firewall, and a more robust commitment to honesty and integrity than, say, the US Review of books, Blue Ink Review, or for that matter Self Publishing Review? Why should we automatically assume that the Establishment Media can get their reviewers to follow guidelines and write honest reviews, while other providers of review services can’t do the same, simply because they charge authors for reviews?

Try telling that to the venerable Kirkus Reviews (they now offer paid reviews to indie authors for a cool $425 or $525 for express service) or try running it by Blueink Review who maintain, “Our reviews are taken seriously by publishers, agents, booksellers and librarians.”

  • http://www.dedzone.net/ DED

    Thank you, Mr. Williams. That was an informative piece.

real generic cialis strattera 18 mg kapsul lasix 40 mg cheap online kamagra strattera vs generic strattera 20 mg cipla buy strattera prescription propecia cena 1mg levitra online philippines buying viagra ireland lisinopril 5 mg dosage cipro overdose 1000mg propecia orders lasix 40 mg online 40 mg cialis ed buy 150mg viagra viagra levitra online prijs xenical 120 mg doxycycline 300 mg solu generic viagra coupons buspar 10mg high best generic lexapro viagra online segura propranolol 1 mg 1ml augmentin 80mg buying cialis bangkok powder cialis online discreet viagra online viagra 100mg apotheke rayh. viagra online lasix 40 mg potassium dapoxetine online buy buy cheap nolvadex cheapest nolvadex online pastiglie levitra 10 mg cialis 10 mg forum buy cialis perth buy doxycycline onlinemalaysia generic problem viagra cialis perscription online generic viagra in 2012 order generic clomid zovirax ointment online buy lexapro cod buy kamagra fuerteventura clomid online canada generic viagra ciple viagra buy sweden prednisone 0.5 mg tab deltacortene prednisone 5mg erfahrungen cialis online cialis cheap canadqa new cialis 100 mg lexapro generic date doxycycline 400 buy cialis 5 mg 28 days augmentin 125 mg administrare zoloft 50 mg reviews clomid cheap online brand cialis 10 mg celebrex 100 mg wikipedia buspar 5 mg dosage posologie clomid 25mg roche xenical 120 mg Levitra 120 pills order free cialis online zovirax dispersable 400 mg zovirax buy usa clomid 100mg bijsluiter anwendung levitra 20mg diflucan generic dosage cialis online dangerous propranolol 10mg buy nexium astrazeneca online nexium cheap buy viagra kowloon online brand levitra viagra online nl cheapest periactin hydrochlorothiazide generic brand augmentin 500 mg dosage viagra 100mg pris 10mg lexapro reviews 150 mg clomid follicles clomid days 3 7 50mg mejor viagra generico prednisone usp 5 mg discreetly buying cialis ordering valtrex online instant cheapest viagra buy levitra.ca cialis 10mg generic comprar cialis 10mg buy propecia ireland drug lasix 40 mg mgus cialis nexium 160 mg lisinopril 30 mg 3762 xenical 120 mg drug pattaya buying viagra valtrex 500mg nebenwirkungen generic viagra quality cialis india buy buying metformin tablets generic cialis name cialis online mastercard viagra 100mg coupons lexapro 10 mg fatigue buy lisinopril 2.5 meds supportonline lexapro 100mg clomid follicles nexium esomeprazole 10mg wellbutrin generic works beipackzettel viagra 100mg cialis 5 10mg viagra pfizer 100mg safelyorder viagra acquista levitra 5 mg celebrex generico zovirax 400 mg tablet propranolol 20 a 40 mg green cialis 20mg diflucan 200mg notice buy nexium toronto viagra 150mg dose levitra 100mg varmi discount generic propecia buspar 10mg generic wellbutrin works lisinopril generic recall clomid 150 mg kaufen zithromax 500 mg 7 days doxycycline 100mg eyes cheap viagra 50mg buy viagra 4.18 levitra 20mg filmtabletten spain kamagra online 20 mg generic levitra cialis 2.5 mg tablet cialis 2,5mg price augmentin goi 250mg metformin 1000 mg ratiopharm zoloft lek 100 mg 20 mg cialis canada mg of bactrim augmentin 500 mg compresse celebrex 500 mg prednisone taper 50 mg 150 mg phenergan cheaps cialis buy 40mg cialis kamagra jelly 50 mg prednisone 50 mg doxycycline rosacea 100 mg 25 mg viagra reviews buy cheap bactrim acheter xenical 120 mg buspar bipolar disorder buy doxycycline hanoi buy celebrex 200 mg generic zovirax forum best online kamagra cialis generic patent soft generic viagra cialis 5mg kur buy clomid nolvadex zoloft 50 mg benefits zovirax 800 mg online buy valtrex online levitra reichen 5 mg 20 mg cialis dose zoloft 0.25 mg augmentin 400 mg posologia cheap zovirax uk propecia o generico viagra cheap 100mg cheapest generic wellbutrin doxycycline 100mg mekophar lisinopril 20 mg erowid 60 mg lexapro overdose prednisone 50 mg price buy nexium twitter buy doxycycline 150 mg doxycycline 250 mg tablets cytotec buy generisk cialis 20mg nexium 20mgphilippinescomapny price zovirax generic canada celebrex purchase online strattera anxiety disorder cialis buy johannesburg celebrex 200mg preis diflucan 200 mg online generic valtrex alcohol zithromax 500 mg n2 viagra 100 mgs cost viagra 1 cpr 50 mg cheap xenical 120 mg cheap kamagra ireland bactrim 40 mg 200 mg paypal order cialis prednisone 5mg pack augmentin zawiesina 457 mg lexapro vs generics generic cialis fast levitra 10mg sklep cialis soft buy buying viagra thailand augmentin pret 500 mg forum cialis generico lisinopril 10 mg wirkung doxycycline 100mg leptospirosis celebrex dosage 600 mg xenical 120 mg wirkung strattera 120 mg daily online cialis doctor actoplus metformin generic buy lasix 100 mg nexium 20 mg 14 tab cialis generico timo buy zoloft hydrochloride 1000 mg glucophage xr viagra to order zoloft 6.25mg buy cytotec generic cialis 10mg opinie kamagra 50 mg jelly strattera buy australia buy cipro mexico cialis 5mg buy levitra 2 5mg buy lisinopril china propecia 5 mg fiyat female viagra online the buy levitra prednisone 20 mg rash xenical 120 mg beipackzettel online viagra paypall cialis 5 mg everyday cost lexapro 20 mg cialis c800 buy women viagra 500mg viagra 100mg cut levitra 100mg price cialis soft cheap doxycycline 100mg pimples buying cialis omline injecting 80 mg cialis lisinopril 5 mg cost viagra generico contraindicaciones using 5mg cialis wellbutrin 300 mg adhd celebrex 200mg reviews l cheap viagra prednisone 20 mg dogs bijsluiter doxycycline 100mg zovirax tabs 800mg cialis 5mg info viagra 100mg testamonials legally buy viagra buying viagra europe propranolol non generic zovirax o generico viagra online philippine viagra 110 mg perfecthealthrx generic cialis average mg zoloft fda generic synthroid lexapro 5mg week 3 prednisone 10 mg online buy synthroid uk xenical 120 mg orlistat viagra online italy viagra going generic 2012 levitra 10 mg kaina doxycycline 100mg dosage ireland viagra online 522 mg wellbutrin nolvadex uk 10mg generic cialis 200 mg 150 mg zoloft celebrex 200mg kaina thuoc cytotec 20mg lexapro buy australia levitra 5mg purchase buy cialis pill nexium online generic cheapest authentic viagra buy xenical mumbai valtrex 3000 mg utilisation cialis 5mg buying online viagra jual levitra 10mg order flagyl er buy nolvadex india doxycycline 200mg cost priligy online celebrex medication generic about glucophage 500mg cheapest daily cialis cialis online arrested downside 10 mg prednisone generic viagra teva buy diflucan overnight cialis 20 mg dividere cialis dosage 100 mg avis cialis 5mg tadalafil cialis 5 mg cialis nombre generico take 2 10 mg levitra viagra online england valtrex 5 mg levitra 10mg effects prednisone 10mg alcohol zithromax buy chlamydia nolvadex 30 tabs 10mg levitra de 40 mg viagra online original priligy 30mg filmtabletten nexium 40 mg high confezione viagra 100 mg lexapro 20mg canada true lexapro generic buy xenical philippines nexium 20 mg precio propranolol 10 mg bid take cialis 20mg viagra 300mg gold cialis 20 mg fiyati clomid 2 9 100mg pregnant prospect augmentin 625mg xenical 120 mg posologie cialis 100mg order metformin 25 mg zovirax cheapest cheap viagra 150 kamagra 100mg fake propecia cheap purchase cialis 5 mg farmacia cytotec 200mg ivg viagra generico monterrey lisinopril 10 mg medicamento generic wellbutrin recall viagra pills generics france buy viagra order xenical 84 propecia 1mg nz valtrex 1000mg propecia generic online levitra online order cancun viagra generic augmentin purchase online cialis 5mg 14 szt cheapest branded viagra generic viagra 26 cialis generic augmentin 500mg order buspar online cialis online user 750 mg cipro diarrhea lexapro alternatives generics Levitra 20 mg order buy 1000 kamagra purchase viagra generic generic viagra injection starting generic lexapro 6 mg zoloft fluoxetine generic cymbalta buy diflucan powder order viagra cheap generic wellbutrin gluten buying levitra mexico propecia generic availability generic cialis mississauga viagra 25 mg kaufen antibiotico augmentin generico zovirax online price viagra prescription cheap generic viagra kopen lexapro dosage 200 mg 40 mg of cialis viagra buy 24 propranolol 20 mg bid doxycycline 400 mg tablet levitra 5 mg cost cialis buy quebec prednisone pill mg prednisone dosage 90 mg buy zoloft europe Online Levitra 20 mg cipro xr 500 mg doxycycline injections buy buying zithromax canada propranolol generic for cortancyl 5 mg prednisone getting valtrex online generic cialis 20 online diflucan 50mg capsules ordering viagra australia levitra 10 mg originale generico do clomid q online cialis generic lexapro medicine viagra gold generic doxycycline 100 mg orally viagra mg size 2.5 mg cialis daily glucophage 500 mg merck buy zovirax injection viagra 150 mg prices cheapest viagra jual propecia 1mg levitra online malaysia nexium 20 mg dosierung wellbutrin 450 mg xl kamagra jelly 5mg prednisone 15 mg taper order tetracycline online 50mg clomid pct india viagra buy metformin 1a 1000 mg teva hydrochlorothiazide 25mg xenical 120 mg benefits levitra online orders cheap propecia prescription viagra 50 mg dauer generic cialis erfahrung doxycycline 100mg regimen tetracycline cheap prednisone watson 20 mg clomid 25 mg pct doxycycline order online buy cialis 50mg buy zithromax 1000mg cialis online naruciti buying diflucan online viagra 100mg slicer buy diflucan capsules levitra generic 2.5 levitra generic 20 mg diflucan 150mg price generic viagra eu cialis generico prospecto lexapro 10 mg directions viagra generic durban viagra buy oonline cheap cialis fedex generic viagra 100 viagra 50 mg online online viagra arizona viagra 2011 online viagra brasil online doxycycline hyclate 75mg nexium 40 mg fass viagra generic viagra lisinopril 40 mg lupi celebrex 200 mg buy celebrex 100 mgs viagra bleeding disorders inderalici 10 mg propranolol buy levitra 10 pills cialis 5 mg or 20 genericall cialis cipro xr 750mg zithromax generic name nexium 20 mg kaufen cialis 2.5 mg canada levitra 20 mg n1 propranolol 20mg tablets cialis 20mg china doxycycline 100mg liquid zovirax 200mg 5ml precio cialis 10 mg augmentin 875 mg prices nolvadex online prescription viagra online toronto zithromax 1000 mg buy 60mg cialis clomid 50mg eod levitra 10mg tetracycline mail order levitra 10mg odt strattera 40mg dosis strattera 60 mg erowid lasix tablets 40mg viagra jelly 10 mg zithromax 500 mg dosis buy propecia answers viagra 10 mg cost cialis 2.5 mg cheep celebrex 200 mg posologia cialis tadora generic cialis 10 mg 2013 buy cialis 36 hr prednisone 20mg cancer nexium pediatrico 10 mg prednisone 50 mg po 50 mg viagra dosage nexium dose mg generico del cytotec zovirax 800 mg posologia